Argumentation as Rational Persuasion in Doctor-Patient Communication

Sara Rubinelli University of Lucerne

Abstract

ABSTRACTThis paper discusses the value of argumentation as an instrument for rational persuasion in doctor-patient (and general health professional–patient) communication. Argumentation can be used to influence those beliefs that form the basis of an individual's attitudes and decision-making process. In the medical context, argumentation can be used to legitimize the points of view of the doctor and the patient; to correct, add to, or modify a patient's set of beliefs; and to enhance the patient's central processing of the information that is foundational to his or her decision making. Overall, argumentation as a method of rational persuasion is an important communication tool for establishing conditions that are conducive to a patient's autonomous decision making. In this article, the issue of argumentation as rational persuasion is set within the context of several key topics in the area of health communication, namely, autonomy, the ways that doctors and patients interact and share information, and the effectiveness of information dissemination through traditional and new channels. Also, the difficulties of using argumentation effectively in this field are discussed, and areas of interest for future argumentation theory–based studies focused on enhancing its quality are highlighted.

Journal
Philosophy & Rhetoric
Published
2013-11-01
DOI
10.5325/philrhet.46.4.0550
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (65) · 6 in this index

  1. Akl, Elie A., Andrew D. Oxman, Jeph Herrin, Gunn E. Vist, et al. 2011. “Framing of Health Information Message…
  2. Bickenbach, Jerome. 2012. “Argumentation and Informed Consent in the Doctor-Patient Relationship.” Journal of…
  3. Benigeri, Mike, and Pierre Pluye. 2003. “Shortcomings of Health Information on the Internet.” Health Promotio…
  4. Argumentation
  5. Argumentation
Show all 65 →
  1. Caiata-Zufferey, Maria, and Peter J. Schulz. 2012. “Physicians' Communicative Strategies in Interacting with …
  2. Charles, Cathy, Amiran Gafni, and Tim Whelan. 1997. “Shared Decision-Making in the Physician-Patient Encounte…
  3. Charles, Cathy, Amiran Gafni, and Tim Whelan. 1999. “Decision-Making in the Physician-Patient Encounter: Revi…
  4. Chinn, Deborah. 2011 “Critical Health Literacy: A Review and Critical Analysis.” Social Science and Medicine …
  5. Collins, Sarah, Nicky Britten, Johanna Ruusuvuori, and Andrew Thompson. 2007. Patient Participation in Health…
  6. Covolo, Loredana, Sara Rubinelli, Grazia Orizio, and Umberto Gelatti. “Misuse (and Abuse?) of the Concept of …
  7. De Boni, Marco, Robert Hurling, and Windy Dryden. 2006. “Argumentation Through an Automated Rational-Emotive …
  8. Deber, Raisa B. 1996. “Shared Decision Making in the Real World.” Journal of General Internal Medicine 11 (6)…
  9. Edwards, Adrian, and Glyn Elwyn, eds. 2009. Shared Decision-Making in Health Care. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  10. Emanuel, Ezekiel J., and Linda L. Emanuel. 1992. “Four Models of the Physician-Patient Relationship.” Journal…
  11. Fishbein, Martin. 1967a. “Attitude and the Prediction of Behavior.” In Readings in Attitude Theory and Measur…
  12. Fishbein, Martin. 1967b. “A Behavior Theory Approach to the Relations Between Beliefs About an Object and the…
  13. Flynn, Kathryn E., Maureen A. Smith, and David Vanness. 2006. “A Typology of Preferences for Participation in…
  14. Fraenkel, Liana. 2011. “Uncertainty and Patients' Preferred Role in Decision Making.” Patient Education and C…
  15. Gafni, Amiran, Cathy Charles, and Tim Whelan. 1998. “The Physician-Patient Encounter: The Physician as a Perf…
  16. Gigerenzer, Gerd. 2007. Gut Feelings: Short Cuts to Better Decision Making. New York: Penguin.
  17. Grasso, Floriano, Alison Cawsey, and Ray Jones. 2000. “Dialectical Argumentation to Solve Conflicts in Advice…
  18. Groarke, Leo A., and Christopher W. Tindale. 2004 Good Reasoning Matters! A Constructive Approach to Critical…
  19. Gwyn, Richard, and Glyn Elwyn. 1999. “When Is a Shared Decision Not (Quite) a Shared Decision? Negotiating Pr…
  20. Heritage, John, and Douglas W. Maynard, eds. 2006. Communication in Medical Care: Interactions Between Primar…
  21. Jagsi, Reshma. 2007. “Conflicts of Interest and the Physician-Patient Relationship in the Era of Direct-to-Pa…
  22. Kahnemann, Daniel. 2011. Thinking Fast and Slow. Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin.
  23. Kennedy, George A. 1991. Aristotle on Rhetoric: A Theory of Civic Discourse. Oxford.
  24. Kreuter, Matthew W., David W. Farrell, Laura R. Olevitch, and Laura K. Brennan. 2000. Tailoring Health Messag…
  25. Argumentation
  26. Légaré, France, Glyn Elwyn, Martin Fishbein, Pierre Frémont, Dominick Frosch, et al. 2008. “Translating Share…
  27. Lorig, Kate M., and Halsted R. Holman. 2003. “Self-Management Education: History, Definition, Outcomes, and M…
  28. McMullan, Miriam. 2006. “Patients Using the Internet to Obtain Health Information: How This Affects the Patie…
  29. Neuhauser, Linda, and Gary L. Kreps. 2003. “Rethinking Communication in the eHealth Era.” Journal of Health P…
  30. Neuhauser, Linda, and Gary L. Kreps. 2010. “eHealth Communication and Behavior Change: Promise and Performanc…
  31. Nutbeam, Don. 2000. “Health Literacy as a Public Health Goal: A Challenge for Contemporary Health Education a…
  32. O'Keefe, Daniel J. 2002. Persuasion: Theory and Research. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
  33. Argumentation
  34. O'Keefe, Daniel J., and Sally Jackson. 1995. “Argument Quality and Persuasive Effects: A Review of Current Ap…
  35. Perelman, Chaïm, and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca. 1958. Traité de l'argumentation: La nouvelle rhétorique. Paris: …
  36. Petty, Richard E., and John T. Cacioppo. 1986. Communication and Persuasion: Central and Peripheral Routes to…
  37. Pilgram, Roosmaryn. 2012. “Reasonableness of a Doctor's Argument by Authority: A Pragma-Dialectical Analysis …
  38. Quill, Timothy E., and Howard Brody. 1996. “Physician Recommendations and Patient Autonomy: Finding a Balance…
  39. Roter, Debra L., and Judith A. Hall. 2006. Doctors Talking to Patients/Patients Talking to Doctors: Improving…
  40. Rubinelli, Sara. 2012. “Argomentazione, tecnologie e salute: Un'analisi critica dal campo della comunicazione…
  41. Rubinelli, Sara. 2013. “Rational Versus Unreasonable Persuasion in Doctor-Patient Communication: A Normative …
  42. Rubinelli, Sara, Nanone Labrie, and Daniel O'Keefe. 2013. “‘What Matters to Andrew’: The Problem of Premissar…
  43. Argumentation
  44. Rubinelli, Sara, Peter J. Schulz, and Kent Nakamoto. 2009. “Letting the Patient Be a Patient: Health Literacy…
  45. Rubinelli, Sara, and A. Francisca Snoeck-Henkemans, eds. 2012. “Argumentation and Health.” Special Issue, Jou…
  46. Rubinelli, Sara, Renske Wierda, Nanon Labrie, and Daniel O'Keefe. 2011. “The Problem of Premissary Relevance.…
  47. Rubinelli, Sara, and Claudia Zanini. 2012. “Teaching Argumentation Theory to Doctors: Why and What.” Journal …
  48. Schneider, Carl E. 1998. The Practice of Autonomy: Patients, Doctors, and Medical Decisions. Oxford: Oxford U…
  49. Schulz, Peter J., and Kent Nakamoto. 2011. “‘Bad’ Literacy, the Internet, and the Limits of Patient Empowerme…
  50. Argumentation
  51. Schulz, Peter J., and Bert Meuffels. 2012. “It is About Our Body, Our Own Body! On the Difficulty of Telling …
  52. Snoeck-Henkemans, A. Francisca, and Dima Mohammed. 2012. “Institutional Constraints on Strategic Maneuvering …
  53. Taylor, Keith. 2009. “Paternalism, Participation and Partnership—The Evolution of Patient Centeredness in the…
  54. Thaler, Richard H., and Cass R. Sunstein. 2009. Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happines…
  55. van Eemeren, Frans H. 2010. Strategic Maneuvering in Argumentative Discourse. Amsterdam: John Benjamins, 2010.
  56. van Eemeren, Frans H., Bart J. Garssen, and Bert Meuffels. 2009. Fallacies and Judgments of Reasonableness: E…
  57. van Eemeren, Frans H., and Rob Grootendorst. 2004. A Systematic Theory of Argumentation: The Pragma-Dialectic…
  58. van Eemeren, Frans H., Rob Grootendorst, Sally Jackson, and Scott Jacobs. 1993. Reconstructing Argumentative …
  59. Wirtz, Veronica, Alan Cribb, and Nick Barber. 2006. “Patient-Doctor Decision-Making About Treatment Within th…
  60. Zanini, Claudia, and Sara Rubinelli. 2012. “Using Argumentation Theory to Identify the Challenges of Shared D…