Abstract

AbstractIn 2009, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights ruled in González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico that Mexico and the state of Chihuahua were responsible for cultivating conditions of feminicidio and pervasive structural violence against women. Drawing on theories of justice, agency, and responsibility, this essay examines the court’s legal decision to understand the power of rhetoric in creating the conditions for justice in the face of state-complicit structural violence. The court crafted a series of definitional, commemorative, and deliberative stipulations that Mexico had to recognize and implement to do justice to past and future victims of feminicidio. The Inter-American Court does important definitional work toward naming gender violence as structural violence, yet the court limits possibilities for justice in two important ways. The court figures Mexico as responsible and uses that frame to suggest that the state is the primary agent responsible for ensuring justice. While this is a common equation of agency and responsibility in legal cases, in matter of state-complicit structural violence, such configurations end up foreclosing the possibility of justice and augmenting the powers of the state.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2021-09-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.24.3.0413
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (103)

  1. 1. Before claimants can make a petition to an international court, they must demonstrate that they have exhau…
  2. 2. For a great description of the relationship between the Inter-American Commission and Inter-American Court…
  3. 3. Marouf Hasian Jr., "Critical Legal Rhetorics: The Theory and Practice of Law in a Postmodern World," South…
  4. and John Louis Lucaites, "Between Rhetoric and 'the Law': Power, Legitimacy, and Social Change," Quarterly Jo…
  5. 4. Justice was a foundational concept in Plato’s theorizing of the purpose of rhetoric. Aristotle and other c…
Show all 103 →
  1. 5. Kathleen M. de Onís, “Lost in Translation: Challenging (White, Monolingual Feminism’s) <Choice> with…
  2. 6. Chaïm Perelman, Justice, Law, and Argument: Essays on Moral and Legal Reasoning (New York: Springer), 1.
  3. 7. Kent A. Ono and John M. Sloop, “Commitment to Telos—A Sustained Critical Rhetoric,” Communication Monograp…
  4. 8. James Boyd White, “Law as Rhetoric, Rhetoric as Law: The Arts of Cultural and Communal Life,” University o…
  5. 9. Peter Odell Campbell, “The Procedural Queer: Substantive Due Process, Lawrence v. Texas, and Queer Rhetori…
  6. 10. Iris Marion Young, Responsbility for Justice (Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2011), 91–92.
  7. 11. Louis Bickford, “Transitional Justice,” in The Encyclopedia of Genocide and Crimes against Humanity, ed. …
  8. 12. Patricia Lundy and Mark McGovern, “Whose Justice? Rethinking Transitional Justice from the Bottom Up,” Jo…
  9. 13. Erik Doxtader, “Making Rhetorical History in a Time of Transition: The Occasion, Constitution, and Repres…
  10. 14. Doxtader, “Making Rhetorical History,” 226.
  11. 15. Ellen L. Lutz and Kathryn Sikkink, “International Human Rights Law and Practice in Latin America,” Intern…
  12. 16. Marouf Hasian Jr., Colonial Legacies in Postcolonial Contexts: A Critical Rhetorical Examination of Legal…
  13. 17. Rebecca Dingo and J. Blake Scott, The Megarhetorics of Global Development (Pittsburgh, PA: University of …
  14. 18. Doris E. Buss, "Rethinking 'Rape as a Weapon of War,'" Feminist Legal Studies 17 (2009): 145-63
  15. Stacey Alicia Maalej Rusnak, "Reconciling Three Countries' Current Laws with Human Rights In the Face of Inte…
  16. 19. Sara L. McKinnon, Gendered Asylum: Race and Violence in U.S. Law and Politics (Urbana: University of Illi…
  17. 20. Sara L. McKinnon, "Positioned in/by the State: Incorporation, Exclusion, and Appropriation of Women's Gen…
  18. and Caroline Joan (Kay) S. Picart, "Rhetorically Reconfiguring Victimhood and Agency: The Violence against Wo…
  19. 21. Karlyn Kohrs Campbell, “Agency: Promiscuous and Protean,” Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies 2 (…
  20. 22. Diane Davis, Inessential Solidarity: Rhetoric and Foreigner Relations (Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pitt…
  21. 23. Davis, Inessential Solidarity, 112.
  22. 24. Young, Responsbility for Justice, 92.
  23. 25. Young, Responsbility for Justice, 104.
  24. 26. For a detailed analysis of the relationship between NAFTA and the rise in feminicidios in Ciudad Júarez, …
  25. 27. Elvia R. Arriola, “Accountability for Murder in the Maquiladoras: Linking Corporate Indifference to Gende…
  26. 28. Alicia Gaspar de Alba, “Poor Brown Female: The Miller’s Compensation for ‘Free’ Trade,” in Making a Killi…
  27. 29. Carla Freeman, High Tech and High Heels in the Global Economy: Women, Work and the Pink-Collar Identities…
  28. 30. Jessica Livingston, “Murder in Juarez: Gender, Sexual Violence, and the Global Assembly Line,” Frontiers …
  29. 31. Melissa W Wright, “Feminine Villians, Masculine Heroes, and Reproduction of Ciudad Juárez,” Social Text 1…
  30. 32. Adrian X. Esparza, Brigitte S. Waldorf, and Javier Chavez, “Localized Effects of Globalization: The Case …
  31. 33. Gaspar de Alba, “Poor Brown Female,” 64.
  32. 34. Gaspar de Alba, “Poor Brown Female,” 64.
  33. 35. Livingston, “Murder in Juarez,” 59–76; and Melissa W Wright, “Necropolitics, Narcopolitics, and Femicide:…
  34. 36. Mercedes Olivera, “Violencia Femicida: Violence against Women and Mexico’s Structural Crisis,” Latin Amer…
  35. 37. Diane E. H. Russell, “The Origin and Importance of the Term Femicide,” December 2011, http://www.dianarus…
  36. 38. Olivera, “Violencia Femicida,” 105.
  37. 39. Olivera, “Violencia Femicida,” 106.
  38. 40. Michelle A. Holling, “‘So My Name Is Alma, and I Am the Sister Of…‘ A Feminicidio Testimonio of Violence …
  39. 41. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 113 (2009).
  40. 42. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 98.
  41. 43. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 99.
  42. 44. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 99.
  43. 45. Kristin Bumiller, In an Abusive State: How Neoliberalism Appropriated the Feminist Movement against Sexua…
  44. 46. Of course, it is important to recognize that a “culture of violence” discourse is used frequently in U.S.…
  45. 47. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 71.
  46. 48. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 72.
  47. 49. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 109.
  48. 50. Ruth Rubio-Marín and Clara Sandoval, “Engendering the Reparations Jurisprudence of the Inter-American Cou…
  49. 51. Each of the families were awarded approximately $15,000 U.S. dollars. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v.…
  50. 52. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 113.
  51. 53. Carole Blair, Marsha S. Jeppeson, and Enrico Pucci Jr., "Public Memoralizing in Postmodernity: The Vietna…
  52. and A. Cheree Carlson and John E. Hocking, "Strategies of Redemption at the Vietnam Veterans' Memorial," West…
  53. 54. Lisa M. Corrigan, “After the Revolution: Cuban Women’s Healing Practices and Knowledge Spaces,” Advances …
  54. 55. Alexandra Huneeus, “Rejecting the Inter-American Court: Judicialization, National Courts and Regional Hum…
  55. 56. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 115.
  56. 57. Justice was doomed almost before the implementation of the remediations began. The families did receive t…
  57. 58. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 114.
  58. 59. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 114.
  59. 60. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 113.
  60. 61. Davis, Inessential Solidarity, 112.
  61. 62. Bettinger-Lopez, “The Challenge,” 329.
  62. 63. “Víctimas Abuchean a Autoridades Durante Inauguración Contra Feminicidios En Cd. Juárez,” November 8, 201…
  63. 64. Rubén Villalpando, “El Estado Mexicano Pide Perdón Por Los Feminicidios; Acto De Simulación: Deudos,” La …
  64. 65. “Inauguran Memorial Dedicado a Las Muertas De Juárez,” El Excelsior, November 7, 2011.
  65. 66. “Inauguran Memorial.”
  66. 67. Gladis Torres Ruiz, “Memorial Del Feminicidio, Reflejo De La Impunidad En Juárez,” Cimacnoticias, August …
  67. 68. Blair, Jeppeson, and Pucci Jr., “Public Memoralizing in Postmodernity,” 263.
  68. 69. As cited in Stephen Howard Browne, “Remembering Crispus Attucks: Race, Rhetoric, and the Politics of Comm…
  69. 70. Blair, Jeppeson, and Pucci Jr., “Public Memoralizing in Postmodernity.”
  70. 71. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 113.
  71. 72. Mauricio Rodíguez, “Víctimas Abuchean a Autoridades Por Inauguración De Monumento En Juárez,” Proceso, No…
  72. 73. Carole Blair and Neil Michel, “The AIDS Memorial Quilt and the Contemporary Culture of Public Commemorati…
  73. 74. Blair and Michel, “The AIDS Memorial Quilt,” 602.
  74. 75. Blair and Michel, “The AIDS Memorial Quilt,” 605.
  75. 76. Lozano, Not One More!
  76. 77. Lozano, Not One More!
  77. 78. Lozano, Not One More!, 98.
  78. 79. Lozano, Not One More!, 104.
  79. 80. John B. Hatch, “Beyond Apologia: Racial Reconciliation and Apologies for Slavery,” Western Journal of Com…
  80. 81. Hatch, “Beyond Apologia,” 190.
  81. 82. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 110.
  82. 83. Bettinger-Lopez, “The Challenge,” 323.
  83. 84. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 113.
  84. 85. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 113.
  85. 86. Bettinger-Lopez, “The Challenge,” 325.
  86. 87. González et al. (“Cotton Field”) v. Mexico, 116.
  87. 88. Violencia feminicida is “la forma extrema de violencia de género contra las mujeres producto de la violac…
  88. 89. Secretaría de Gobernación, INMUJERES, and ONU Mujeres, “Violencia Feminicida,” 7.
  89. 90. Secretaría de Gobernación, IINMUJERES, and ONU Mujeres, “Violencia Feminicida,” 10.
  90. 91. Kirk Semple and Paulina Villegas, “The Grisly Deaths of a Woman and a Girl Shock Mexico and Test Its Pres…
  91. 92. “Cada Dos Horas y Media, Una Mujer Es Asesinada En México,” Aristegui Noticias, July 6, 2019.
  92. 93. “Las Dramáticas Cifras De Los Feminicidios En México,” RT, February 19, 2019; and Alejandra Gudiño, “En C…
  93. 94. “Feminicidios En México Crecen 111% En Los Últimos 4 Años,” El Financiero, February 12, 2019.
  94. 95. Angeles Pillado, “9 De Cada 10 Mujeres Han Sido Víctimas De Violencia Sexual En El Metro,” SDP Noticias, …
  95. 96. Cynthia Enloe, Bananas, Beaches, and Bases: Making Feminist Sense of International Politics (Berkeley: Un…
  96. 97. Margo Okazawa-Rey, “Warring on Women: Understanding Complex Inequalities of Gender, Race, Class, and Nati…
  97. 98. Hatch, “Beyond Apologia.”
  98. 99. Hernández and Upton, Challenging Reproductive Control, 90.