Abstract

AbstractIn 1925, Herbert Wichelns published The Literary Criticism of Oratory. By many accounts, the essay would become the founding document of the academic study of rhetoric and public address. However, in that same year, historian Carter G. Woodson published Negro Orators and Their Orations, which focused on the study of the African American oratorical tradition. In this essay, by way of speculative history and using my sanctified imagination, I wonder what an alternative or speculative history would look like if we can conceive Woodson as challenging the dominant (exclusively white) notions of public address and rhetorical praxis. By paying particular attention to Woodson’s introduction in Negro Orators and Their Orations, I submit that not only would we have been introduced to the richness and power of the African American public address tradition earlier but, more importantly, who we start to see as scholars and what we call scholarship would be different as well.I examine this by first, offering an examination of Woodson’s text, paying close attention to the introduction, where Woodson develops his theory of oratory. Second, I examine the African American rhetoric and public address scholarship between 1925 and 1960. Finally, I offer a speculative history of what could have been and what we can still do if we would include some of these voices and their scholarship in the public address canon.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2021-03-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.24.1-2.0015
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (1)

  1. Rhetoric Society Quarterly

References (127)

  1. 1. Herbert A. Wichelns, “The Literary Criticism of Oratory in Readings in Rhetorical Criticism,” in Readings …
  2. 2. Amos Kiewe, “Herbert A. Wichelns at the Discipline’s Centennial Mark: Re-Reading a Prospectus for Rhetoric…
  3. 3. Kiewe, “Herbert A. Wichelns,” 50.
  4. 4. Donald Bryant, quoted in Walter R. Fisher, “Genre: Concepts and Applications in Rhetorical Criticism,” Wes…
  5. 5. Carter G. Woodson, Negro Orators and Their Orations (New York: Russell and Russell, 1925; repr. 1969).
Show all 127 →
  1. 6. Woodson, Negro Orators, foreword.
  2. 7. Wilda C. Gafney, Womanish Midrash: A Reintroduction to the Women of the Torah and the Throne (Louisville, …
  3. 8. Joseph Dewey, “Carter G. Woodson,” in Salem Press Biographical Encyclopedia (Hackensack, N.J.: Salem Press…
  4. 9. Dewey, “Carter G. Woodson.”
  5. 10. Dewey, “Carter G. Woodson.”
  6. 11. Dewey, “Carter G. Woodson.”
  7. 12. Woodson, Negro Orators, foreword.
  8. 13. W. H. Jernagin, Adah M. Waters, and Lena Trent Gordon, “Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Associat…
  9. 14. Shirley Wilson Logan, Liberating Language: Sites of Rhetorical Education in Nineteenth-Century Black Amer…
  10. 15. “Review, Negro Orators and Their Orations by Carter G. Woodson,” Journal of Negro History 10 (1925): 780.
  11. 16. John Hope Franklin, “The Place of Carter G. Woodson in American Historiography,” Negro History Bulletin 1…
  12. 17. Lyndrey A. Niles, “Negro Orators and Their Orations,” Speech Teacher 19 (1970): 149.
  13. 18. Russell H. Wagner, “Negro Orators and Their Orations (Review),” Quarterly Journal of Speech Education 12,…
  14. 19. Wagner, “Negro Orators and Their Orations (Review).”
  15. 20. Alice Moore Dunbar, Masterpieces of Negro Eloquence: The Best Speeches Delivered by the Negro from the Da…
  16. 21. Alice Moore Dunbar, The Dunbar Speaker and Entertainer (Naperville, IL: J. L. Nichols, 1920).
  17. 22. Anna Julia Cooper, A Voice from the South: By a Black Woman of the South (Xenia, OH: Aldine Printing Hous…
  18. 23. Brittney C. Cooper. Beyond Respectability: The Intellectual Thought of Race Women (Urbana: University of …
  19. 24. Quoted in Pero Gaglo Dagbovie, “Black Women, Carter G. Woodson, and the Association for the Study of Negr…
  20. 25. Dagbovie, “Black Women,” 21-41.
  21. 26. Kirt Wilson, “The Racial Contexts of Public Address: Interpreting Violence During the Reconstruction Era,…
  22. 27. Wilson, “The Racial Contexts of Public Address,” 208.
  23. 28. Wilson, “The Racial Contexts of Public Address,” 208.
  24. 29. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 7-8.
  25. 30. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 8.
  26. 31. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 1.
  27. 32. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 1-2.
  28. 33. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 2.
  29. 34. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 2-3.
  30. 35. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 4.
  31. 36. Edwin Du Bois Shurter, The Rhetoric of Oratory (New York: Macmillan, 1909), 3.
  32. 37. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 5.
  33. 38. Molefi Kete Asante, “The Classical African Concept of Maat and Human Communication,” in Black/Africana Co…
  34. 39. Asante, “The Classical African Concept,” 16.
  35. 40. Asante, “The Classical African Concept,” 22.
  36. 41. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 5-6.
  37. 42. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 6.
  38. 43. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 6.
  39. 44. For the study of Nommo, see Arthur L. Smith (Molefi Asante), “Markings of an African Concept,” Today’s Sp…
  40. 45. Howard, “Manifestations of Nommo,” 739.
  41. 46. Howard, “Manifestations of Nommo,” 739.
  42. 47. Howard, “Manifestations of Nommo,” 739.
  43. 48. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 10.
  44. 49. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 10.
  45. 50. See J. W. Hood, The Negro in the Christian Pulpit (Raleigh, NC: Edwards, Broughton and Co., 1884)
  46. L. H. Holsey, Autobiography, Sermons, Addresses, and Essays of Bishop L. H. Holsey (Atlanta, GA: Franklin Pri…
  47. E. W. Brawley, The Negro Baptist Pulpit (Philadelphia, PA: American Baptist Publication Society, 1890).
  48. 51. William E. Hatcher, John Jasper: The Unmatched Negro Preacher and Philosopher (New York: Flemming H. Reve…
  49. 52. J. M. O'Neill, "Review: The Work of Preaching," Quarterly Journal of Speech Education 4 (1918): 335-36
  50. H. A. Wichelns, "Review: Art of Preaching," Quarterly Journal of Speech Education 10 (1924): 401-2.
  51. 53. For example, see Norman Matthis, "Robert South," Quarterly Journal of Speech 15 (1929): 537-60
  52. Lionel Croker, "The Rhetorical Influence of Henry Ward Beecher," Quarterly Journal of Speech 18 (1932): 82-88
  53. Harold King, "George Whitefield: Dramatic Evangelist," Quarterly Journal of Speech 19 (1933): 165-76
  54. Lionel Crocker, "Charles Haddon Spurgeon's Theory of Preaching," Quarterly Journal of Speech 25 (1939): 214-25
  55. Edward J. Lantz, "A Survey of Modern Preaching," Quarterly Journal of Speech 29 (1943): 167-73
  56. Elton Abernathy, "Trends in American Homiletic Theory Since 1860," Speech Monographs 10 (1943): 68-75
  57. Eugene E. White, "The Preaching of George Whitefield during the Great Awakening in America," Speech Monograph…
  58. 54. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 11.
  59. 55. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 1.
  60. 56. Woodson, Negro Orators, introduction, 12.
  61. 57. For more on Maat, see Ronald L. Jackson and Elaine B. Richardson, eds., Understanding African American Rh…
  62. 58. Carter G. Woodson, The Mind of the Negro as Reflected in Letters Written during the Crisis, 1800-1860 (Wa…
  63. 59. Woodson, The Mind of the Negro, v.
  64. 60. John Hope Franklin, “The Place of Carter G. Woodson in American Historiography,” Negro History Bulletin 1…
  65. 61. Reverdy Ransom, The Spirit of Freedom and Justice: Orations and Speeches (Nashville, TN: AME Sunday Schoo…
  66. 62. Alain Locke, “Review: The Spirit of Freedom and Justice: Orations and Speeches,” Journal of Negro History…
  67. 63. Nancy Cunard, ed., Negro: An Anthology (London: Wishart and Co., 1934).
  68. 64. Zora Neale Hurston, “Characteristics of Negro Expression,” in Sweat, by Zora Neale Hurston, ed. Cheryl A.…
  69. 65. Hurston, “Characteristics of Negro Expression,” 57.
  70. 66. Sterling A. Brown, Arthur P. Davis, and Ulysses Lee, The Negro Caravan (New York: Dryden Press, 1941).
  71. 67. Brown, et al., The Negro Caravan, 2.
  72. 68. Carter G. Woodson, ed., The Works of Francis J. Grimke (Washington, D.C.: Associated Publishers, 1942).
  73. 69. Woodson, The Works of Francis J. Grimke, vii.
  74. 70. Journal of Negro Education, “Mission and History,” 2021, http://www.journalnegroed.org/generalinfo.html.
  75. 71. Dorothy B. Porter, “The Organized Educational Activities of Negro Literary Societies, 1828-1846,” Journal…
  76. 72. John W. Parker, “Current Debate Practices in Thirty Negro Colleges,” Journal of Negro Education 9 (1940):…
  77. 73. John W. Parker, “The Status of Debate in the Negro College,” Journal of Negro Education 24 (1955): 146-53.
  78. 74. Nancy Bullock Woolridge, “The Negro Preacher in American Fiction before 1900” (PhD diss., University of C…
  79. 75. Nancy Bullock Woolridge, “The Slave Preacher—Portrait of a Leader,” Journal of Negro Education 14 (1945):…
  80. 76. Lillian W. Voorhees, “A Program of Speech Education for Talladega College,” Journal of Negro Education 15…
  81. 77. “Survey of American Negro Oratory,” Negro History Bulletin 7 (1944): 203-14.
  82. 78. “Survey,” 203.
  83. 79. “Survey,” 203.
  84. 80. Howard H. Bell, “National Negro Conventions of the Middle 1840s: Moral Suasion vs. Political Action,” Jou…
  85. 81. Fred L. Ryon, “William Allen, Negro Evangelist of the Society of Friends,” Bulletin of Friends’ Historica…
  86. 82. Lillian W. Voorhees, “Speech in the Negro College,” Southern Speech Journal 6 (1941): 51-56.
  87. 83. Bert Bradley, “Negro Speakers in Congress: 1869-1875,” Southern Speech Journal 18 (1953): 216-25.
  88. 84. Marcus H. Boulware, “Speech Training in Negro Colleges,” Quarterly Journal of Speech 33 (1947): 509-14.
  89. 85. William Holmes Honan, “John Jasper and the Sermon That Moved the Sun,” Speech Monographs 23 (1956): 255-61.
  90. 86. Winifred DeWitt Bennett, “A Survey of American Negro Oratory: 1619-1900” (master’s thesis, Columbia Colle…
  91. 87. Bennett, “A Survey,” chapter 6, 15-16.
  92. 88. Bennett, “A Survey,” chapter 6, 14-15.
  93. 89. Doris G. Yoakam, “An Historical Study of the Public Speaking Activity of Women in America from 1828 to 18…
  94. 90. Yoakam, “An Historical Study,” 480.
  95. 91. Yoakam, “An Historical Study,” 507.
  96. 92. Doris G. Yoakam, “Pioneer Women Orators of America,” Quarterly Journal of Speech 23 (1937): 251-59.
  97. 93. Doris G. Yoakam, “Women’s Introduction to the American Platform,” in A History and Criticism of Public Ad…
  98. 94. William Harrison Pipes, “Sources of Booker T. Washington’s Effectiveness as a Public Speaker” (master’s t…
  99. 95. William Harrison Pipes, “Old-Time Negro Preaching: An Interpretative Study,” Quarterly Journal of Speech …
  100. 96. William Harrison Pipes, “An Interpretative Study of Old Time Negro Preaching” (PhD dissertation, Universi…
  101. 97. William Harrison Pipes, Say Amen Brother! Old Time Negro Preaching: A Study in American Frustration (New …
  102. 98. Robert Bao, “MSU’s Iconic Professors,” MSU Alumni, Michigan State University, https://alumni.msu.edu/stay…
  103. 99. Lowell Tillry Moseberry. “An Historical Study of Negro Oratory in the United States to 1915” (PhD diss., …
  104. 100. Moseberry, “An Historical Study,” iv.
  105. 101. Moseberry, “An Historical Study,” 147.
  106. 102. Moseberry, “An Historical Study,” 150.
  107. 103. Moseberry, “An Historical Study,” 247.
  108. 104. Jayme Coleman Williams, “A Rhetorical Analysis of Thurgood Marshall’s Arguments Before the Supreme Court…
  109. 105. Coleman Williams, “A Rhetorical Analysis,” 1.
  110. 106. Coleman Williams, “A Rhetorical Analysis,” 234.
  111. 107. Coleman Williams, “A Rhetorical Analysis,” 234.
  112. 108. Coleman Williams, “A Rhetorical Analysis,” 183.
  113. 109. Martin J. Medhurst, “The History of Public Address as an Academic Study,” in The Handbook of Rhetoric an…
  114. 110. William Norwood Brigance, “Whither Research,” Quarterly Journal of Speech 19 (1933): 556.
  115. 111. Brigance, “Whither Research,” 557.
  116. 112. Brigance, “Whither Research,” 559.
  117. 113. Wilson, “The Racial Contexts of Public Address,” 206.
  118. 114. Wilson, “The Racial Contexts of Public Address,” 206.
  119. 115. Wilson, “The Racial Contexts of Public Address,” 206.
  120. 116. Dallas C. Dickey, “Southern Oratory: A Field for Research,” Quarterly Journal of Speech 33 (1947): 462.
  121. 117. Dickey, “Southern Oratory,” 462.
  122. 118. Medhurst, “The History of Public Address,” 36.