Abstract

AbstractIn this essay, I offer a reception study of the varied responses to and interpretations of a burning church in the town of Eldoret following the 2007 Kenya presidential election. Specifically, I study responses from the U.S. and British media, U.S. officials, and Kenyan politicians. My analysis illuminates how different uses of the term “genocide” mobilize particular sensibilities about the relation between ethnicity and politics and demonstrates how the label of genocide constrains interpretations of violence. In the media and discourse of U.S. politicians, the identification or denial of genocide was made by setting ethnicity and politics as opposing explanatory factors of the violence. Discourses in Kenya, however, demonstrate that understanding the violence required understanding the intersection and permeability of these same categories. This analysis has important implications for understanding how conflicts are and are not named genocide. It demonstrates the importance of attending to the nuanced rhetoric of genocide and calls our attention to the contingent relationships among ethnicity, politics, and genocide.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2019-09-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.22.3.0421
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (115) · 1 in this index

  1. 1. Commission of Inquiry into Post Election Violence (CIPEV), Report of the Commission of Inquiry into Post E…
  2. 2. CIPEV, Report, 46.
  3. 3. See, for example, "Kenyans Burned to Death in Church," BBC News, January 1, 2008, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/…
  4. "Kenya 'Facing Humanitarian Disaster'," Guardian, January 2, 2008, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2008/jan…
  5. Gboyega Akinsanmi, "Fears of Genocide as Death Toll Hits 300," This Day (Lagos), January 3, 2008, https://all…
Show all 115 →
  1. Nick Wadhams, "A Massacre in a Kenyan Church," Time, January 1, 2008, http://content.time.com/time/world/arti…
  2. Mike Pflanz and Richard Holt, "Kenya on the Brink Amid 'Genocide' Claims," Telegraph, January 2, 2008, https:…
  3. and Thilo Thielke, "Chaos in Kenya: Tribal Massacres Echo Rwanda Genocide," Spiegel Online (Hamburg), January…
  4. 4. Genocide Watch, Genocide Watch: Kenya, October 3, 2013, http://www.genocidewatch.org/kenya.html.
  5. 5. See, for example, Xan Rice, "EU Observers Condemn Kenyan Election and Call for Investigation," Guardian, J…
  6. Jeffrey Gettleman, "Riots Batter Kenya as Rivals Declare Victory," New York Times, December 30, 2007, https:/…
  7. and Gwen Thompkins, "Protesters Dispute Kibaki Victory in Kenya Election," NPR: Morning Edition, December 31,…
  8. 6. UN General Assembly, Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, A/RES/260, Dece…
  9. 7. James Jasinski and Jennifer R. Mercieca, “Analyzing Constitutive Rhetorics: The Virginia and Kentucky Reso…
  10. 8. The news articles were gathered from LexisNexis and Factiva and included major newspapers and wire service…
  11. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  12. 10. Mailloux, “Re-Marking Slave Bodies,” 99.
  13. 11. Childers, “Transforming Violence,” 595.
  14. 12. On the dominance of the citizenship narrative, see Karma R. Chávez, “Beyond Inclusion: Rethinking Rhetori…
  15. 13. UN General Assembly, Convention.
  16. 14. William A. Schabas, Genocide in International Law: The Crime of Crimes, 2nd ed. (New York: Cambridge Univ…
  17. 15. Samantha Power, A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide (New York: Basic Books, 2002), 29.
  18. 16. Power, A Problem from Hell, 42.
  19. 17. Raphael Lemkin, Axis Rule in Occupied Europe: Laws of Occupation, Analysis of Government, Proposals for R…
  20. 18. For a thorough account of the origin of the term, see Schabas, Genocide in International Law, 17-58.
  21. 19. UN General Assembly, Convention, Article 2.
  22. 20. Power, A Problem from Hell, 514.
  23. 21. Power, A Problem from Hell, 508.
  24. 22. Kenneth Burke, “The Rhetoric of Hitler’s ‘Battle’,” in The Philosophy of Literary Form: Studies in Symbol…
  25. 23. Randall L. Bytwerk, “The Argument for Genocide in Nazi Propaganda,” Quarterly Journal of Speech 91 (2005)…
  26. 24. See, for example, Marouf Hasian, “Remembering and Forgetting the ‘Final Solution’: A Rhetorical Pilgrimag…
  27. 25. Tumolo, Just Remembering, 7-8.
  28. 26. For two notable examples, see Michael Barnett, Eyewitness to a Genocide: The United Nations and Rwanda (I…
  29. 27. Ben Voth, The Rhetoric of Genocide: Death as a Text (New York: Lexington Books, 2014). See also Ben Voth …
  30. 28. Voth, The Rhetoric of Genocide, 16.
  31. 29. John L. Comaroff and Jean Comaroff, Ethnicity, Inc. (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 2009), 38.
  32. 30. Wangari Maathai, The Challenge for Africa (London: Arrow Books, 2010), 185.
  33. 31. Peter O. Ndege, “Colonialism and Its Legacies in Kenya” (lecture, Fulbright-Hays Group Project Abroad Pro…
  34. 32. Timothy Parson, “Being Kikuyu in Meru: Challenging the Tribal Geography of Colonial Kenya,” Journal of Af…
  35. 33. Rok Ajulu, “Politicised Ethnicity, Competitive Politics and Conflict in Kenya: A Historical Perspective,”…
  36. 34. Elisha Stephen Atieno-Odhiambo describes how British colonists sharpened and fixed ethnic identities in K…
  37. 35. Donald L. Horowitz, Ethnic Groups in Conflict (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1985), 4.
  38. 36. For a detailed account of the Kalenjin, their political relevance, and their role in the postelection cri…
  39. 37. Maathai, Challenge for Africa, 185.
  40. 38. Jeffrey Steeves, “Beyond Democratic Consolidation in Kenya: Ethnicity, Leadership, and Unbounded Politics…
  41. 39. Koigi wa Wamwere, Towards Genocide in Kenya: The Curse of Negative Ethnicity (Nairobi, Kenya: Mvuke Publi…
  42. 40. Wamwere, Towards Genocide, 146.
  43. 41. Njuwa Maina and Nicolo Gnecchi, “Slum Dwellers Cower in Kenya’s ‘Unhappy Valley,‘” Reuters, January 3, 20…
  44. 42. Bruce Berman, Dickson Eyoh, and Will Kymlicka, eds., Ethnicity and Democracy in Africa (Athens: Ohio Univ…
  45. 43. Makau Mutua, Kenya’s Quest for Democracy: Taming Leviathan (Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2008), 21.
  46. 44. Human Rights Watch, Ballots to Bullets: Organized Political Violence and Kenya's Crisis of Governance (Ne…
  47. and Peter Kagwanja, "Courting Genocide: Populism, Ethno-Nationalism and the Informalisation of Violence in Ke…
  48. 45. Xan Rice, “President Heads for Humiliating Defeat as Kenyan Voters Throw Out the Old Guard,” Guardian, De…
  49. 46. The “knife-edge” metaphor appeared in numerous headlines and leads. For examples, see Xan Rice, “Kenya Ho…
  50. 47. Human Rights Watch, Ballots to Bullets, 35.
  51. 48. CIPEV, Report, 46.
  52. 49. CIPEV, Report, 46-47; and Kagwanja, “Courting Genocide,” 379.
  53. 50. CIPEV, Report, viii, 25.
  54. 51. Wadhams, “A Massacre in a Kenyan Church.” The reported number of victims varies among news reports and of…
  55. 52. Most accounts of the attack attributed it to the Kalenjin, although a few other minority ethnic groups, a…
  56. 53. Jeffrey Gettleman, “Kenya, Known for Its Stability, Topples into Post-Election Crisis,” New York Times, J…
  57. 54. Stephanie McCrummen, “Kenyans Killed Fleeing Violence; Dozens of Victims Trapped in Church That Mob Set A…
  58. 55. African Rights, Rwanda: Death, Despair, and Defiance, rev. ed. (London: African Rights, 1995), 865.
  59. 56. “Kenya ‘Facing Humanitarian Disaster’.”
  60. 57. Alistair Thomson, “Shades of Rwanda Skin-Deep, but Could Push Kenya Deal,” Reuters, January 3, 2008, http…
  61. 58. Tumolo, Just Remembering, 7.
  62. 59. Tami Hultman, “Africa: If It’s Africa, It Must Be a Tribe,” All Africa, December 1, 1990, https://allafri…
  63. 60. Maathai, Challenge for Africa, 185. It is for this reason that I use the term “ethnicity” or “ethnic conf…
  64. 61. Lowe, “Talking About ‘Tribe’,” 3.
  65. 62. Gettleman, “Riots Batter Kenya.”
  66. 63. Stephanie McCrummen, “Tribal Rage Tears at Diverse Kenyan City,” Washington Post, January 3, 2008, http:/…
  67. 64. Nicholas O. Kristof, “Machetes and Elections,” New York Times, February 21, 2008, https://www.nytimes.com…
  68. 65. Keith Somerville, “British Media Coverage of the Post-Election Violence in Kenya, 2007-08,” Journal of Ea…
  69. 66. Somerville, “British Media Coverage,” 530.
  70. 67. Maathai, Challenge for Africa, 185.
  71. 68. Thomson, “Shades of Rwanda Skin-Deep.”
  72. 69. Tumolo, Just Remembering, 20.
  73. 70. House Subcommittee on Africa and Global Health of the Committee on Foreign Affairs, The Political Crisis …
  74. 71. Senate Subcommittee on African Affairs, The Immediate and Underlying Causes and Consequences of Kenya’s F…
  75. 72. Stanley D. Ross, "The Rule of Law and Lawyers in Kenya," Journal of African Studies 30 (1992): 421. Many …
  76. and Makau Mutua, "Human Rights and State Despotism in Kenya: Institutional Problems," Africa Today 41 (1994):…
  77. 73. Power, A Problem from Hell, 504.
  78. 74. Jendayi Frazer, “Ethnic Cleansing in Kenya,” U.S. Department of State Archive, January 31, 2008, http://2…
  79. 75. Sean McCormack, “Daily Press Briefing,” U.S. Department of State Archive, January 30, 2008, http://2001-2…
  80. 76. According to Payne, “Dr. Jendayi Frazer’s statement on January 31st about ethnic cleansing played right i…
  81. 77. The UN has defined ethnic cleansing as “a purposeful policy designed by one ethnic or religious group to …
  82. 78. On the U.S. avoidance of the term “genocide” during the Rwandan genocide and failure to intervene, see Po…
  83. 79. George W. Bush, “The President’s News Conference with President Paul Kagame of Rwanda in Kigali,” Washing…
  84. 80. House Subcommittee, The Political Crisis in Kenya, 26.
  85. 81. On criticisms of the United States, and the international community more generally, for failing to interv…
  86. 82. House Subcommittee, The Political Crisis in Kenya, 7, 4.
  87. 83. House Subcommittee, The Political Crisis in Kenya, 7, 26.
  88. 84. House Subcommittee, The Political Crisis in Kenya, 108.
  89. 85. These proposed solutions appear throughout the Senate and House of Representatives hearings.
  90. 86. House Subcommittee, The Political Crisis in Kenya, 84. Emphasis added.
  91. 87. C. Bryson Hull and Andrew Cawthorne, “Kenya Government Denounces ‘Genocide’ as Toll Hits 300,” Reuters, J…
  92. 88. Kenya National Commission on Human Rights, On the Brink of the Precipice: A Human Rights Account of Kenya…
  93. 89. Reported in Peter Mwaura, “Has Crime of Genocide Been Committed?” Nation (Nairobi), January 12, 2008, htt…
  94. 90. Although Odinga’s official statement is unavailable, the accusation was reported in several news reports.…
  95. 91. “Chronicles of the Kenyan Genocide,” http://kenyangenocide.blogspot.com. See also Keith Somerville, Radio…
  96. 92. “Kibaki Names Cabinet,” East Africa Standard (Nairobi), January 8, 2008, https://allafrica.com/stories/20…
  97. 93. “Debate: Kenya Elections,” BBC News, January 9, 2008, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/hardtalk/7179…
  98. 94. Kagwanja, “Courting Genocide,” 366.
  99. 95. House Subcommittee, The Political Crisis in Kenya, 85.
  100. 96. Wamwere, Negative Ethnicity, 154-55.
  101. 97. House Subcommittee, The Political Crisis in Kenya, 73. Although the media’s use of the term “tribe” typic…
  102. 98. CIPEV, Report, viii.
  103. 99. Voth, The Rhetoric of Genocide, 10.
  104. 100. Power, A Problem from Hell, 506-7.
  105. 101. Childers, “Transforming Violence,” 575.
  106. 102. Nancy Fraser, “Rethinking the Public Sphere: A Contribution to the Critique of Actually Existing Democra…
  107. 103. John Lonsdale, “Moral and Political Argument in Kenya,” in Ethnicity and Democracy in Africa, 75.
  108. 104. Lonsdale, “Moral and Political Argument in Kenya,” 77.
  109. 105. Jacqueline M. Klopp, “Can Moral Ethnicity Trump Political Tribalism? The Struggle for Land and Nation in…
  110. 106. Chávez, “Beyond Inclusion,” 165.