Abstract

AbstractAmerican politics and horror have been linked since the birth of the United States. Within this genre, two frames of horror are common: the classic and the conflicted. The 2016 presidential campaign advertisements of Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton employed these horror frames in vastly different ways. Analysis of these ads as a part of an extended message to the American public reveals that Clinton primarily used a conflicted horror frame when attacking Trump, with some rare usage of the classic horror frame. Further, her campaign gave little in the way of audience efficacy through positive assessments of herself, specific policy proposals to defeat the monster, or calls for collective, mob action. Trump, however, almost exclusively used the classic horror frame to articulate threats to America. Even though this frame is more conducive to conventional demonization and fear mongering, Trump also included specific policy proposals, numerous positive assessments of himself, and a call for mob action by American voters to slay the monsters facing the country.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2019-06-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.22.2.0281
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (221)

  1. 1. See Robert L. Ivie and Oscar Giner, Hunt the Devil: A Demonology of U.S. War Culture (Tuscaloosa: Universi…
  2. 2. Ernest W. King and Franklin G. Mixon Jr., “Religiosity and the Political Economy of the Salem Witch Trials…
  3. 3. John Edgar Browning, “Classical Hollywood Horror,” in A Companion to the Horror Film, ed. Harry M. Benshof…
  4. 4. Lydia Saad, “Trump and Clinton Finish with Historically Poor Images, Gallup“ November 8, 2016, http://news…
  5. 5. Glenn W. Richardson Jr., “Pulp Politics: Popular Culture and Political Advertising,” Rhetoric & Public Aff…
Show all 221 →
  1. 6. Richardson, “Pulp Politics,” 611.
  2. 7. Richardson, “Pulp Politics,” 617.
  3. 8. Glenn W. Richardson Jr., Pulp Politics: How Political Advertising Tells the Stories of American Politics (…
  4. 9. Richardson, Pulp Politics, 39.
  5. 10. Richardson, Pulp Politics, 39.
  6. 11. See Caroline Joan (Kay) S. Picart and David A. Frank, Frames of Evil: The Holocaust as Horror in American…
  7. 12. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 6, 8.
  8. 13. Browning, “Classical Hollywood Horror,” 226.
  9. 14. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 6–7.
  10. 15. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 7.
  11. 16. Rosemary Jackson, Fantasy: The Literature of Subversion (London: Methuen, 1981), 179.
  12. 17. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 7.
  13. 18. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 7.
  14. 19. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 7.
  15. 20. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 9.
  16. 21. Steffen Hantke, “The Kingdom of the Unimaginable: The Construction of Social Space and the Fantasy of Pri…
  17. 22. Hantke, “The Kingdom of the Unimaginable,” 181.
  18. 23. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari, directed by Robert Wiene, 1920, http://www.horrortheque.com/public-domain-ho…
  19. 24. Browning, “Classical Hollywood Horror,” 228.
  20. 25. Kathleen Hall Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency: A History and Criticism of Presidential Campaign Advert…
  21. 26. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 446.
  22. 27. Theodore F. Sheckels, “Narrative Coherence and Antecedent Ethos in the Rhetoric of Attack Advertising: A …
  23. 28. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 449.
  24. 29. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 449.
  25. 30. Kenneth Burke, “Four Master Tropes,” Kenyon Review 3 (1941): 421.
  26. 31. Burke, “Four Master Tropes,” 426.
  27. 32. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 450.
  28. 33. Kathleen Hall Jamieson, Dirty Politics: Deception, Distraction, and Democracy (New York: Oxford Universit…
  29. 34. Jamieson, Dirty Politics, 17.
  30. 35. Aaron Smuts, “Cognitive and Philosophical Approaches to Horror,” in A Companion to the Horror Film, 5.
  31. 36. Smuts, “Cognitive and Philosophical,” 13–14.
  32. 37. Kim Witte, “Putting the Fear Back into Fear Appeals: The Extended Parallel Process Model,” Communication …
  33. 38. Witte, “Putting the Fear Back,” 345.
  34. 39. P. Sol Hart and Lauren Feldman, “Threat without Efficacy? Climate Change on U.S. Network News,” Science C…
  35. 40. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 447.
  36. 41. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 447.
  37. 42. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 447. Note, the use of “his” is present in the original quote and is n…
  38. 43. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 448.
  39. 44. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 448.
  40. 45. Museum of the Moving Image, The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–2016, http:…
  41. 46. “Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton’s Final Campaign Spending Revealed,” Guardian, December 9, 2016, https:…
  42. 47. Hillary for America, “Who We Are,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–2016…
  43. 48. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  44. 49. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  45. 50. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  46. 51. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  47. 52. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  48. 53. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  49. 54. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  50. 55. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  51. 56. Harry M. Benshoff, “Horror Before ‘The Horror Film,’” in A Companion to the Horror Film, 216.
  52. 57. Lotte H. Eisner, The Haunted Screen: Expressionism in the German Cinema and the Influence of Max Reinhard…
  53. 58. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  54. 59. Hillary for America, “Sacrifice,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–2016,…
  55. 60. Hillary for America, “Sacrifice.”
  56. 61. “Confidence in Institutions,” Gallup, n.d., https://news.gallup.com/poll/1597/confidence-institutions.aspx.
  57. 62. Hillary for America, “Sacrifice.”
  58. 63. Steffen Hantke, “Science Fiction and Horror in the 1950s,” in A Companion to the Horror Film, 259.
  59. 64. Hantke, “Science Fiction and Horror,” 262.
  60. 65. Hillary for America, “Low Opinion,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–201…
  61. 66. Hillary for America, “Low Opinion.”
  62. 67. Hillary for America, “Low Opinion.”
  63. 68. Hillary for America, “Low Opinion.”
  64. 69. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 448.
  65. 70. Hillary for America, “Mirrors,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–2016, S…
  66. 71. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  67. 72. Hillary for America, “Just One.”
  68. 73. Mark Jancovich, “Gender, Sexuality, and the Horror Film: Introduction,” in Horror, the Film Reader, ed. M…
  69. 74. Daniel Humphrey, “Gender and Sexuality Haunt the Horror Film,” in A Companion to the Horror Film, ed. Har…
  70. 75. Hillary for America, “Respected,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–2016,…
  71. 76. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 450.
  72. 77. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 450.
  73. 78. Hillary for America, “Respected.”
  74. 79. Hillary for America, “Captain Kahn,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–20…
  75. 80. Hillary for America, “Captain Kahn.”
  76. 81. Hillary for America, “Captain Kahn.”
  77. 82. Benshoff, “Horror Before ‘The Horror Film,’” 216.
  78. 83. Hillary for America, “We Are America,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–…
  79. 84. Hillary for America, “We Are America.”
  80. 85. Hillary for America, “We Are America.”
  81. 86. Hillary for America, “We Are America.”
  82. 87. Hillary for America, “We Are America.”
  83. 88. Hillary for America, “Unfit (D),” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–2016,…
  84. 89. Hillary for America, “Unfit (D).”
  85. 90. Hillary for America, “Unfit (D).”
  86. 91. Hillary for America, “Unfit (D).”
  87. 92. Hillary for America, “Unfit (D).”
  88. 93. Hillary for America, “Unfit (D).”
  89. 94. See Vivian Sobchack, “American Science Fiction Film: An Overview,” in A Companion to Science Fiction, ed.…
  90. 95. Hillary for America, “Just One,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–2016, …
  91. 96. Hillary for America, “Just One.”
  92. 97. Hillary for America, “Just One.”
  93. 98. Hillary for America, “Just One.”
  94. 99. Hillary for America, “Just One.”
  95. 100. Eisner, The Haunted Screen, 21.
  96. 101. See Jackson, Fantasy, 179; and Horace Walpole, The Castle of Otranto (Edinburgh: James Ballantune and Co…
  97. 102. Frankenstein, directed by James Whale (1931; Universal Studios Home Entertainment, 2016), DVD.
  98. 103. Hillary for America, “Daisy,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–2016, Oc…
  99. 104. Hillary for America, “Daisy.”
  100. 105. Democratic National Committee, “Peace Little Girl (Daisy),” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Camp…
  101. 106. Democratic National Committee, “Peace Little Girl.”
  102. 107. Theodore H. White, The Making of the President, 1964 (New York: Atheneum, 1965), 322.
  103. 108. Hillary for America, “Daisy.”
  104. 109. Hillary for America, “Daisy.”
  105. 110. The Curse of Frankenstein, directed by Terence Fisher, 1957, http://www.horrortheque.com/public-domain-h…
  106. 111. Bram Stoker’s Dracula, directed by Francis Ford Coppola (1992; Sony Pictures, 2017), DVD.
  107. 112. Hillary for America, “Role Models,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–20…
  108. 113. Hillary for America, “Role Models.”
  109. 114. Hillary for America, “Role Models.”
  110. 115. Julian Petley, “Horror and the Censors,” in A Companion to the Horror Film, 130.
  111. 116. Humphrey, “Gender and Sexuality Haunts the Horror Film,” 48.
  112. 117. Hillary for America, “Role Models.”
  113. 118. Humphrey, “Gender and Sexuality,” 48.
  114. 119. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 141.
  115. 120. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  116. 121. Bruce E. Gronbeck, “Negative Narratives in 1988 Presidential Campaign Ads,” Quarterly Journal of Speech …
  117. 122. Hillary for America, “Barbershop,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–201…
  118. 123. Hillary for America, “Barbershop.”
  119. 124. Hillary for America, “Barbershop.”
  120. 125. Hart and Feldman, “Threat without Efficacy,” 341.
  121. 126. Hillary for America, “27 Million Strong,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1…
  122. 127. Hillary for America, “27 Million Strong.”
  123. 128. Hillary for America, “27 Million Strong.”
  124. 129. Hillary for America, “Tomorrow,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952–2016,…
  125. 130. Hillary for America, “Tomorrow.”
  126. 131. Hillary for America, “Tomorrow.”
  127. 132. Hillary for America, “Tomorrow.”
  128. 133. Hillary for America, “Tomorrow.”
  129. 134. Pamela Engel, “How Trump Came Up with His Slogan ‘Make America Great Again,’” Business Insider, January …
  130. 135. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 7.
  131. 136. Donald J. Trump for President, “Two Americas Immigration,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campa…
  132. 137. Donald J. Trump for President, “Two Americas Immigration.”
  133. 138. Donald J. Trump for President, “Two Americas Immigration.”
  134. 139. Donald J. Trump for President, “Two Americas Immigration.”
  135. 140. Donald J. Trump for President, “Two Americas Immigration.”
  136. 141. Donald J. Trump for President, “Two Americas Immigration.”
  137. 142. Donald J. Trump for President, “Two Americas Immigration.”
  138. 143. Donald J. Trump for President, “Two Americas Immigration.”
  139. 144. Richardson, Pulp Politics, 39.
  140. 145. J. David Cisneros, “Contaminated Communities: The Metaphor of ‘Immigrant as Pollutant’ in Media Represen…
  141. 146. Cisneros, “Contaminated Communities,” 588.
  142. 147. Donald J. Trump for President, “Two Americas Immigration.”
  143. 148. Frankenstein, Whale.
  144. 149. Anne Demo, “Sovereignty Discourse and Contemporary Immigration Politics,” Quarterly Journal of Speech 91…
  145. 150. Witte, “Putting the Fear Back,” 345.
  146. 151. Donald J. Trump for President, “Laura,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 195…
  147. 152. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 450.
  148. 153. Donald J. Trump for President, “Laura.”
  149. 154. Donald J. Trump for President, “Laura.”
  150. 155. Donald J. Trump for President, “Laura.”
  151. 156. Cat People, directed by Jacques Tourneur (1942; Turner Home Entertainment, 2005), DVD.
  152. 157. Ivan Butler, Horror in the Cinema (New York: Paperback Library, 1971), 76.
  153. 158. Richardson, Pulp Politics, 39.
  154. 159. Donald J. Trump for President, “Laura.”
  155. 160. Frankenstein, Whale.
  156. 161. Donald J. Trump for President, “Choice,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 19…
  157. 162. Donald J. Trump for President, “Choice.”
  158. 163. Donald J. Trump for President, “Choice.”
  159. 164. Hillary for America, “Who We Are.”
  160. 165. Benshoff, “Horror Before ‘The Horror Film,’” 216.
  161. 166. Donald J. Trump for President, “Choice.”
  162. 167. Trump, “Donald Trump’s Argument for America,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercia…
  163. 168. Trump, “Donald Trump’s Argument for America.”
  164. 169. Frankenstein, Whale.
  165. 170. The Wolf Man, directed by George Waggner (1941; Universal Studios Home Entertainment, 2016), DVD.
  166. 171. Donald J. Trump for America, “Two Americas: Economy,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign C…
  167. 172. Jackson, Fantasy, 179.
  168. 173. Donald J. Trump for America, “Two Americas: Economy.”
  169. 174. Donald J. Trump for America, “Two Americas: Economy.”
  170. 175. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 449.
  171. 176. Donald J. Trump for America, “Two Americas: Economy.”
  172. 177. Donald J. Trump for America, “Two Americas: Economy.”
  173. 178. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 449.
  174. 179. Donald J. Trump for America, “Choice.”
  175. 180. Donald J. Trump for America, “Choice.”
  176. 181. Donald J. Trump for America, “Choice.”
  177. 182. Trump, “Donald Trump’s Argument for America.”
  178. 183. Trump, “Donald Trump’s Argument for America.”
  179. 184. Trump, “Donald Trump’s Argument for America.”
  180. 185. The Birds, directed by Alfred Hitchcock (1963; Universal Studios Home Entertainment, 2014), DVD.
  181. 186. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 7.
  182. 187. Trump, “Donald Trump’s Argument for America.”
  183. 188. See Dracula, directed by Tod Browning, 1931, http://www.horrortheque.com/public-domain-horror-movies/dracula/.
  184. 189. Trump, “Donald Trump’s Argument for America.”
  185. 190. Donald J. Trump for President, “Deplorables,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercia…
  186. 191. Donald J. Trump for President, “Deplorables.”
  187. 192. Donald J. Trump for President, “Deplorables.”
  188. 193. Donald J. Trump for President, “Predators,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials…
  189. 194. Donald J. Trump for President, “Predators.”
  190. 195. Donald J. Trump for President, “Predators.”
  191. 196. See Dracula, Browning; and The Wolf Man, Waggner.
  192. 197. Donald J. Trump for President, “Unfit (R),” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials…
  193. 198. Donald J. Trump for President, “Unfit (R).”
  194. 199. Donald J. Trump for President, “Unfit (R).”
  195. 200. Jackson, Fantasy, 179.
  196. 201. See Dracula, Browning.
  197. 202. The Mummy, directed by Karl Freund (1932; Universal Studios Home Entertainment, 2016), DVD.
  198. 203. See L. L. Wynn, “Shape Shifting Lizard People, Israelite Slaves, and Other Theories of Pyramid Building,…
  199. 204. Trump, “Donald Trump’s Argument for America.”
  200. 205. Trump, “Donald Trump’s Argument for America.”
  201. 206. Donald J. Trump for President, “Movement,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials …
  202. 207. Donald J. Trump for President, “Movement.”
  203. 208. Donald J. Trump for President, “Motherhood,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercial…
  204. 209. Donald J. Trump for President, “Motherhood.”
  205. 210. Donald J. Trump for President, “United,” The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 19…
  206. 211. Donald J. Trump for President, “United.”
  207. 212. Donald J. Trump for President, “United.”
  208. 213. Donald J. Trump for President, “United.”
  209. 214. Richardson, “Pulp Politics,” 617.
  210. 215. Frankenstein, Whale.
  211. 216. The Wolf Man, Waggner.
  212. 217. Picart and Frank, Frames of Evil, 7.
  213. 218. Jamieson, Packaging the Presidency, 447.
  214. 219. Witte, “Putting the Fear Back,” 331.
  215. 220. Hantke, “The Kingdom of the Unimaginable,” 181.
  216. 221. Hart and Feldman, “Threat without Efficacy,” 341.