Abstract

Abstract Commemorating both the Stonewall Riots of 1969 and the subsequent Gay Liberation Movement, the Gay Liberation Monument projects a quiet, muted homosexuality that stands in sharp contrast to the courageous and violent assertion of homosexual identity that was Stonewall. Our essay examines this strange incongruity, revealing in the process the homosentimental style—a unique rhetorical form that attempts to negotiate the many contradictory motives animating LGBT advocacy. The Gay Liberation Monument’s use of homosentimentality refracts in many directions, simultaneously challenging dehumanizing rhetorics with affective appeals to care and friendship, presenting itself as assimilationist even as it offers coded indices of clone culture, and producing a doubled homosexual body—at once assimilationist and queer. Both the monument and the homosentimental style thus pose a challenge to binary conceptualizations of LGBT rights advocacy that separate assimilationist and queer politics.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2018-03-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.21.1.0039
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (89)

  1. “Stonewall Riots,”
  2. “Stonewall Riots.”
  3. Stonewall: The Riots That Sparked the Gay Revolution
  4. Stonewall
  5. “Stonewall Riots.”
Show all 89 →
  1. “queer”
  2. “Movements and Memory,”
    American Sociological Review
  3. “Christopher Park Highlights,”
  4. “Christopher Park Highlights.”
  5. “queer public memory”
  6. “Remembering ‘A Great Fag’: Visualizing Public Memory and the Construction of Queer Space,”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech
  7. “My Old Kentucky Homo: Abraham Lincoln, Larry Kramer, and the Politics of Queer Memory,”
  8. “while this important scholarship has assessed queer public memory in one form or another…
  9. If Memory Serves: Gay Men, AIDS, and the Promise of the Queer Past
  10. “Obama Names LGBT Landmark as National Monument,”
  11. “Gay Politics: Sixteen Propositions,”
  12. “not simply as word choice and sentence structure, but rather as a distinctive way of hol…
  13. Gay Rights
  14. “The Anita Bryant Brigade,”
  15. Gay Rights
  16. Gay Rights
  17. “Anita Bryant,”
  18. “more than one hundred cities and counties and four states had passed laws protecting the…
  19. The Prophetic Tradition
  20. “Gay Politics,”
  21. “Anita Bryant,”
  22. The Prophetic Tradition
  23. “The Making of Gay Liberation (the statue),”
    The Harvard Gay and Lesbian Review
  24. In Memory of May 4, 1970: Kent State—Abraham and Isaac
  25. “Greenwich Village Is Not Amused,”
  26. “Greenwich Village,”
  27. “Greenwich Village,”
  28. “Greenwich Village,”
    Art History
  29. “Greenwich Village,”
  30. “Greenwich Village,”
  31. “Greenwich Village,”
  32. “Gay Liberation,”
  33. “Greenwich Village,”
  34. “Gay Liberation,”
  35. “Gay Liberation,”
  36. “Gay Liberation,”
  37. “Gay Liberation,”
  38. “Productive Bodies, Performative Spaces: Everyday Life in Christopher Park,”
    Sexualities
  39. “Productive Bodies,”
  40. “The alternative ‘assimilationist’ position sought to achieve societal acceptance of homo…
  41. “What Is Sentimentality?”
  42. “Tom Doerr and Marty Robinson during Gay Activists Alliance Sit-In,”
  43. “What Lips These Lips Have Kissed.”
  44. “The Queer/Gay Assimilationist Split: The Suits versus the Sluts,”
    Monthly Review
  45. “The Queer/Gay Assimilationist Split.”
  46. “Gay Politics,”
  47. “to reposition gays in relation to the discourses and practices of American national identity,”
    Philadelphia
  48. Between Past and Future: Six Exercises in Political Thought
  49. “The Politics of Homosexuality,”
  50. The Recovery of Race in America
  51. “Remembering Matthew Shepard,”
  52. “Homosexual Signs (in Memory of Roland Barthes),”
  53. “Recursivity: A Working Paper on Rhetoric and Mnesis,”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  
  54. “Something Queer about the Nation-State,”
    Alphabet City
  55. “The Quare in the Square,”
  56. “What Is Sentimentality,”
  57. “Nationalizing the Gay Body”
  58. “The Making of Gay Liberation,”
  59. “Christopher Park Highlights.”
  60. “Christopher Park Highlights.”
  61. “Productive Bodies,”
  62. “Social and Cultural Sensitivity in Group-Specific HIV and AIDS Programming,”
    Journal of Counseling and Development
  63. “Social and Cultural Sensitivity,”
  64. “pedestrian”
  65. “Clones for a Queer Nation,”
  66. Daring to Be Bad: Radical Feminism in America, 1967–1975
  67. “Clones for a Queer Nation”
  68. “Recognizing Lincoln: Image Vernaculars in Nineteenth-Century Visual Culture,”
  69. “Clones for a Queer Nation,”
  70. “Sex in Public,”
    Publics and Counterpublics
  71. Publics and Counterpublics
  72. “Polysemy: Multiple Meanings in Rhetorical Criticism,”
  73. “Clones for a Queer Nation,”
  74. “Public Memorializing in Postmodernity,”
  75. “Provoke, Don’t Placate,”
  76. “Whiteness: A Strategic Rhetoric,”
  77. “Stonewall Riots.”
  78. “Cisgendered”
  79. “Fanny Fern’s 1855 Ruth Hall.”
  80. “Like Gory Spectres,”
  81. “movements,”
  82. “ordinary homosexuality”
  83. “designated as a National Historic Landmark”