Abstract

Abstract Following a democratic uprising in 1998, the Muslim-majority nation of Indonesia embarked on a transition from four decades of authoritarian rule to become the world's third largest democracy. A recent surge in religious intolerance, however, has sparked concern over an apparent backlash against the political and religious pluralism of the new democratic era. As the world looks to this vast country of 237 million as a model for other Muslim nations now rebelling against their own dictatorships, it is important to understand this political turn marked by a growing incapacity to deal with otherness. This article examines public discourse surrounding accelerating attacks on religious minorities in Indonesia to provide insight into a similar rise in intolerance worldwide, and to address a pressing question for many rhetoric scholars: how does religion work to legitimate or eliminate violence?

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2013-06-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.16.2.0275
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (120)

  1. Except where otherwise indicated, all translations in this article are by the author
  2. “Tahrir One Year Later,”
  3. “The Roles of Indonesia and Turkey in Democratic Developments,”
  4. “SBY Urged to Back UN on Religious Violence,”
  5. “Religious Roots of Terrorism: Perceptions of God Playing Out in World Politics,”
    Forum on Public Policy: A Journal of the Oxford Round Table
Show all 120 →
  1. “An Ideology of Difference,”
    Critical Inquiry
  2. Also commonly spelled umat and umma
  3. “Radicalism in Indonesia Wavering: Survey,”
  4. Pancasila
  5. “Long-standing Tradition under Siege,”
  6. Metaphors We Live By
  7. “Democracy, War, and Decivilizing Metaphors of American Insecurity,”
  8. “Religious Metaphors Can Kill,”
  9. “The Organic State,”
  10. Metaphors We Live By
  11. Coming to Jakarta: A Poem About Terror
  12. “Keputusan Musyawarah Nasional II Majelis Ulama se-Indonesia no. 05/Kep/Munas II/MUI/1980…
  13. “The Fallen Lady,”
  14. “Contaminated Communities: The Metaphor of ‘Immigrant as Pollutant’ in Media Representati…
  15. “The Rhetoric of Hitler's ‘Battle,’”
  16. To the present, all citizens must believe in one god to claim membership in the national …
  17. The 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia
  18. Indonesians of Chinese descent, though sharing this legal status, suffered varying degree…
  19. Risalah Sidang Badan Penyelidik Usaha-Usaha Persiapan Kemerdekaan Indonesia (BPUPKI), Pan…
  20. “Of the Turmoil in Indonesia and Its Roots,”
  21. “A Sixth Religion?: Confucianism and the Negotiation of Indonesian-Chinese Identity Under…
  22. A Nation in Waiting: Indonesia in the 1990s
  23. “Facebook Statistics by Country,”
  24. “Every person shall have the right of freedom of association, assembly, and the expressio…
  25. The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century
  26. The outbreak of fighting between Muslims and Christians in Ambon in early 1999 shattered …
  27. “A Battle to Worship in Peace,”
  28. “Kriteria Aliran Sesat,”
  29. “Ustadzah Dewi Purnamawati (Pakar Kristologi): Pelacuran Aqidah atas Nama Pluralisme,”
  30. “Profile Setara Institute,”
  31. “Bubarkan Islam Liberal & Semua Organisasinya,”
  32. “Interfaith Relations in Indonesia Put to the Litmus Test,”
  33. “Honour is from Allah Alone,”
  34. “Indonesia's Artists vs. Muslim Extremists,”
  35. “Tirani Minoritas Kristen terhadap Mayoritas Islam di Indonesia.”
  36. “Awas Aliran Sesat Bakal Merajalela,”
  37. “Ustadzah Dewi Purnamawati.”
  38. “Banyak Muslimah di Ambon Menjadi Murtad. Kemanakah Engkau Wahai Ulama?”
  39. “Kasus Terbanyak, Pemuda Kristen Hamili Gadis Muslimah,”
  40. Interview with Shihabuddin MH, “Kasus Terbanyak, Pemuda Kristen Hamili Gadis Muslimah.”
  41. Shifting Borders: Rhetoric, Immigration, and California's Proposition 187
  42. “Ternyata Kristenisasi Merajalela,”
  43. “Kasus Terbanyak, Pemuda Kristen Hamili Gadis Muslimah.”
  44. The passages he cites are Matthew 28:19 and Mark 16:15. Syihab, “Tirani Minoritas Kristen…
  45. “Christians Under Attack in Indonesia Says Top Bishop,”
  46. “Shiites Fear They Are the Next Target,”
  47. “Indonesia's Treatment of ‘Deviant’ Sects Under the Spotlight,”
  48. “The Rise of Extremist Islam in Indonesia,”
  49. “Ahmadiyah Mau Lapor PBB,”
  50. “Gubernur Kalbar Didesak Larang Ahmadiyah,”
  51. “Para Ulama Desak Pemerintah Larang Ahmadiyah,”
  52. “Sumber Konflik dan Penoda Agama Kenapa Malah Dimanjakan?”
  53. Significantly, rather than dominated by a few people debating, nearly all of the 40+ post…
  54. “KH. Cholil Ridwan: Siap Mufaraqah, Jika MUI Tidak Bubarkan Ahmadiyah,”
  55. “Ahmadiyah Bans.”
  56. “No Shame for Religious Killings in Indonesian Town,”
  57. “No Shame for Religious Killings in Indonesian Town.”
  58. “Indonesia Mob Victim: No Justice for Minorities,”
  59. “Pluralism, Tolerance Under Growing Threat.”
  60. “Why Is Islamic Extremism Growing in Indonesia?”
  61. Dissociated Identities: Ethnicity, Religion, and Class in an Indonesian Society
  62. “Illiberal But Not Intolerant: Understanding the Indonesian Council of Ulamas,”
  63. “Preachers Told to Support Controversial MUI Edicts,”
  64. fatwa
  65. “NU Criticizes Controversial MUI Edicts,”
  66. “FPI: Brute Force,”
  67. “Indonesian Government Blamed for Religious Violence,”
  68. “NU Criticizes Controversial MUI Edicts.”
  69. “Ahmadiyah: Scrutinizing Faiths, Stifling Beliefs,”
  70. “Ahmadiyah Mosque Burned as Protests Grow,”
  71. “Exclusive: Secret Report Reveals How BIN Misread Threat to Ahmadiyah,”
  72. “PPP ‘Officially’ Rejects Ahmadiyah,”
  73. “Indonesia, War on the Ahmadi Considered Blasphemous by Government and Islamic Leaders,”
  74. “MUI Urges Government to Ban Ahmadiya,”
  75. Official name: “The Law on the Prevention of the Misuse and Disgrace of Religion.”
  76. “Mayor Uses Security as Excuse to Ban Ahmadiyah,”
  77. “Ministry Defends Regional Bans On Ahmadiyah,”
  78. “Ahmadis to Drop Further Legal Proceedings in Cikeusik Killings,”
  79. “Ahmadiyah Women Are ‘Denied Rights,’”
  80. “Ahmadiyah Refugees Denied Voting Rights,”
  81. Purity and Danger: An Analysis of the Concepts of Pollution and Taboo
  82. “New Sects ‘Screwing Up’ Islam Teachings,”
  83. “The Rhetoric of Hitler's ‘Battle,’”
  84. “Religious Metaphors Can Kill,”
  85. Things Hidden since the Foundation of the World
  86. “Religious Metaphors Can Kill,”
  87. “No Shame for Religious Killings in Indonesian Town.”
  88. “Religious Metaphors Can Kill,”
  89. “Religious Roots of Terrorism,”
  90. “The Meaning of Purity for Man's Relationship to God in Islam,”
  91. The Body in the Mind: The Bodily Basis of Meaning Imagination and Reason
  92. “House Told To Scrap ‘Intolerant’ Bill,”
  93. “Police, Military ‘Intimidate’ Bogor Ahmadis to Convert,”
  94. “Police, Military ‘Intimidate’ Bogor Ahmadis to Convert.”
  95. “A Good Precedence Set in Sectarian Conflict Resolution,”
  96. “A Bravery Test for National Police,”
    Jakarta Post
  97. “An Ideology of Difference,”
  98. Among the most prominent of such groups are Hizbut Tahrir, Jemaah Islameeyah, Negara Isla…
  99. Enjoy Your Symptom! Jacques Lacan in Hollywood and Out
  100. Slavoj Žižek
  101. “Shiites Fear They Are the Next Target.”
  102. “Egypt's Christians Fear Violence as Changes Embolden Islamists,”
  103. Government officials, particularly the president, are in fact now in an increasingly diff…
  104. “Deputy Mayor: Punk Community a ‘New Social Disease,’”
  105. Strategies of Remembrance: The Rhetorical Dimensions of National Identity Construction
  106. “Indonesia's Counter Radicalisation Programme: Challenges from Radicals,”
  107. “The Challenge to Religious Liberty in Indonesia,”
  108. “‘Wise’ Politicians Key to Religious Tolerance,”
  109. “Politicians Question Government Inaction,”
  110. “Pidato Lengkap BJ Habibie yang Memukau,”
  111. “TNI Sebagai Pengaman dan Pengawal Pancasila,”
  112. Strategies of Remembrance
  113. At a minimum, the changes that have shaken religious hierarchies in Indonesia—including f…
  114. “The New Trinity: Religion, Knowledge and Power,”