A Zero-Sum Politics of Identification: A Topological Analysis of Wildlife Advocacy Rhetoric in the Mexican Gray Wolf Reintroduction Project

Written Communication Jul 2019

A Zero-Sum Politics of Identification: A Topological Analysis of Wildlife Advocacy Rhetoric in the Mexican Gray Wolf Reintroduction Project

Lynda Walsh University of Nevada, Reno

Abstract

As climate change contracts our environment, bringing human and nonhuman communities into increased contact and conflict over scarce resources, advocacy rhetoric is making a related shift, from raising human awareness of problems “out there” to renegotiating the very boundaries between human and nonhuman communities. This shift—along with the advent of online media, which similarly blurs traditional urban versus rural boundaries between communities—invites us to update classic studies of advocacy rhetoric from the 1990s and early 2000s. Accordingly, this study addresses advocates’ use of online media in the Mexican Gray Wolf Reintroduction Project. I reconstruct wildlife advocates’ attitudes toward the Project, as expressed online in press releases and blog posts, by using a combination of topology—a method that looks at patterns of topoi (shared beliefs, values, and norms) that a community expresses in a given rhetorical situation—and Kenneth Burke’s theories of attitudes and identification. I then compare advocates’ attitudes with the attitudes of project administrators and landowners in the reintroduction area, reconstructed in earlier work. I conclude that advocates amplify their identification with allies (chiefly wolves and supportive sectors of “the public”) and their alienation from competitors (chiefly public-land ranchers and project administrators) via the creation of “straw attitudes” for these communities that conflict both with their own attitude and with the documented attitudes of these communities. This rhetorical strategy creates a zero-sum political scenario for communication in the Project and recapitulates old political divisions in the southwestern United States. I finish by recommending rhetorical strategies aimed to increase identification, rather than alienation, in the Project and by showing what online advocacy rhetoric can teach us about the structure of Burkean theories of identification.

Journal: Written Communication
Published: 2019-07-01
DOI: 10.1177/0741088319842566
Open Access: Closed
Topics: rhetorical theory multilingual writers

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (1)

Lindenman et al. (2024)

A Taxonomy of Life Writing: Exploring the Functions of Meaningful Self-Sponsore…

Written Communication

Cites in this index (6)

Graham et al. (2019)

There’s No Such Thing as a Scientific Controversy

Technical Communication Quarterly
Walsh (2013)

Resistance and Common Ground as Functions of Mis/aligned Attitudes

Written Communication
Huckin et al. (2012)

Critical Discourse Analysis and Rhetoric and Composition

College Composition and Communication
Walsh (2009)

Marking Territory

Written Communication
Ratcliffe (1999)

Rhetorical Listening: A Trope for Interpretive Invention and a "Code of Cross-C…

College Composition and Communication

Show all 6 →

Patterson et al. (1997)

The Environmental Rhetoric of "Balance": A Case Study of Regulatory Discourse a…

Technical Communication Quarterly

Also cites 27 works outside this index ↓

Anderson D. (2004)

10.1353/par.2004.0019

Philosophy and Rhetoric ↗
10.1525/9780520933101

↗
10.2111/07-063.1

↗
10.1525/9780520340664

↗
10.1525/9780520353237

↗
10.1525/9780520340978

↗
Burke K. (1984)

Attitudes toward history: With a new afterword

↗
10.1080/17524032.2013.822408

↗
10.1023/B:CLIM.0000004708.74871.62

↗
10.4324/9780203063088

↗
10.1007/978-3-319-51268-6_6

↗
Hasselmann K. (2013)

Reframing the problem of climate change: From zero sum game to win-win solutions

↗
10.1177/0957926502013003054

↗
10.1007/978-3-319-51268-6_7

↗
10.4159/9780674039964

↗
10.1080/00335638009383499

↗
10.3200/ENVT.51.2.12-23

↗
10.5325/jinfopoli.2.2012.0001

↗
Opotow S. (2003)

Identity and the natural environment: The psychological significance of nature

↗
10.1002/wsb.251

↗
10.1111/j.1755-263X.2010.00099.x

↗
10.1080/17524032.2015.1018837

↗
Rutten K. (2013)

10.1080/02560046.2013.867587

Critical Arts ↗
Sandler R. D. (2007)

Environmental justice and environmentalism: The social justice challenge to the environme…

↗
10.22230/cjc.1991v16n3a626

↗
Walsh L. (2017)

Topologies as techniques for a post-critical rhetoric

↗
10.1177/1075547014566990

↗

CrossRef global citation count: 4 View in citation network →