Writing the Critique, a Text about a Text

Written Communication Jul 1996

Writing the Critique, a Text about a Text

MAUREEN A. MATHISON

Abstract

The research reported investigated how 32 undergraduate students in an upper-level sociology course wrote critiques and how their texts were evaluated by 4 professors in the discipline. Students represented different majors and education levels. Features associated with critique were tested for their relationship to the professors' summed holistic quality scores. Student's status as major and their educational level were also tested for their relationship to the summed scores. Results indicate that (a) students were more likely to receive higher scores if they found weaknesses in the source article, basing their judgments on disciplinary knowledge and employing an integrated text configuration, and (b) neither major nor educational level was a strong predictor of quality. Findings suggest that current pedagogy that promotes personal evaluation of texts may not lead to the type of writing valued in particular disciplinary communities, where evaluative commentary may be more linked to unique disciplinary standards.

Journal: Written Communication
Published: 1996-07-01
DOI: 10.1177/0741088396013003002
Open Access: Closed
Topics: graduate education

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (2)

HAYES et al. (1999)

Issues in Measuring Reliability

Written Communication
HASWELL et al. (1999)

Context and Rhetorical Reading Strategies

Written Communication

Cites in this index (17)

GREENE (1995)

Making Sense of My Own Ideas

Written Communication
Herrington et al. (1994)

Writing, Teaching and Learning in the Disciplines

College Composition and Communication
Sheard (1993)

Kairos and Kenneth Burke's Psychology of Political and Social Communication

College English
Greene (1993)

The Role of Task in the Development of Academic Thinking through Reading and Wr…

Research in the Teaching of English
North (1992)

On book reviews in rhetoric and composition

Rhetoric Review

Show all 17 →

Spivey (1991)

The Shaping of Meaning: Options in Writing the Comparison

Research in the Teaching of English
Ackerman (1991)

Reading, Writing, and Knowing: The Role of Disciplinary Knowledge in Comprehens…

Research in the Teaching of English
Hull et al. (1990)

"This Wooden Shack Place": The Logic of an Unconventional Reading

College Composition and Communication
SPIVEY (1990)

Transforming Texts

Written Communication
KAUFER et al. (1989)

Novelty in Academic Writing

Written Communication
Durst (1987)

Cognitive and Linguistic Demands of Analytic Writing

Research in the Teaching of English
KENNEDY (1985)

The Composing Process of College Students Writing from Sources

Written Communication
BAZERMAN (1985)

Physicists Reading Physics

Written Communication
BRIDGEMAN et al. (1984)

Survey of Academic Writing Tasks

Written Communication
BRELAND et al. (1984)

Perceptions of Writing Skills

Written Communication
Witte (1983)

Topical Structure and Revision: An Exploratory Study

College Composition and Communication
Nold et al. (1977)

An Analysis of Readers’ Responses to Essays

Research in the Teaching of English

Also cites 17 works outside this index ↓

10.2307/747852

↗
10.1037/0022-0663.80.1.67

↗
10.1080/00461528209529252

↗
10.1080/00335637409383222

↗
Diederich, P. B.

Factors in judgments of writing ability

↗
10.1207/s15516709cog0601_2

↗
Firbas, J.

Functional sentence perspective in written and spoken communication

↗
Flower, L.

Reading to write: Exploring a social and cognitive process

↗
10.2307/356491

↗
10.1037/0022-0663.71.3.328

↗
10.2307/358026

↗
Harding, S.

Whose science? Whose knowledge?

↗
Kaufer, D.

Communication at a distance: The influence of print on social organization and change

↗
10.2307/747793

↗
10.1080/00335638409383686

↗
10.1080/03637756809375565

↗
10.1598/RRQ.24.1.1

↗

CrossRef global citation count: 12 View in citation network →