The 1931 Lemon Grove Case and Segregation Arguments: Learning from a Multilayer, Cross-Border Rhetorical Endeavor

Suzanne Bordelon Russian State Agrarian Correspondence University

Abstract

This essay examines the multidimensional, cross-border actions and rhetorical strategies surrounding the 1931 case, Roberto Alvarez v. the Board of Trustees of the Lemon Grove School District, the nation’s first successful class action school desegregation decision involving Mexican-origin students. A commonplace in US school desegregation history is that it started with the 1954 landmark Supreme Court decision of Brown v. Board of Education. This study argues that the Alvarez v. Lemon Grove case’s success was because it was a multifaceted, multilayered effort involving multiple agents: Mexico’s State Department, the Secretary of Public Education, and the San Diego Consul, as well as lawyers and families. It considers the ways such efforts were successful in this instance in preventing segregation, yet how they were unsuccessful in disrupting other forms of racism, particularly whiteness as the standard. Ultimately, this analysis demonstrates the need for such a multidimensional analysis of similar cases in the future, a transnational archival methodology.

Journal
Rhetoric Society Quarterly
Published
2022-01-01
DOI
10.1080/02773945.2021.1990379
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (48)

  1. 10.1525/9780520342880
  2. Journal of San Diego History
  3. ———. “Re: Lemon Grove Incident.” Received by author, 26 Aug. 2020.
  4. In Defense of La Raza: The Los Angeles Mexican Consulate and the Mexican Community, 1929 …
  5. The Mexican Revolution: Conflict and Consolidation, 1910–1940, edited by Douglas W. Richm…
Show all 48 →
  1. 10.1525/scq.2012.94.3.346
  2. 10.2307/1373047
  3. Visual Rhetoric: A Reader in Communication and American Culture
  4. Form and Genre: Shaping Rhetorical Action
  5. Ceceña, Daniel, [version]. “The Mexican’s Children Must Return to Their Classes Now.” Hispano Americano 13 Ma…
  6. 10.17763/haer.82.2.a562315u72355106
  7. The Lemon Grove Incident (VHS)
  8. Espinosa, Paul. “Lemon Grove Case Was First Time A Court Ordered Desegregation,” San Diego Union-Tribune, 24 …
  9. 10.9783/9780812209891
  10. ———. “Re: [EXT] Re: Question Related to the Lemon Grove Case.” Received by author, 17 Dec. 2020.
  11. Reflexiones 1997: New Directions in Mexican American Studies
  12. 10.1080/10570314.2019.1658892
  13. Rhetorical Criticism: Exploration and Practice
  14. School and Society
  15. 10.1093/oso/9780199914142.001.0001
  16. Gonzalez, Juan. “Letter Thought to Be Written to Local Newspapers or the Mexican Consul.” 11 Feb. 1931. (Paul…
  17. Clasificación Y Estudio Estadistico De 3,719 Alumnos, La Mayoria De Primer Año De Enseñan…
  18. Kasulaitis, Mary Noon. “Re: Fred C. Noon.” Received by author, 30 Oct. 2020.
  19. “Lemon Grove School Row up in Court: Writ Is Asked to Allow Children to Attend Regular Session.” San Diego Su…
  20. “Lemon Grove School Strike Still Going On: Mexican Consul Claims It Has Not Been Settled Satisfactorily: Make…
  21. Multicultural Education, Spring
  22. “Mandamus.” Legal Information Institute. Cornell Law School. www.law.cornell.edu/wex/mandamus#:~:text=Overvie…
  23. 10.1007/978-94-010-0570-8_2
  24. Minutes, Board of Trustees of the Lemon Grove School District, 1930–1931. Lemon Grove Historical Society [arc…
  25. 10.1525/phr.2010.79.2.167
  26. Diverse Issues in Higher Education
  27. “No Admiten a Los Niños Mexicanos: Los padres de familia notificados por las autoridades de Lemon Grove, Cal.…
  28. Race Ethnicity Education
  29. “Orders Mexican Pupils Admitted at Lemon Grove: Court Rules Children Must Be Given Equality with All Other St…
  30. 10.1525/phr.2020.89.3.347
    Pacific Historical Review  
  31. “Petition for Writ of Mandate.” Roberto Alvarez v. Board of Trustees of Lemon Grove School District, Case No.…
  32. Practicing Research in Writing Studies: Reflexive and Ethically Responsible Research
  33. 10.18085/llas.1.3.3t28w4u423vn3322
  34. Brown V. Board of Education at Fifty: A Rhetorical Perspective
  35. From the Grassroots to the Supreme Court: Brown V. Board of Education and American Democracy
  36. Memoria de la Secretaría de Relationes Exteriores de Agosto de 1930 a Julio de 1931, pres…
  37. Smith, Jeff. “Unforgettable: Long-Ago San Diego.” San Diego Reader, 26 July 2007, n.p. Lemon Grove Historical…
  38. “Students Refuse to Return to Special School Rooms: Lemon Grove’ Walkout” Is Still Going On: Mexican Consul C…
  39. “Tapia Selects Local Attorney: Fred Noon Representative in California for This District; to Aid Consul.” San …
  40. Memoria de la de Agosto de 1930 a Julio de 1931, presentada al H. Congreso de la Union po…
  41. Memoria de la Secretaría de Relationes Exteriores de Agosto de 1930 a Julio de 1931, pres…
  42. Chicano Students and the Courts: The Mexican American Legal Struggle for Educational Equality
  43. 10.2307/25157525