Rhetoric Society Quarterly Jan 2003

Theology, canonicity, and abbreviated enthymemes: Traditional and critical influences on the British reception of Aristotle'sRhetoric

Carol Poster Florida State University

Abstract

Abstract This essay argues that the construction of the 18th and 19th century British rhetorical theories and canon was strongly influenced by the debates between Catholic (or Anglo‐Catholic) traditionalists and Protestant critics over religious hermeneutics, by examining three specific cases, the Phalaris controversy, definitions of the enthymeme, and the reception history of the Rhetorica ad Alexandrum. The major figures discussed are Richard Bentley, William Temple, John Gillies, Edward Copleston, Sydney Smith, Richard Whately, James Hessey, and William Hamilton. Notes Research for this study has been supported by many sources, including a fellowship at the Tanner Humanities Center of the University of Utah, a Rocky Mountain MLA Huntington fellowship, and a First Year Assistant Professor grant from Florida State University. An NEH Summer 2002 Seminar, "The Reform of Reason,"; which I co‐directed with Jan Swearingen, provided an opportunity to revise this essay, and I owe thanks to both the NEH and the fifteen seminar participants. I also owe thanks to several libraries, including the Bodleian Library, the British Library, Cambridge University Library, Folger Shakespeare Library, Huntington Library, Rylands Library, St. Deiniol's Library, and the ILL staffs of Montana State University and Florida State University libraries. I also would like to thank Marilyn Faulkenburg, Thomas Miller, Christopher Stray, Jan Swearingen, and Karen Whedbee for many useful comments.

Journal
Rhetoric Society Quarterly
Published
2003-01-01
DOI
10.1080/02773940309391246
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (5)

  1. Poster (2015)
    A Good Dissenter Speaking Well: William Enfield’s Educational and Elocutionary …
    Advances in the History of Rhetoric
  2. Poster (2008)
    Whose Aristotle? Which Aristotelianism? A Historical Prolegomenon to Thomas Far…
    Philosophy & Rhetoric
  3. Poster (2006)
    An Organon for Theology: Whately's Rhetoric and Logic in Religious Context
    Rhetorica
  4. Poster (2005)
    FramingTheaetetus:Plato and rhetorical (mis)representation
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  5. Ornatowski et al. (2003)
    Reviews
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly

References (143) · 3 in this index

  1. (1833)
    Edinburgh Review
  2. Aristotle (1497)
    Eis organon Aristotelous
  3. _____ (1791)
    Aristotelis opera omnia Graece
  4. _____ (1831)
    Aristotelis Opera
  5. _____ (1843)
    Opera omnia
Show all 143 →
  1. _____ (1848)
    Opera omnia
  2. Arnold Matthew (1875)
    God and the Bible
  3. Barthes Roland (1977)
    Image‐Music‐Text
  4. Barthélemy‐Saint‐Hilaire J. (1870)
    Rhétorique d'Aristote: traduite en français et accompagnée de notes perpétuelles avec La …
  5. Baur Ferdinand Christian (1876)
    Paul: The Apostle of Jesus Christ, His Life, His Work His Epistles, His Doctrine
  6. Bensel‐Myers, Linda. 1992.Rhetoric for Academic Reasoning, 124–128. 167–173. 210New York: Harper Collins.
  7. Berlin James (1984)
    Writing Instruction in Nineteenth Century American Colleges
  8. Bentham George (1827)
    Outline of a New System of Logic, With a Critical Examination of Dr. Whately's “Elements …
  9. Blakesley Joseph (1839)
    A Life of Aristotle
  10. Brandt William (1969)
    The Craft of Writing
  11. Brink Charles Oscar (1986)
    English Classical Scholarship: Historical Reflections on Bentley, Porson and Housman
  12. Burgess Thomas (1829)
    A Letter to the Reverend Thomas Beynon, Archdeacon of Cardigan, in Reply to the Vindicati…
  13. Burgon John William (1896)
    The Traditional Text of the Holy Gospels Vindicated and Established
  14. _____ (1896)
    The Causes of Corruption of The Traditional Text of the Holy Gospels
  15. Burnyeat M. F. (1994)
    Aristotle's Rhetoric: Philosophical Essays
  16. 10.1080/00335638409383687
     ↗
  17. _____ (1990)
    Rhetoric in the European Tradition
  18. Cope E. M. (1867)
    An Introduction to Aristotle's Rhetoric
  19. Copleston Edward (1857)
    Opinions of the late Dr. Copleston, Bishop of Llandaff, and Archbishop Whately in Favour …
  20. (1827)
    A Vindication of the Literary Character of Professor Porson from the Animadversions of th…
  21. Day Angel (1586)
    The English secretorie. Wherein is contayned, a perfect method, for the inditing of all m…
  22. Defoe Daniel (1727)
    The compleat English tradesman, with supplement
  23. Dilthey Wilhelm (1976)
    Selected Writings
  24. Ellison Robert H. (1998)
    The Victorian Pulpit: Spoken and Written Sermons in Nineteenth‐Century Britain
  25. Emmel (1994)
    Toward a pedagogy of the enthymeme: The roles of dialogue, intention, and funct…
    Rhetoric Review
  26. Foucault Michel (1977)
    Language. Counter Memory. Practice
  27. Fox Adam (1954)
    John Mill and Richard Bentley: A Study of the Textual Criticism of the New Testament, 1675–1729
  28. Fulwood William (1568)
    The enimie of idlenesse: teaching the manner and stile how to endite, compose and write a…
  29. Funk Robert W. (1993)
    The Five Gospels: The Search for the Authentic Words of Jesus
  30. Gadamer Hans‐Georg (1976)
    Philosophical Hermeneutics
  31. _____ (1986)
    The Idea of the Good in Platonic‐Aristotelian Philosophy
  32. _____ (1975)
    Truth and Method
  33. _____ (1991)
    Gadamer and Hermeneutics
  34. Gage (1983)
    Teaching the enthymeme: Invention and arrangement
    Rhetoric Review
  35. _____ (1991)
    The Shape of Reason: Argumentative Writing in College
  36. Gaines Robert (2000)
    Rereading Aristotle's Rhetoric
  37. Gillies John (1804)
    Aristotle's Ethics and Politics
  38. Grant Alexander (1878)
    Aristotle
  39. Green Lawrence (1995)
    Rhetoric and Pedagogy: Its History, Philosophy, and Practice
  40. Gross Alan (2000)
    Rereading Aristotle's Rhetoric
  41. Grote George (1883)
    Aristotle
  42. Hamilton Sir William (1860)
    Lectures on Logic
  43. _____ (1856)
    Discussions on Philosophy and Literature, Education and University Reform
  44. Hampden Renn Dickson (1839)
    A Lecture on Tradition. Read Before the University, in the Divinity School, Oxford, On Th…
  45. _____ (1848)
    The Scholastic Philosophy Considered in its Relation to Christian Theology
  46. _____ (1862)
    The Fathers of Greek Philosophy
  47. Heath Malcolm (1995)
    Hermogenes. On Issues
  48. Hessey James Augustus (1845)
    Schemata Rhetorica, or Tables Explanatory of the Nature of the Enthymeme
  49. _____ (1860)
    Sunday: its origin, history, and present obligation, considered in the Bampton Lectures p…
  50. _____ (1850)
    A scripture argument against permitting marriage with a wife's sister: a clergyman's lett…
  51. _____ (1883)
    Six grand objections to marriage with a deceased wife's sister: set forth in a paper read…
  52. Holland Lady S. (1874)
    A Memoir of the Reverend Sydney Smith
  53. Horner Winifred Bryan (1990)
    A Short History of Writing Instruction
  54. _____ (1993)
    Nineteenth Century Scottish Rhetoric: The American Connection
  55. Howell W. S. (1956)
    Logic and Rhetoric in England 1500–1700
  56. _____ (1971)
    Eighteenth Century British Logic and Rhetoric
  57. Jacobi Martin (1986)
    10.1177/108056998604900109
    Bulletin of the Association for Business Communication  ↗
  58. Jarratt Susan (1991)
    Rereading the Sophists: Classical Rhetoric Refigured
  59. Jauss Hans Robert (1982)
    Towards an Aesthetics of Reception
  60. Jebb Richard Claverhouse (1909)
    Bentley
  61. Jevons William Stanley (1864)
    Pure Logic or the Logic of Quality Apart from Quantity
  62. _____ (1870)
    Elementary Lessons in Logic: Deductive and Inductive
  63. _____ (1874)
    The Principles of Science: A Treatise on Logic and Scientific Method
  64. _____ (1876)
    Logic
  65. Jordan W. G. (1909)
    Biblical Criticism and Modem Thought
  66. Kennedy George (1980)
    Classical Rhetoric and Its Christian and Secular Tradition from Ancient to Modern Times
  67. _____ (1983)
    Greek Rhetoric Under the Christian Emperors
  68. Lampe David Robert (1982)
    Bentley and the Wits: A Critical Introduction to the “Dialogues of the Dead” of William King
  69. Mansel H. L. (1856)
    Arris Logicae Rudimento from the text of Aldrich
  70. Maynard Michael (1995)
    A History of the Debate over 1 John 5,7–8. A Tracing of the Longevity of the Comma Johann…
  71. McGann Jerome (1992)
    A Critique of Modem Textual Criticism
  72. Metzger Bruce M. (1963)
    Chapters in the History of the New Testament Textual Criticism
     ↗
  73. _____ (1964)
    The Text of the New Testament: Its Transmission, Corruption, and Restoration
  74. Miller Arthur (1972)
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
  75. Monk James Henry (1833)
    The life of Richard Bentley
  76. Nash Henry S. (1900)
    The History of the Higher Criticism of the New Testament
  77. Neel Jasper (1988)
    Plato, Derrida, and Writing
  78. _____ (1994)
    Aristotle's Voice
  79. Nestle Eberhard (1901)
    Introduction to the Textual Criticism of the Greek New Testament
  80. Newman John Henry (1967)
    On the Inspiration of Scripture
  81. _____ (1974)
    An Essay on The Development of Christian Doctrine. The Edition of 1845
  82. _____ (1833)
    The Arians of the Fourth Century: their doctrine, temper, and conduct, chiefly as exhibit…
  83. _____ (1840)
    The Church of the Fathers
  84. _____ (1836)
    Elucidations of Dr. Hampden ‘s theological statements
  85. Newman John Henry (1839)
    Tracts for the Times
  86. Owen Octavius Freire (1853)
    The Organon, or Logical Treatises of Aristotle
  87. Pacius Julius (1606)
    Aristotelis . . . Organum: hoc est, libri omnes ad logicam pertinentes, Graecè, et Latinè
  88. Peters John P. (1901)
    The Old Testament and the New Scholarship
  89. Pfeiffer Rudolf (1976)
    History of Classical Scholarship from 1300 to 1850
  90. Phillips Arthur (1923)
    The Failure of the Higher Criticism of the New Testament
  91. Pattison Mark (1861)
    Recent Inquiries in Theology
  92. Pattison Robert (1991)
    The Great Dissent: John Henry Newman and the Liberal Heresy
     ↗
  93. Porson Richard (1790)
    Letters to Mr Archdeacon Travis, in answer to his defense of the Three Heavenly Witnesses…
  94. Poster (1992)
    A historicist recontextualization of the enthymeme
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  95. _____ (1998)
    Rhetorical’ Feminist Interpretations of Aristotle
  96. _____ (2000)
    Journal for the Study of the Rhetoric of the New Testament
  97. 10.1353/par.2000.0014
     ↗
  98. _____ (2001)
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  99. _____ (2002)
    Ancient Philosophy
  100. Reeve Anne (1986)
    Erasmus’ Annotations of the New Testament
  101. Reich Emil (1905)
    The Failure of the ‘Higher Criticism’ of the Bible
  102. Reid Thomas (1806)
    Analysis of Aristotle's Logic with Remarks
  103. Reimarus Hermann Samuel (1970)
    Reimarus: Fragments
  104. Renan Ernest (1864)
    The Life of Jesus
  105. Reynolds L. D. (1991)
    Scribes and Scholars: A Guide to the Transmission of Greek and Latin Literature
     ↗
  106. Richardson Samuel (1741)
    Letters written to and for particular friends, on the Most important occasions
  107. Ricoeur Paul (1983)
    Philosophy in France Today
  108. _____ (1977)
    The Rule of Metaphor
  109. _____ (1976)
    Interpretation Theory
  110. _____ (1981)
    Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences
  111. Russell Donald A. (1983)
    Greek Declamation
     ↗
  112. _____ (1988)
    Journal of Hellenic Studies
  113. Salmon George (1897)
    Some Thoughts on the Textual Criticism of the New Testament
  114. Sandys John Edwin (1967)
    A History of Classical Scholarship
  115. Schaff P. (1892)
    Companion to the Greek Testament and the English Version
  116. Schleiermacher Friedrich (1975)
    The Life of Jesus
  117. _____ (1998)
    Hermeneutics and Criticism and Other Writings
  118. Schweitzer Albert (1954)
    The Quest of the Historical Jesus: A Critical Study of its Progress from Reimarus to Wrede
  119. Scrivener F. H. A. (1894)
    A Plain Introduction to Criticism of the New Testament
  120. Smith Sidney (1810)
    Edinburgh Review
  121. Spengel Leonhard von (1847)
    Ars rhetorica, quae vulgo fertur Aristotelis Ad Alexandrum
  122. Stewart Donald (1990)
    The Present State of Scholarship in Historical and Contemporary Rhetoric
  123. Stirewalt Martin Luther (1993)
    Studies in Ancient Greek Epistolography
  124. Strauss David Friedrich (1972)
    The Life of Jesus Critically Examined
  125. _____ (1977)
    The Christ of Faith and the Jesus of History: A Critique of Schleiermacher's The Life of Jesus
  126. Taylor Thomas (1812)
    The Works of Aristotle Translated from the Greek with Copious Elucidations from the Best …
  127. Trollope Anthony (1994)
    Barchester Towers
  128. Tuckwell William (1909)
    Pre‐Tractarian Oxford
  129. Utz Richard (2002)
    Chaucer and the Discourse of German Philology
  130. Veyne Paul (1988)
    Did the Greeks Believe in Their Myths?
  131. Vincent Marvin R. (1899)
    A History of the Textual Criticism of the New Testament
  132. Vitanza Victor (1997)
    Negation, Subjectivity, and the History of Rhetoric
  133. Whately Richard (1975)
    Elements of Logic
  134. White Reginald James (1968)
    Dr. Bentley: A Study in Academic Scarlet
  135. Wimsatt William (1972)
    20th Century Literary Criticism
  136. Wolf Friedrich August (1784)
    Animadversiones ad Aristotelis Librum Primum Rhetoricum cum Notitia et Censura Graeci Sch…
  137. _____ (1986)
    Prolegomena ad Homerum
  138. Zeller Eduard (1844)
    Die Philosophie der Griechen, eine Untersuchung uber Character, Gang, und Hauptmommente i…
CrossRef global citation count: 8 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Res Rhetorica Apr 2026
    Logos in ancient Greek discourse on rhetoric: An overview ↗
    Arkadiusz Sokolnicki
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument
  2. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication Mar 2026
    Canon to Code: Rhetorical Rulemaking for Generative AI Content Audits and Governance ↗
    Miriam F. Williams
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism assessment technical communication artificial intelligence
  3. Poroi Feb 2026
    Using Stasis Theory as a Heuristic for Examining Epistemological Dilemmas in a Post-Truth Landscape ↗
    Bruce Bowles
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument
  4. Res Rhetorica Jan 2026
    Ethos – between vir bonus and VIA: Virtue ethics in contemporary rhetorical education ↗
    Agnieszka Budzyńska-Daca
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory argument
  5. Rhetorica Jan 2026
    The Daimonion of Isocrates: Anti-Socratic Polemics and the Power of Politikoi Logoi in the Philippos ↗
    Tobias Hirsch
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument