Responses to Elisabeth McPherson, “Remembering, Regretting, and Rejoicing” David W. Chapman, Joyce Magnotto, and Barbara Stout Reply Elisabeth McPherson Response to Lester Faigley, “Judging Writing, Judging Selves” Bruce Holland ReplyLester Faigley Response to James Hoetker and Gordon Brossell, “The Effects of Systematic Variations in Essay Topics on the Writing Performance of College Freshmen” Davida Charney Reply James Hoetker