A Modern Theory of Stasis

Abstract

Abstract This article revisits stasis theory, the rhetorical tool that outlines the strategic options of a defendant in a moral or legal accusation. By analyzing the burden of proof of an accuser and deducing a comprehensive model for a modern theory of stasis from the resulting obligations, it develops a system of ten vital staseis (key issues), each of which is by itself sufficient for a defense in front of a reasonable audience. The resulting modern theory of stasis can be a useful heuristic tool for the rhetorical defense against moral and legal accusations as well as for the systematic analysis of judicial speeches and debates.

Journal
Philosophy & Rhetoric
Published
2014-08-01
DOI
10.5325/philrhet.47.3.0273
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (5)

  1. Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  2. Philosophy & Rhetoric
  3. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  4. Philosophy & Rhetoric
  5. Argumentation

References (50) · 4 in this index

  1. Alexy, Robert. 2010. A Theory of Legal Argumentation. Trans. Ruth Adler and Neil MacCormick. Oxford: Oxford U…
  2. Barwick, Karl. 1961. “Augustins Schrift ‘De Rhetorica’ und Hermagoras von Temnos.” Philologus 105:97–110.
  3. Barwick, Karl. 1964. “Zur Erklärung und Geschichte der Staseislehre des Hermagoras von Temnos.” Philologus 10…
  4. Barwick, Karl. 1965. “Zur Rekonstruktion der Rhetorik des Hermagoras von Temnos.” Philologus 109:186–218.
  5. Bedau, Hugo, and Erin Kelly. 2010. “Punishment.” In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. Edward N. Zalta.…
Show all 50 →
  1. Bolin, Bill. 2010. “Addressing Plagiarism with Stasis Theory.” Currents in Teaching and Learning 2 (2): 13–21.
  2. Braet, Antoine C. 1984. “De klassieke statusleer in modern perspectief.” PhD diss., University of Groningen.
  3. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  4. Corbett, Edward P. J., and Robert J. Connors. 1999. Classical Rhetoric for the Modern Student, 4th ed. New Yo…
  5. Goodwin, Jean. 2001. “Reply to Takuzo Konishi: A Generalized Stasis Theory and Arguers' Dialectical Obligatio…
  6. Goodwin, Jean. 2002. “Designing Issues.” In Dialectic and Rhetoric, ed. Frans van Eemeren and Peter Houtlosse…
  7. Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  8. Hart, H. L. A. 1968. Punishment and Responsibility. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  9. Heath, Malcolm. 1994. “The Substructure of Stasis-Theory from Hermagoras to Hermogenes.” Classical Quarterly …
  10. Heath, Malcolm. 2002. “Hermagoras: Transmission and Attribution.” Philologus 146:287–98.
  11. Hoppmann, Michael. 2007. “Statuslehre.” In Historisches Wörterbuch der Rhetorik, ed. G. Ueding, 8:1327–58. Tü…
  12. Hoppmann, Michael. 2008. Argumentative Verteidigung. Berlin: Weidler.
  13. Hoppmann, Michael. 2011. “Genera Causarum and the Burden of Proof.” Cogency 3:33–50.
  14. Horak, Franz. 1972. “Die rhetorische Statuslehre und der moderne Aufbau des Verbrechensbegriffs.” In Festgabe…
  15. Hultzén, Lee S. 1966. “Status in Deliberative Analysis.” In The Rhetorical Idiom, ed. Donald C. Bryant, 97–12…
  16. Argumentation
  17. Kauffeld, Fred. 2002. “Pivotal Issues and Norms in Rhetorical Theories of Argumentation.” In Dialectic and Rh…
  18. Kauffeld, Fred. 2003. “The Ordinary Practice of Presuming and Presumption with Special Attention to Veracity …
  19. Konishi, Takuzo. 2001. “A Generalized Stasis Theory and Arguers' Dialectical Obligations.” In Argumentation a…
  20. Kühl, Kristian. 2005. Strafrecht: Allgemeiner Teil. 5th ed. Munich: Vahlen.
  21. Lausberg, Heinrich. 1960. Handbuch der literarischen Rhetorik. Munich: Max Huber.
  22. Marsh, Charles. 2012. “A Legal Semiotics Framework for Exploring the Origins of Hermagorean Stasis.” Internat…
  23. Matthes, Dieter. 1955. “Hermagoras von Temnos.” PhD diss., University of Hamburg.
  24. Matthes, Dieter. 1958. “Hermagoras von Temnos.” Lustrum 3:58–214.
  25. Matthes, Dieter. 1962. Hermagoras “Temnitae testimonia et fragmenta.” Leipzig: Teubner.
  26. Meyer, Ernst. 1951. “Die Quaestiones der Rhetorik und die Anfänge juristischer Methodenlehre.” Zeitschrift de…
  27. Nadeau, Ray. 1958. “Hermogenes on ‘Stock Issues’ in Deliberative Speaking.” Speech Monographs 25:51–71.
  28. Perelman, Chaim. 1967. Über die Gerechtigkeit. Trans. Ulrike Blüm and Ottmar Ballweg. Munich: Beck.
  29. Perelman, Chaim, and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca. 1969. The New Rhetoric. Trans. John Wilkinson and Purcell Weaver…
  30. Roxin, Claus. 2006. Strafrecht: Allgemeiner Teil. Vol. 1. 4th ed. Munich: Beck, Claus.
  31. Santa Cruz, José. 1958. “Der Einfluß der rhetorischen Theorie der Status auf die römische Jurisprudenz, insbe…
  32. Schünemann, Bernd. 1984. “Einführung in das strafrechtliche Systemdenken.” In Grundfragen des modernen Strafr…
  33. Schwalbach, Theodor. 1881. “Zur Geschichte der Lehre von den Processeinreden.” Zeitschrift der Savigny-Stiftu…
  34. Stroux, Johannes. 1949. Römische Rechtswissenschaft und Rhetorik. Potsdam: Stichnote.
  35. Van Eemeren, Frans H., and Rob Grootendorst. 1992. Argumentation, Communication, and Fallacies. Hove: Lawrenc…
  36. Van Eemeren, Frans H., and Rob Grootendorst. 2004. A Systematic Theory of Argumentation. Cambridge: Cambridge…
  37. Van Eemeren, Frans H., Rob Grootendorst, and Francisca Snoeck Henkemans. 2002. Argumentation. Mahwah, NJ: Law…
  38. Argumentation
  39. Walton, Douglas. 2002. Legal Argumentation and Evidence. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.
  40. Weber, Heinrich. 1886. “Über die Quellen der ‘Rhetorica ad Herennium’ des Cornificius.” PhD diss., University…
  41. Wenzel, Joseph. 2003. “Arguers' Obligations: Another Perspective.” In Anyone Who Has a View, ed. Frans H. van…
  42. Wesel, Uwe. 1967. Rhetorische Statuslehre und Gesetzesauslegung der römischen Juristen. Cologne: Heymann.
  43. Whately, Richard. 1963. Elements of Rhetoric. Ed. Douglas Ehninger. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University …
  44. Woerther, Frédérique. 2012. “Hermagoras et la doctrine des [asystata].” Mnemosyne 65:179–202.
  45. Wood, David. 2002. “Retribution, Crime Reduction, and the Justification of Punishment.” Oxford Journal of Leg…