Computers and Composition Dec 2024 Open Access

A rhetorical consideration of the {XE “embedded”} index

J.A.T. Smith

Abstract

• Indexes are hylomorphic; they turn accidence into substance. • Indexes are authored, not merely produced. • The syntactic, alphabetic, and columnar form of indexes are rhetorically powerful. • Indexes are political because they destabilize hegemonic reading practices. This article, in the area of digital rhetoric, argues that the apparatus of the index is an authored text that bears all of the qualities of creative work. Its primary and distinguishing quality, moreover, is a hylomorphic one that bridges the temporal and material divide by taking the accidence in a text and naming it in substance. This dual nature is especially apparent in indexes that are produced by software, such as MS Word, that require the tagging of a main text to create what is called an “embedded index”; indexes of this sort exist both inside a main text and outside of it, in the tags and in the index list. Because the index both transforms (accidence to idea) and translates (from the main text to index list), the index has rhetorical force, interpreting a text for its readers. It does so as much by its content as by its formal qualities: syntactic, alphabetic, and columnar. Its persuasiveness in tandem with its intervention in the reading process, moreover, has social and political implications since the index can serve as both a means of rebellion and control for those who use and make them.

Journal
Computers and Composition
Published
2024-12-01
DOI
10.1016/j.compcom.2024.102887
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
rhetorical criticism digital rhetoric
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (53) · 3 in this index

  1. Abbamonte (2023)
    On indexing: The birth and early development of an idea
    Journal of the History of Ideas  ↗
  2. Banned Books Week Coordinator & ALA Office for Intellectual Freedom. (n.d.). Banned books week. Retrieved May…
  3. Bloch (1990)
    New philology and old French
    Speculum  ↗
  4. Bloch (2014)
    Rethinking the new medievalism
  5. Breslin (1991)
    Two cheers for the new formalism
    The Kenyon Review
Show all 53 →
  1. Cannon (2007)
    Form
    Middle english: Oxford twenty-first century approaches to literature
  2. Chicago Manual of Style, 17th Edition. (n.d.). Chicago manual of style online. Retrieved May 24, 2023, from h…
  3. Cindex [Computer software]. (n.d.). Scribendi AI. Retrieved May 24, 2023, from https://www.scribendi.ai/cindex/.
  4. Crawford (2020)
    Why we drive: Toward a philosophy of the open road
  5. Duncan (2022)
    Index, a history of the: A bookish adventure from medieval manuscripts to the digital age
  6. ESV single column journaling bible. (2017). Crossway.
  7. Eve (2022)
    New leaves: Riffling the history of digital pagination
    Book History  ↗
  8. Even-Ezra (2021)
    Lines of thought: Branching diagrams and the medieval mind
  9. Fisher (2012)
    Scribal authorship and the writing of history in medieval england
  10. Fleischman (1990)
    Philology, linguistics, and the discourse of the medieval text
    Speculum  ↗
  11. (2020)
    Form and reform: Reading across the fifteenth century
  12. Gillespie (1997)
    Medieval hypertext: Image and text from York minster
    Of the making of books: Medieval manuscripts, their scribes and readers: Essays presented to M.B. parkes
  13. Gioia (1987)
    Notes on the new formalism
    The Hudson Review  ↗
  14. Greulich (2018)
    PDFs in the indexing process
    The Indexer  ↗
  15. Hamburger (2011)
    Medieval hypertext: The illuminated manuscript in an age of virtual reproduction
    Bild und text im mittelalter
  16. Jane Schaffer Academic Writing Program. (n.d.). Jane Schaffer Writing Program. Retrieved May 24, 2023, from h…
  17. Klement (2002)
    Open-system versus closed-system indexing: A vital distinction
    The Indexer: The International Journal of Indexing  ↗
  18. Knight (1979)
    Indexing, the art of: A guide to the indexing of books and periodicals
  19. Kuskin (2013)
    Recursive origins: Writing at the transition to modernity
  20. Lanham (2003)
    Analyzing prose
  21. Lerer (2004)
    The endurance of formalism in Middle English studies
    Literature Compass  ↗
  22. Levinson (2007)
    What is new formalism?
    PMLA
  23. Little (2019)
    The politics of lists
    Exemplaria  ↗
  24. Long (2016)
    Visualizing Words and Knowledge: Arts of Memory for the Digital Age
    Computers and Composition
  25. Macrex Indexing Program [Computer software]. (n.d.). Retrieved May 24, 2023, from http://www.macrex.com/.
  26. Marshall (2011)
    New formalism and the forms of Middle English literary texts
    Literature Compass  ↗
  27. McGann (1991)
    The textual condition
  28. McGann (2001)
    Radiant textuality: Literary studies after the world wide web
  29. McGann (2014)
    A new republic of letters: Memory and scholarship in the age of digital reproduction
  30. McGee et al. (2002)
    The politics of the program: ms word as the invisible grammarian
    Computers and Composition
  31. Mulvany (2005)
    Indexing books
  32. Nichols (1990)
    Introduction: Philology in a manuscript culture
    Speculum  ↗
  33. Parkes (1995)
    Folia librorum quarere: Medieval experience of the problems of hypertext and the index
    Fabula in tabula: Una storia degli indici dal manoscritto al testo elettronico
  34. Patterson (1990)
    On the margin: Postmodernism, ironic history, and medieval studies
    Speculum  ↗
  35. (2002)
    Quintilian: The orator's education, books 3-5
  36. Raschko (2017)
    Introduction: Textual form and spiritual formation
    The Yearbook of Langland Studies  ↗
  37. Rust (2023)
    Listology blog
  38. Salomon (2012)
    An introduction to the glossa ordinaria as medieval hypertext
  39. Selfe et al. (1994)
    The Politics of the Interface: Power and Its Exercise in Electronic Contact Zones
    College Composition and Communication
  40. Shapiro (1987)
    The new formalism
    Critical Inquiry  ↗
  41. SKY [Computer software]. (n.d.). Retrieved May 24, 2023, from https://www.sky-software.com/.
  42. Spears (1991)
    The poetics of the new formalism
    The Hudson Review  ↗
  43. Spiegel (1990)
    History, historicism, and the social logic of the text in the Middle Ages
    Speculum  ↗
  44. Verne (2020)
    Book indexing for authors: How to create a professional nonfiction index in word
  45. Vose (2022)
    The index of prohibited books: Four centuries of struggle over word and image for the greater glory of god
  46. Wakelin (2014)
    Scribal correction and literary craft: English manuscripts 1375–1510
  47. Wenzel (1990)
    Reflections on (new) philology
    Speculum  ↗
  48. Witt (1987)
    Hylomorphism in Aristotle
    The Journal of Philosophy  ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Computers and Composition Jun 2026
    Legacies, commitments, and new challenges: The Sweetland Digital Rhetoric Collaborative interviews three generations of Computers and Composition editors ↗
    Ali Alalem; Alyse Campbell; Thais Rodrigues Cons; Funmilola Fadairo; Nicole Koyuki Golden
    rhetorical criticism collaborative writing digital rhetoric
  2. Res Rhetorica Jan 2026
    Review/Recenzja: Nancy Organ. 2024. Data Visualization for People of All Ages. Oxon: CRC Press; and Jen Christiansen. 2023. Building Science Graphics: An Illustrated Guide to Communicating Science Through Diagrams and Visualizations. Oxon: CRC Press ↗
    Ewa Modrzejewska
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis digital rhetoric multimodality grammar and mechanics race and writing book reviews
  3. Rhetoric Society Quarterly Jan 2026
    The Paradigmatic Aftermath of Digital Rhetoric ↗
    Caddie Alford
    rhetorical criticism digital rhetoric
  4. Communication Design Quarterly Sep 2025
    Review of "Queer Techné: Bodies, Rhetoric, and Desire in the History of Computing by Patricia Fancher," Fancher P. (2024). Queer techné: Bodies, rhetoric, and desire in the history of computing. National Council of Teachers of English. ↗
    Thomas Gurinskas
    rhetorical criticism technical communication professional writing archival research digital rhetoric gender and writing book reviews
  5. Pedagogy Apr 2025
    Contributors ↗
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism african american rhetorics cultural rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy basic writing graduate education two-year college teacher development writing centers technical communication professional writing labor and working conditions digital rhetoric multimodality social media literacy studies race and writing gender and writing community literacy literary studies editorial matter