Eliciting formative assessment in peer review
Abstract
Computer-supported peer review systems can support reviewers and authors in many different ways, including through the use of different kinds of reviewing criteria. It has become an increasingly important empirical question to determine whether reviewers are sensitive to different criteria and whether some kinds of criteria are more effective than others. In this work, we compared the differential effects of two types of rating prompts, each focused on a different set of criteria for evaluating writing: prompts that focus on domain-relevant aspects of writing composition versus prompts that focus on issues directly pertaining to the assigned problem and to the substantive issues under analysis. We found evidence that reviewers are sensitive to the differences between the two types of prompts, that reviewers distinguish among problem-specific issues but not among domain-writing ones; that both types of ratings correlate with instructor scores; and that problem-specific ratings are more likely to be helpful and informative to peer authors in that they are less redundant.
- Journal
- Journal of Writing Research
- Published
- 2012-11-01
- DOI
- 10.17239/jowr-2012.04.02.5
- CompPile
- Search in CompPile ↗
- Open Access
- OA PDF Diamond
- Topics
- Export
- BibTeX RIS
Citation Context
Cited by in this index (0)
No articles in this index cite this work.
Cites in this index (0)
No references match articles in this index.
Related Articles
-
Written Communication Mar 2026Matthew Overstreet; Silvia Vaccino-Salvadore; Diana Akhmedjanova
-
Assessing Writing Jan 2026The effects of online resource use on L2 learners’ computer-mediated writing processes and written products ↗Honglan Wang; Jookyoung Jung
-
Business and Professional Communication Quarterly Dec 2025Huu Phuoc Tran
-
Res Rhetorica Mar 2025Jacek Wasilewski; Agata Kostrzewa
-
Business and Professional Communication Quarterly Sep 2022Making Meaningful Connections and Learning Workplace-Like Business Writing Through LinkedIn and Blogging ↗Daneshwar Sharma