Synthesizing Professional Knowledge and Racial Literacy Content Through Explicit Composing Instruction: A Discourse Synthesis Study

Jenifer Jasinski Schneider University of South Florida ; James R. King University of South Florida ; Gretchen Dodson New Mexico State University

Abstract

This design-based study occurred within a writing methods course in an urban teacher education program. We designed an intervention to develop student teachers’ meta-composing strategies, critical thinking, and justice-oriented reflexivity by revising a teacher-as-writer course assignment to achieve two pedagogical goals: (1) synthesizing antiracist and pedagogical content from curated source texts, and (2) explicating racial literacy as future writing teachers of K-6 students. Using discourse synthesis as both an instructional and research method, we analyzed the synthesis outputs of student teachers during a writing assignment designed to communicate their learnings to an intended audience. Outputs included graphic organizers, planning documents, and a range of final products. We employed discourse synthesis to analyze source and synthesis texts through propositionalization, template formation, and thematic categorization, identifying idea unit origins, progression, or omission. Additionally, content and thematic analyses evaluated instructional strategies and materials to assess whether pedagogical objectives were met. Results indicated discourse synthesis instruction facilitated student engagement with antiracism content, such as historical events, systemic trends, and awareness of racist practices in schools. Findings also highlighted areas for improvement, including modifying source texts, revising the teacher-as-writer assignment, and reevaluating assessment practices in antiracist writing pedagogy.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
2025-07-01
DOI
10.1177/07410883251328352
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (109) · 11 in this index

  1. Accurso K. Mizell J. D. (2020). Toward an antiracist genre pedagogy: Considerations for a North American cont…
  2. Baker-Bell A. (2020). Dismantling anti-black linguistic racism in English language arts classrooms: Toward an…
  3. Barab S. Squire K. (2004). Design-based research: Putting a stake in the ground. The Journal of the Learning …
  4. Barzilai S. Ka’adan I. (2017). Learning to integrate divergent information sources: The interplay of epistemi…
  5. Words their way: Word study for phonics vocabulary and spelling instruction
Show all 109 →
  1. Using critical reflection to improve urban teacher preparation: A collaborative inquiry o…
    Penn GSE Perspectives on Urban Education
  2. Mirrors, windows, and sliding glass doors
    Perspectives: Choosing and Using Books for the Classroom
  3. Boscolo P. Arfé B. Quarisa M. (2007). Improving the quality of students’ academic writing: An intervention st…
  4. Bovair S. Kieras D. E. (1981). A guide to propositional analysis for research on technical prose (Technical R…
  5. Brooks G. (2007). Teachers as readers and writers and as teachers of reading and writing. The Journal of Educ…
  6. Casado-Ledesma L. Cuevas I. Van den Bergh H. Rijlaarsdam G. Mateos M. Granado-Peinado M. Martín E. (2021). Te…
  7. Chávez-Moreno L. (2022). Critiquing racial literacy: Presenting a continuum of racial literacies. Educational…
  8. Clark C. Medina C. (2000). How reading and writing literacy narratives affect preservice teachers’ understand…
  9. Cobb P. Confrey J. diSessa A. Lehrer R. Schauble L. (2003). Design experiments in educational research. Educa…
  10. Collins A. A. Ciullo S. Graham S. Sigafoos L. L. Guerra S. David M. Judd L. (2021). Writing expository essays…
  11. 10.4324/9781003245650
  12. 10.37514/ATD-B.2016.0933
  13. The powers of literacy: A genre approach to teaching writing
  14. 6 + 1 traits of writing: The complete guide, Grades 3 and up
  15. Cumming A. Lai C. Cho H. (2016). Students’ writing from sources for academic purposes: A synthesis of recent …
  16. Cutler L. Graham S. (2008). Primary grade writing instruction: A national survey. Journal of Educational Psyc…
  17. Beyond the personal narrative: Choice and authenticity in middle school novel writing
    Journal of Teacher Action Research
  18. 10.4324/9781315134543
  19. Across the Disciplines
  20. White fragility: Why understanding racism can be so hard for White people
  21. Literate lives: Teaching reading and writing in elementary classrooms
  22. The Fountas & Pinnell literacy continuum: A tool for assessment, planning, and teaching
  23. Culturally responsive teaching: Theory, research, and practice
  24. Gere A. Buehler J. Dallavis C. Haviland V. (2009). A visibility project: Learning to see how preservice teach…
  25. Graham S. (2019). Changing how writing is taught. Review of Research in Education 43 2277–2303. https://doi.o…
  26. Handbook of learning disabilities
  27. Graves D. H. (1983). Writing: Teachers and children at work. Heinemann.
    Writing: Teachers and children at work
  28. The great White hype: Anti-critical race theory legislation and the matrix of domination …
    Journal of Critical Race Inquiry
  29. Guinier L. (2004). From racial liberalism to racial literacy: Brown v. Board of Education and the interest-di…
  30. 10.1598/RRQ.43.2.3
  31. Rhetoric Review
  32. The 1619 project: New York Times magazine, August 18, 2019
  33. Harmon J. Wood K. (2018). The vocabulary-comprehension relationship across the disciplines: Implications for …
  34. Harris K. R. Graham S. (2009). Self-regulated strategy development in writing: Premises evolution and the fut…
  35. Design principles for teaching effective writing: Theoretical and empirical grounded principles
  36. 10.4324/9780203700280
  37. Howell E. Perez S. Abraham W. T. (2021). Toward a professional development model for writing as a digital par…
  38. Hsieh H. F. Shannon S. E. (2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Resear…
  39. Hytten K. Stemhagen K. (2023). Abolishing re-narratizing and revaluing: Dismantling antiblack racism in educa…
  40. 10.37514/PER-B.2015.0698
  41. Labor-based grading contracts: Building equity and inclusion in the compassionate writing…
  42. Inoue A. B. Poe M. (2012). Race and writing assessment. Peter Lang Verlag. https://www.peterlang.com/document…
  43. Literacy and power
  44. How to be an antiracist: One world
    New York
  45. Kilgour P. Northcote M. Williams A. Kilgour A. (2020). A plan for the co-construction and collaborative use o…
  46. Kinloch V. Dixon K. (2017). Equity and justice for all: The politics of cultivating anti-racist practices in …
  47. The representation of meaning in memory
  48. Kirkpatrick L. C. Klein P. D. (2009). Planning text structure as a way to improve students’ writing from sour…
  49. Ladson-Billings G. (1995). Toward a theory of culturally relevant pedagogy. American Educational Research Jou…
  50. Envisioning knowledge: Building literacy in the academic disciplines
  51. Lenski S. D. Johns J. L. (1997). Patterns of reading-to-write. Reading Research and Instruction 37 15–38. htt…
  52. Liao W. Wang C. Zhou J. Cui Z. Sun X. Bo Y. Xu M. Dang Q. (2022). Effects of equity-oriented teacher educatio…
  53. Luke A. (2012). Critical literacy: Foundational notes. Theory into Practice 51(1) 4–11. https://doi.org/10.10…
  54. Maloney T. (2023). Using dilemma protocol discussions in antiracist teacher preparation. Teaching and Teacher…
  55. Journal of Writing Research
  56. Mateos M. Rijlaarsdam G. Martín E. Cuevas I. Van den Bergh H. Solari M. (2020). Learning paths in synthesis w…
  57. Milner H. R.IV. (2020). Disrupting punitive practices and policies: Rac(e)ing back to teaching teacher prepar…
  58. 10.4324/9780367031138-8
  59. Moje E. B. (2007). Developing socially just subject-matter instruction: A review of the literature on discipl…
  60. Myers J. Scales R. Q. Grisham D. L. Wolsey T. D. Dismuke S. Smetana L. Ikpeze C. Ganske K. Martin S. (2016). …
  61. Nelson N. King J. R. (2023). Discourse synthesis: Textual transformations in writing from sources. Reading & …
  62. Paris D. (2012). Culturally sustaining pedagogy: A needed change in stance terminology and practice. Educatio…
  63. Parsons S. A. Malloy J. A. Parsons A. W. Burrowbridge S. C. (2015). Students’ engagement in literacy tasks. R…
  64. Persohn L. (Host). (2021 March 9). A conversation with Carol Lee. (Season 1 No. 17) [Audio podcast episode]. …
  65. College Composition and Communication
  66. Pratt A. B. Calderon-Berumen F. (2024). Spreading acorns: Teacher futurity and micro- interventions. Journal …
  67. Reading Rockets. (2015). Mirrors windows and sliding glass doors [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/wa…
  68. A framework for conceptualizing, planning, conducting, and reporting a formative experime…
  69. Literacy Research Methodologies
  70. On formative and design experiments: Approaches to language and literacy
  71. Writing essentials
  72. Ruben B. Moll L. (2013). Putting the heart back into writing: Nurturing voice in middle school students. Midd…
  73. Ryan G. W. Bernard H. R. (2003). Techniques to identify themes. Field Methods 15(1) 85. https://doi.org/10.11…
  74. The coding manual for qualitative researchers
  75. Research in the Teaching of English
  76. The summary-comparison matrix: A tool for writing the literature review
  77. Schneider J. J. (2001). No blood guns or gays allowed!: The silencing of the elementary writer. Language Arts…
  78. Research in the Teaching of English
  79. Schneider J. J. Hadley E. Panos A. Smith P. Richards J. Bennett S. Gunn A. A. Persohn L. Frier A. Krause M. (…
  80. 10.4324/9780429331435-21
  81. Segev-Miller R. (2004). Writing from sources: The effect of explicit instruction in college students’ process…
  82. Mirrors, windows, and sliding glass doors
    Perspectives: Choosing and Using Books for the Classroom
  83. Sims-Bishop R. (2015). Mirrors windows and sliding glass doors. Reading Rockets. https://www.youtube.com/watc…
  84. Skerrett A. (2011). English teachers’ racial literacy knowledge and practice. Race Ethnicity & Education 14(3…
  85. White racism
    Multicultural Education
  86. Smith P. (2019). (Re)Positioning in the Englishes and (English) literacies of a Black immigrant youth: Toward…
  87. Written Communication
  88. Discourse synthesis: Constructing texts in reading and writing
  89. Research in the Teaching of English
  90. 10.1598/RRQ.24.1.1
  91. Strauss V. (2021). Why Republican efforts to ban the 1619 Project from classrooms are so misguided. https://w…
  92. Sue D. W. Alsaidi S. Awad M. N. Glaeser E. Calle C. Z. Mendez N. (2019). Disarming racial microaggressions: M…
  93. Teaching English in the Two-Year College
  94. Pedagogies of difference: Rethinking education for social change
  95. Literacy for the 21st century: A balanced approach
  96. The construction and use of a propositional text base
    JSAS Catalog of Selected Documents in Psychology
  97. U.S. Department of Justice. (2022). Three former Minneapolis police officers convicted of federal civil right…
  98. Research in the Teaching of English
  99. Willis A. I. Smith P. (2021). Advancing antiracism in literacy research. Literacy Research: Theory Method and…
  100. Everyone has an accent
    Southern Poverty Law Center, Learning for Justice
  101. Engaging in resistant genres as antiracist teacher response
    Journal of Writing Assessment
  102. Xu W. Zammit K. (2020). Applying thematic analysis to education: A hybrid approach to interpreting data in pr…
  103. Written Communication
  104. Zhang C. (2013). Effect of instruction on ESL students’ synthesis writing. Journal of Second Language Writing…