A Case Study of One Youth’s Stance toward the Discourse of Literary Analysis in a Secondary English Classroom

Research in the Teaching of English May 2021

A Case Study of One Youth’s Stance toward the Discourse of Literary Analysis in a Secondary English Classroom

Susan S. Fields Texas A&M University ; Katherine K. Frankel

Abstract

The discourse of literary analysis is dynamic and ideological, shifting as writers navigate conventions and practices to meet their rhetorical purposes in particular contexts. While scholars have engaged ideological analyses of students learning to write literary analysis essays in university contexts, few studies have documented student writers’ experiences of disciplinary enculturation in secondary English language arts classrooms. In this case study, we address this absence by using the concept of stance to examine how the identity of one student—Katarina—informed her interactions with the discourse of literary analysis as it was understood and instantiated by her teacher. In our analysis of essay drafts, field notes, artifacts, and interview transcripts, we found that the convergence of Katarina’s identity as a creative and emotional person and writer with the possibilities for selfhood afforded to her in this context contributed to her stance toward the discourse. We examine points of tension across two of Katarina’s essays that illuminate her ideological struggles as she navigated the discourse of her classroom. Our findings point to the utility of stance as a conceptual tool for researchers and educators to take a critical perspective on students’ writing processes in the context of the ideologically laden, authoritative demands of secondary classrooms.

Journal: Research in the Teaching of English
Published: 2021-05-15
DOI: 10.58680/rte202131258
Open Access: Closed
Topics: qualitative research

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

Cites in this index (4)

Smith (2018)

Composing for Affect, Audience, and Identity: Toward a Multidimensional Underst…

Written Communication
Smagorinsky (2008)

The Method Section as Conceptual Epicenter in Constructing Social Science Resea…

Written Communication
Wilder (2005)

“The Rhetoric of Literary Criticism” Revisited

Written Communication
Wilder (2002)

“Get Comfortable With Uncertainty”

Written Communication

Also cites 17 works outside this index ↓

Beck (2009)

Genre and thinking in academic writing tasks

Journal of Literacy Research ↗
DiPardo (2011)

Seeing voices: Assessing writerly stance in the NWP Analytic Writing Continuum

Assessing Writing ↗
Frankel (2013)

Revisiting the role of explicit genre instruction in the classroom

Journal of Education ↗
Greenhow (2012)

Twitteracy: Tweeting as a new literacy practice

The Educational Forum ↗
Harman (2018)

Critical SFL praxis with bilingual youth: Disciplinary instruction in a third space

Critical Inquiry in Language Studies ↗
Ivanicˇ (1998)

Writing and identity: The discoursal construction of identity in academic writing

↗
Lee (1995)

A culturally based cognitive apprenticeship: Teaching African American high school studen…

Reading Research Quarterly ↗
Levine (2014)

Making interpretation visible with an affect-based strategy

Reading Research Quarterly ↗
Levine (2015)

Helping high school students read like experts: Affective evaluation, salience, and liter…

Cognition and Instruction ↗
Lewis (2011)

Topoi and literary interpretation: The effects of a critical reading and writing interven…

Contemporary Educational Psychology ↗
Marlatt (2018)

Literary analysis using Minecraft: An Asian American youth crafts her literacy identity

Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy ↗
Penrose (1994)

10.2307/358762

Reading and writing without authority College Composition and Communication ↗
Rainey (2017)

Disciplinary literacy in English language arts: Exploring the social and problem-based na…

Reading Research Quarterly ↗
Rosenblatt (2013)

The transactional theory of reading and writing

Theoretical models and processes of reading ↗
Storm (2018)

Striving toward woke English teaching and learning

English Journal ↗
West (2008)

Weblogs and literary response: Socially situated identities and hybrid social languages i…

Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy ↗
Yi (2010)

Adolescent multilingual writers’ transitions across in- and out-of-school writing contexts

Journal of Second Language Writing ↗

CrossRef global citation count: 4 View in citation network →