Journal of Technical Writing and Communication Jan 2008

Darwin's Dilemma: Science in the Public Forum

Richard Johnson-Sheehan Purdue University West Lafayette ; Lawrence Morgan

Abstract

This article explores the basis of the public debate between Darwinian evolution and creationism. Using dramatic analysis, we show that the source for the debate is due to what we call “Darwin's Dilemma,” which is found in Darwin's Origin of Species. In the Origin, Darwin extends the mechanistic metaphor featured in Enlightenment science by devising the concept of “natural selection.” In the process, however, he also ascribes a motive to nature, which moves his theory outside the boundaries of Enlightenment science. We show that he is aware of this dilemma in his theory, and that he tries to pass it off as a metaphorical maneuver for the sake of brevity. Darwin's inability to resolve this dilemma, however, opens the door for purveyors of creationism and intelligent design. Indeed, much of the debate today over Darwinian evolution still pivots on our inability to come to terms with Darwin's dilemma.

Journal
Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Published
2008-01-01
DOI
10.2190/tw.38.1.d
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
argument public rhetoric
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (4)

  1. Sánchez (2017)
    The Roles of Technical Communication Researchers in Design Scholarship
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  2. Rademaekers et al. (2014)
    Framing and Re-Framing in Environmental Science: Explaining Climate Change to t…
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  3. Yu (2011)
    Visualizing Banking and Financial Products: A Comparative Study of Chinese and …
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  4. Journet (2010)
    The Resources of Ambiguity: Context, Narrative, and Metaphor in Richard Dawkins…
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication

References (35) · 2 in this index

  1. Dennett D. (1995)
    Darwin's Dangerous Idea
  2. 10.1146/annurev.anthro.26.1.263
     ↗
  3. Beem K., Poll: A Belief in God and Evolution; Kansans Hold Mixed Views on State Board's Action, The Kansas Ci…
  4. Blakesley D. (2002)
    The Elements of Dramatism
  5. Burke K. (1945)
    A Grammar of Motives
Show all 35 →
  1. Bowler P. (1996)
    Charles Darwin: The Man and His Influence
  2. Huxley T. H. (1887)
    The Life and Letters of Charles Darwin
  3. Lamarck J. B. (1984)
    Zoological Philosopy: An Exposition with Regard to the Natural History of Animals
  4. Darwin E. (1792)
    Zoonomia; or The Laws of Organic Life
  5. Chambers R. (1844)
    Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation
  6. Newton I. (1999)
    The Principia: Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy
  7. Darwin C. (2001)
    On the Origin of Species (1859), Darwin
  8. Ospovat D. (1981)
    The Development of Darwin's Scientific Theory
  9. Campbell J. A. (2003)
    Darwinism, Design and Public Education
  10. Darwin C. (1872)
    On the Origin of Species
  11. 10.4159/harvard.9780674063426
     ↗
  12. Gould S. J. (1980)
    The Panda's Thumb
  13. Morris H. (1974)
    Creation: Arts, Facts, Impacts
  14. Morris H. (1982)
    What is Creation Science?
  15. Frair W. (1983)
    A Case for Creation
  16. Gish D. (1982)
    Evolution: The Challenge of the Fossil Record
  17. Miller K. (1999)
    Finding Darwin's God
  18. Paley W. (1802)
    Natural Theology
  19. Behe M. (1996)
    Darwin's Black Box
  20. Johnson P. (1993)
    Darwin on Trial
  21. Gross A. (1996)
    The Rhetoric of Science
  22. Dawkins R. (1986)
    The Blind Watchmaker
  23. Dawkins R. (1976)
    The Selfish Gene
  24. Jones S. (2000)
    Darwin's Ghost
  25. Johnson-Sheehan R. (2008)
    Writing Proposals
  26. Johnson-Sheehan R. (2007)
    Technical Communication Today
  27. Johnson-Sheehan R., A Primer on Writing Grants, in Read Science Group Academic Sourcebook, June 16–20, 2006.
  28. Johnson-Sheehan et al. (2004)
    Changing the Center of Gravity: Collaborative Writing Program Administration in…
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  29. Johnson-Sheehan et al. (2003)
    Guest Editors' Column
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  30. Morgan Lawrence
    Weber Studies
CrossRef global citation count: 4 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Argumentation Feb 2026
    The Influence of Justification Content and Argument Source on Perceived Argument Quality ↗
    Kaisa Herne; Josefina Sipinen; Peter Söderlund; Elina Kestilä-Kekkonen
    argument public rhetoric
  2. Res Rhetorica Jan 2026
    Politicians’ privacy management in social media as a tool for shaping ethos ↗
    Anna M. Kiełbiewska
    rhetorical criticism argument social media public rhetoric
  3. Argumentation Dec 2025
    Questions as Elements of Argumentation in Political Debates ↗
    Daniel Ziembicki
    discourse analysis argument artificial intelligence public rhetoric
  4. Philosophy & Rhetoric Apr 2025
    What It Takes to Want to Turn to Others ↗
    Nirvana Tanoukhi
    argument public rhetoric
  5. Philosophy & Rhetoric Apr 2025
    Aristotle: Art of Rhetoric ↗
    Peter A. O’Connell
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism revision argument multilingual writers grammar and mechanics public rhetoric editorial matter