Argumentation Dec 2024 Open Access

Multimodal Argument as Dialogue

Jan Albert van Laar University of Groningen

Abstract

AbstractAccording to a dialectical approach to argumentation, a single argument can be seen as a dialogical "Why? Because!" sequence. Does this also apply to multimodal arguments? This paper focuses on multimodal arguments with a predominantly visual character and shows that dialogues are helpful for identifying and reconstructing arguments in multimodal communication. To include nonverbal arguments in dialectical argumentation theory, it is proposed to regard dialogue as mode-fluid. The account of multimodal argument as dialogue will be compared with Champagne and Pietarinen’s account of visual argument as movement.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2024-12-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-024-09639-8
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
argument multimodality
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (1)

  1. Grzenkowicz (2026)
    Non-verbal Artifacts and Propositionality: Adjusting Speech Act Theory To Accom…
    Argumentation

References (44) · 9 in this index

  1. A Abdel-Raheem (2023)
    Abdel-Raheem, A. 2023. Do political cartoons and illustrations have their own specialized forms for warnings,…
    Social Semiotics  ↗
  2. Adsoftheworld (no date). Don’t Drive Drunk Foundation: Beer, Champagne, Vodka. Retrieved, September 18 2023 f…
  3. Aikin et al. (2023)
    On Halting Meta-argument with Para-Argument
    Argumentation
  4. N Asher (2003)
    Logics of conversation
  5. J Bateman (2018)
    Bateman, J. 2018. Position paper on argument and multimodality. International Review of Pragmatics 10: 294–308.
    International Review of Pragmatics  ↗
Show all 44 →
  1. Blair (2015)
    Probative Norms for Multimodal Visual Arguments
    Argumentation
  2. J Casey (2020)
    Casey, J. 2020. Adversariality and Argumentation. Informal Logic 40: 77–108.
    Adversariality and Argumentation. Informal Logic
  3. Champagne et al. (2020)
    Why Images Cannot be Arguments, But Moving Ones Might
    Argumentation
  4. I Dove (2012)
    Topical Themes in Argumentation Theory
  5. C Dutilh Novaes (2020)
    The Dialogical Roots of Deduction: Historical, Cognitive, and Philosophical Perspectives …
     ↗
  6. FH van Eemeren (2010)
    Strategic Maneuvering in Argumentative Discourse
     ↗
  7. Eemeren et al. (2023)
    The Pragma-Dialectical Approach to the Fallacies Revisited
    Argumentation
  8. MA Finocchiaro (2006)
    Considering Pragma-Dialectics
  9. D Fleming (1996)
    Fleming, D. 1996. Can pictures be arguments? Argumentation and Advocacy 33: 1–20.
    Argumentation and Advocacy
  10. C Forceville (2020)
    Visual and Multimodal Communication: Applying the Relevance Principle
     ↗
  11. PH Grice (1957)
    Grice, P.H. 1957. Meaning. The Philosophical Review 66: 377–388.
    The Philosophical Review  ↗
  12. L Groarke (2002)
    Advances in Pragma-dialectics
  13. Groarke (2015)
    Going Multimodal: What is a Mode of Arguing and Why Does it Matter?
    Argumentation
  14. CL Hamblin (1970)
    Fallacies
  15. Johnson, R.J. (2003). Why “Visual Arguments” aren’t Arguments. In H.V. Hansen, J.C. Tindale, A. Blair & R.H. …
  16. Kišiček, G. (2020) Listen Carefully! Fallacious Auditory Arguments. In J. Cook (Ed.), In: Proceedings of the …
  17. Kjeldsen (2015)
    The Rhetoric of Thick Representation: How Pictures Render the Importance and St…
    Argumentation
  18. Krabbe, E.C.W. & Walton, D.N. (2011). Formal dialectical systems and their uses in the study of argumentation…
     ↗
  19. ECW Krabbe (2007)
    Krabbe, E.C.W., and J.A. van Laar. 2007. About old and new dialectic: Dialogues, fallacies, and strategies. I…
    Informal Logic  ↗
  20. Laar et al. (2013)
    The Burden of Criticism: Consequences of Taking a Critical Stance
    Argumentation
  21. J Mackenzie (1990)
    Mackenzie, J. 1990. Four dialogue systems. Studia Logica 49: 567–583.
    Studia Logica  ↗
  22. Marraud (2018)
    Arguments from Ostension
    Argumentation
  23. Naess, A. (1966), Communication and Argument: Elements of Applied Semantics. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget; Lond…
  24. de Oliveira Fernandes, D. & S. Oswald (2022). On the rhetorical effectiveness of implicit meaning. Languages, 8
     ↗
  25. Pietarinen, A. (2019). Charles S. Peirce: Logic of the Future, Volume 1. Berlin et al: De Gruyter.
  26. Pinto, R.C. (2001). Argument, Inference and Dialectic: Collected Papers on Informal Logic with an Introductio…
     ↗
  27. EO Popa (2016)
    Popa, E.O. 2016. We have yet to see the “Visual Argument.” Multimodal Communication 5: 79–92.
    Multimodal Communication  ↗
  28. D Serafis (2023)
    Authoritarianism on the Front Page: Multimodal discourse and argumentation in times of mu…
     ↗
  29. Henkemans (2003)
    Complex Argumentation in a Critical Discussion
    Argumentation
  30. JF Sowa (2011)
    Sowa, J.F. 2011. Peirce’s Tutorial on Existential Graphs. Semiotica 186: 345–394.
    Semiotica
  31. D Sperber (1986)
    Relevance: Communication and Cognition
  32. A Tseronis (2018)
    Tseronis, A. 2018. Determining the commitments of image-makers in arguments with multimodal allusions in the …
    International Review of Pragmatics  ↗
  33. DN Walton (1989)
    Question-Reply Argumentation
  34. DN Walton (1990)
    Walton, D.N. 1990. What Is Reasoning? What Is an Argument? The Journal of Philosophy 8: 399–419.
    The Journal of Philosophy  ↗
  35. Walton, D.N. 1998. The new dialectic: Conversational contexts of argument. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
     ↗
  36. Walton, D.N., and E. C. W. Krabbe. 1995. Commitment in dialogue: Basic concepts of interpersonal reasoning. A…
  37. Walton, D.N., C. Reed, and F. Macagno. 2008. Argumentation Schemes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
     ↗
  38. J Wildfeuer (2017)
    Multimodal Argumentation and Rhetoric in Media Genres
  39. Z Zeman (1978)
    Selling the War: Art and Propaganda in World War II
CrossRef global citation count: 4 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Argumentation Jan 2026
    Non-verbal Artifacts and Propositionality: Adjusting Speech Act Theory To Accommodate Multimodal Argumentation ↗
    Maciej Grzenkowicz
    discourse analysis argument multimodality
  2. Res Rhetorica Jun 2025
    Rhetorical and linguistic devices in the argumentation against supporting Ukraine in the radicalized Polish media sphere ↗
    Katarzyna Molek-Kozakowska; Jan Paszczyński
    rhetorical criticism argument multimodality literacy studies
  3. Research in the Teaching of English May 2025
    Argument as Architecture: Constructing an Alternative K–12 Writing Paradigm for Collective Civic Futures ↗
    Nicole Mirra; Kia Turner; Antero Garcia
    discourse analysis writing pedagogy argument assessment multimodality literacy studies
  4. Assessing Writing Apr 2025
    Designing a rating scale for an integrated reading-writing test: A needs-oriented approach ↗
    Aynur Ismayilli Karakoҫ; Peter Gu; Rachael Ruegg
    first-year composition argument assessment empirical research multimodality literacy studies
  5. Pedagogy Oct 2024
    Contributors ↗
    rhetorical criticism first-year composition writing pedagogy basic writing writing across the curriculum graduate education two-year college service learning teacher development revision argument collaborative writing assessment writing program administration multimodality multilingual writers literacy studies race and writing disability studies community literacy editorial matter