Lone Geniuses in Popular Science: The Devaluation of Scientific Consensus

Davida Charney The University of Texas at Austin

Abstract

Popular accounts of scientific discoveries diverge from scholarly accounts, stripping off hedges and promoting short-term social consequences. This case study illustrates how the “horse-race” framing of popular accounts devalues the collective sharing, challenging, and extending of scientific work. In her best-selling Longitude , Dava Sobel (1996) depicts John Harrison's 18th-century invention of a marine chronometer, a ground-breaking precision instrument that eventually allowed sailors to calculate their longitude at sea, as an unequal race with Harrison as beleaguered hero. Sobel represents the demands of the Board of Longitude to test and replicate the chronometer as the obstructionist machinations of an academic elite. Her framing underreports the feasibility of the chronometer and its astronomical rival, the lunar distance method, which each satisfied different criteria. That readers accept Sobel's framing is indicated by an analysis of 187 reviews posted on Amazon.com, suggesting that popular representation of science fuels cynicism in popular and academic forums.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
2003-07-01
DOI
10.1177/0741088303257505
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (8)

  1. Written Communication
  2. Written Communication
  3. Written Communication
  4. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  5. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Show all 8 →
  1. Written Communication
  2. Written Communication
  3. Written Communication

References (42) · 5 in this index

  1. Atkinson D. (1999). Scientific discourse in sociohistorical context: The Philosophical Trans-actions of the R…
  2. Bazerman C. (1988). Shaping written knowledge. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
  3. 10.1353/pbm.1997.0067
  4. Charney D. (in press). Empiricism is not a four-letter word. In S. Selber & J. Johnson-Eilola (Eds.) Central …
  5. 10.2307/358602
Show all 42 →
  1. Written Communication
  2. (Reprinted from Written Communication, 3, 275-296, 1986)
    Written Communication
  3. Francis, D. H., & Sandberg, W. R. (2000). Friendship within entrepreneurial teams and its association with te…
    Entrepreneurship: Theory and Practice
  4. Gladwell M. (2002 May 27). The televisionary: Big business and the myth of the lone inventor. The New Yorker 112.
  5. Gleick J. (1987). Chaos: Making a new science. New York: Penguin.
  6. Gould R. (1960). The Marine Chronometer. London: Holland Press. (Original work published in 1923)
  7. Howse D. (1989). Nevil Maskelyne: The seaman's astronomer. Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press.
  8. 10.3138/cjh.36.2.283
  9. John Harrison and the Longitude Problem. (2002 January 23). Royal Observatory Greenwich. Available from http:…
  10. Katz S. B. (1992). Narration technical communication and culture: The soul of a new machine as narrative roma…
  11. Written Communication
  12. Kidder T. (1982). The soul of a new machine. New York: Avon.
  13. Kitcher P. (1993). The advancement of science: Science without legend objectivity without illusions. New York…
  14. 10.1177/016224390202700102
  15. Lanham F. (1998 Oct 4). Dava Sobel: The illustrated longitude. The Houston Chronicle p. 5.
  16. Mahoney M. (1993). Longitude in the context of the history of science. In W. Andrewes (Ed.) The quest for lon…
  17. Written Communication
  18. Myers, G. (1985b). Nineteenth century popularizations of thermodynamics and the rhetoric of social prophecy. …
    Victorian Studies
  19. 10.1177/1461445603005002006
  20. Neergaard L. (2002 Oct 10). Mixed messages continue on breast cancer. The Cincinnati Post p. B1.
  21. Nelkin D. (1995). Selling science: How the press covers science and technology (Rev. ed.). New York: Freeman.
  22. Observations of latitude and longitude at all remarkable points. (1996 June 19). An exhibition of maps and na…
  23. Paul D. (2002). Spreading chaos: The role of popular scientific literature in interdisciplinary diffusion. Pa…
  24. Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  25. 10.1093/ei/cbg012
  26. Popper K. (1971). The open society and its enemies (2 vols. 5th ed.). Princeton NJ: Prince-ton University Press.
  27. Porter T. (1995). Trust in numbers: The pursuit of objectivity in science and public life. Prince-ton NJ: Pri…
  28. Professions in 18th century Britain. (2000 February). History faculty lecture notes Warwick University. Retri…
  29. 10.1177/146488490100200310
  30. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  31. Sobel D. (1996). Longitude: The true story of a lone genius who solved the greatest scientific problem of his…
  32. Sobel D. & Andrewes W. J. H. (1998). The illustrated longitude. New York: Walker.
  33. 10.1086/235069
  34. Sturridge C. (Writer/Director). (2000). Longitude [Motion picture]. United Kingdom: Granada Film Production.
  35. 10.1111/j.1741-5705.2003.tb00020.x
  36. Watson J. (1980). The double helix: A personal account of the discovery of the structure of DNA. In G. Stent …
  37. Williams C. J. (2001 December 2). Mistakes and oversights: Occasionally those judging physics chemistry and m…