What Are Students being Taught about the Ethics of Technical Communication?: An Analysis of the Ethical Discussions Presented in Four Textbooks

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication Oct 1998

What Are Students being Taught about the Ethics of Technical Communication?: An Analysis of the Ethical Discussions Presented in Four Textbooks

Kris K. Hartung Boise State University

Abstract

This article analyzes the ethical perspectives of four technical communication textbooks. It argues that the authors do not engage in ethical inquiry as it is defined traditionally. Instead, they engage in the ethics-related activities known as moral casuistry, which deduces moral judgements, and moralism, which prescribes moral principles. The authors deduce and prescribe, but they do not justify or critically examine the underlying principles of morality. The analysis also suggests that at least two of the textbooks introduce ideas that are either inconsistent with traditional ethical theories or are subject to the objections that philosophers have raised against them in previous ethical inquiries. Finally, the article recommends that authors avoid approaches that are either strictly rhetorical or provide no ethical guidelines for students. They should avoid resorting to cursory accounts of traditional ethical theories because briefly mentioning philosophers' ethical approaches has very little practical value. They should also treat moral principles, not as objective and self-evident statements of fact, but as evaluative assumptions whose truth-values and meaning are both tentative and lacking universal agreement.

Journal: Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Published: 1998-10-01
DOI: 10.2190/g08w-fd0r-vnpb-ahaw
Open Access: Closed
Topics: technical communication multilingual writers

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (3)

Sánchez (2019)

Trans Students’ Right to Their Own Gender in Professional Communication Courses…

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Chong (2016)

The Pedagogy of Usability: An Analysis of Technical Communication Textbooks, An…

Technical Communication Quarterly
Dombrowski (2000)

Ethics and Technical Communication: The Past Quarter Century

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication

Cites in this index (6)

McKenna et al. (1997)

A Survey of Recent Technical Writing Textbooks

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Dragga (1997)

A Question of Ethics: Lessons from Technical Communicators on the Job

Technical Communication Quarterly
Possin (1991)

Ethical Argumentation

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Sawyer (1988)

The Argument about Ethics, Fairness, or Right and Wrong

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Hall et al. (1987)

Integrating Professional Ethics into the Technical Writing Course

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication

Show all 6 →

Rubens (1981)

Reinventing the Wheel?: Ethics for Technical Communicators

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication

Also cites 3 works outside this index ↓

10.1109/47.650006

↗
10.1109/47.222686

↗
10.2307/378062

↗

CrossRef global citation count: 5 View in citation network →