Research in the Teaching of English May 2024

College Composition Graduate Instructors’ Development of Conceptual and Practical Tools for Responding to Student Writing

Carolyn Wisniewski University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign

Abstract

Recent scholarship has demonstrated the need for criticality toward writing assessments that privilege standard language ideologies and correctness-based approaches. However, teachers continue to experience discrepancies between their intentions and actions, struggling to address both content and form in facilitative, constructive commentary. This study uses the activity theory framework of pedagogical tools, composed of conceptual and practical tools, to analyze through interviews and commented-on papers how two college composition graduate instructors responded to student writing. This study finds that while one teacher held and enacted consistent and congruent pedagogical tools grounded in sociocultural theories of writing development, the other experienced entrenched conflict between competing beliefs about evaluative and process-oriented purposes for teaching writing. These contrastive experiences illustrate how instructors’ development of pedagogical tools is mediated by interactions between their epistemological orientations and language ideologies, reinforcing the need to surface tacit beliefs about Standardized English and academic writing. This study concludes with recommendations for productive intervention in novice composition teachers’ development of response practices.

Journal
Research in the Teaching of English
Published
2024-05-01
DOI
10.58680/rte2024584353
Open Access
Closed
Topics
writing pedagogy assessment genre theory

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

Cites in this index (11)

  1. Vossoughi et al. (2021)
    Writing as a Social Act: The Feedback Relation as a Context for Political and E…
    Research in the Teaching of English
  2. Zuidema et al. (2016)
    Resources Preservice Teachers Use to Think about Student Writing
    Research in the Teaching of English
  3. Orzulak (2015)
    Disinviting Deficit Ideologies: Beyond “That’s Standard,” “That’s Racist,” and …
    Research in the Teaching of English
  4. Woodard (2015)
    The Dialogic Interplay of Writing and Teaching Writing: Teacher-Writers’ Talk a…
    Research in the Teaching of English
  5. Canagarajah (2013)
    Negotiating Translingual Literacy: An Enactment
    Research in the Teaching of English
Show all 11 →
  1. McQuitty (2012)
    Emerging Possibilities: A Complex Account of Learning to Teach Writing
    Research in the Teaching of English
  2. Newell et al. (2009)
    A Longitudinal Study of Consequential Transitions in the Teaching of Literature
    Research in the Teaching of English
  3. Kynard (2006)
    Y’all Are Killin’ Me Up in Here: Response Theory from a Newjack Composition Ins…
    Teaching English in the Two-Year College
  4. Smith (1997)
    The Genre of the End Comment: Conventions in Teacher Responses to Student Writing
    College Composition and Communication
  5. SPERLING et al. (1987)
    A Good Girl Writes Like a Good Girl
    Written Communication
  6. Sommers (1982)
    Responding to Student Writing
    College Composition and Communication
Also cites 18 works outside this index ↓
  1. Ascenzi-Moreno (2021)
    Always at the bottom: Ideologies in assessment of emergent bilinguals
    Journal of Literacy Research  ↗
  2. Baker-Bell (2020)
    Linguistic justice: Black language, literacy, identity, and pedagogy
     ↗
  3. Ball (1997)
    Expanding the dialogue on culture as a critical component when assessing writing
    Assessing Writing  ↗
  4. Ferris (2011)
    Treatment of error in second language student writing
     ↗
  5. Ferris (2011)
    Responding to L2 students in college writing classes: Teacher perspectives
    TESOL Quarterly  ↗
  6. Flores (2020)
    From academic language to language architecture: Challenging raciolinguistic ideologies i…
    Theory Into Practice  ↗
  7. Flores (2015)
    Undoing appropriateness: Raciolinguistic ideologies and language diversity in education
    Harvard Educational Review  ↗
  8. Grossman (1999)
    Appropriating tools for teaching English: A theoretical framework for research on learnin…
    American Journal of Education  ↗
  9. Lippi-Green (2012)
    English with an accent: Language, ideology, and discrimination in the United States
     ↗
  10. Metz (2021)
    The dominant school language narrative: Unpacking English teachers’ language ideologies
    Linguistic Society of America  ↗
  11. Montgomery (2007)
    Teacher-written feedback: Student perceptions, teacher self-assessment, and actual teache…
    Journal of Second Language Writing  ↗
  12. Myers (2016)
    What about writing? A national exploratory study of writing instruction in teacher prepar…
    Literacy Research and Instruction  ↗
  13. Newell (2015)
    Teaching and learning argumentative writing in high school English language arts classrooms
     ↗
  14. Sieben (2017)
    Building hopeful secondary school writers through effective feedback strategies
    English Journal  ↗
  15. Simon (2013)
    “Starting with what is”: Exploring response and responsibility to student writing through…
    English Education  ↗
  16. Smagorinsky (2003)
    The twisting path of concept development in learning to teach
    Teachers College Record  ↗
  17. Smagorinsky (2013)
    Competing centers of gravity: A beginning English teacher’s socialization process within …
    English Education  ↗
  18. Smitherman (2017)
    Raciolinguistics, “mis-education,” and language arts teaching in the 21st century
    Language Arts Journal of Michigan  ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 1 View in citation network →

Related Articles

  1. Written Communication Jan 2026
    Writing Instruction for Adult L2-Learners: A Case Study From Three Swedish Classrooms ↗
    Clara Palm; Ann-Christin Randahl; Liss Kerstin Sylvén
    writing pedagogy genre theory qualitative research multimodality
  2. Written Communication Apr 2025
    Effects of Online Professional Development on First-Grade Writing Instruction: Coaching plus Manual Improves Teachers’ Implementation, Confidence, and Students’ Writing Quality ↗
    Zoi A. Traga Philippakos; Louis Rocconi; Ashley Voggt
    writing pedagogy genre theory multimodality affect and writing
  3. College Composition and Communication Sep 2023
    Engaging Assessment Counterstories through a Cultural Rhetorics Framework ↗
    Stephanie West-Puckett; Nicole I. Caswell; William P. Banks
    writing pedagogy writing program administration assessment multimodality gender and writing multilingual writers affect and writing
  4. Written Communication Jan 2023
    A Systematic Review on Inquiry-Based Writing Instruction in Tertiary Settings ↗
    Vivien Lin; Neil E. Barrett; Gi-Zen Liu; Howard Hao-Jan Chen
    writing pedagogy genre theory multimodality scientific writing multilingual writers
  5. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication Jan 2019
    Testing the Test: Expanding the Dialogue on Technical Writing Assessment in the Academy and Workplace ↗
    Lindsay Tanner; Jon Balzotti
    writing pedagogy assessment qualitative research quantitative research technical communication professional writing