Another Voice in the Room: Negotiating Authority in Multidisciplinary Writing Groups

Sara Wilder University of Maryland, College Park

Abstract

Scholarship has shown that writing groups are important sites of authority negotiation for student writers, yet little empirical research has examined how groups negotiate authority through conversation or how these negotiations influence students’ developing expertise. Drawing on observations and interviews of an undergraduate thesis and a graduate dissertation writing group, I use the concept of “presentification” to analyze conversational moments in which group members referenced advisors, “making present” advisor authority to influence group collaborations. Specifically, I analyze these moments to show how writing groups can serve as low-stakes communities in which students negotiate their emerging sense of authority. I found that whereas less experienced writers looked to advisors to solve writing problems and used advisor authority to stand in for disciplinary expertise, more experienced writers voiced advisor guidance to help pose writing problems and negotiate their own stance as disciplinary experts. This study thus theorizes one process through which student writers negotiate emerging authority across sites of literate practice and in collaboration with others who may not themselves be members of the same disciplinary community.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
2021-04-01
DOI
10.1177/0741088320986540
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (4)

  1. Written Communication
  2. Written Communication
  3. Written Communication
  4. Research in the Teaching of English

References (47) · 7 in this index

  1. Aitchison C. (2010). Learning together to publish: Writing group pedagogies for doctoral publishing. In Aitch…
  2. Aitchison C. (2014). Learning from multiple voices: Feedback and authority in doctoral writing groups. In Ait…
  3. Aitchison C., Guerin C. (2014). Writing groups for doctoral education and beyond: Innovations in practice and…
  4. Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  5. Artemeva N. (2009). Stories of becoming: A study of novice engineers learning genres of their profession. In …
Show all 47 →
  1. Benoit-Barné C., Cooren F. (2009). The accomplishment of authority through presentification. Management Commu…
  2. Written Communication
  3. Brooks-Gillies M., Garcia E. G., Manthey K. (2020). Making do by making space: Multidisciplinary graduate wri…
  4. Handbook of emergent methods
  5. Communication as organizing: Empirical and theoretical explorations in the dynamic of tex…
  6. Cooren F. (2008). The selection of agency as a rhetorical device: Opening up the scene of dialogue through ve…
  7. Cooren F., Brummans H. J. M., Charrieras D. (2008). The coproduction of organizational presence: A study of M…
  8. Worlds apart: Acting and writing in academic and workplace contexts
  9. Research in the Teaching of English
  10. The Writing Center Journal
  11. Written Communication
  12. Emerson R., Fretz R., Shaw L. (2011). Writing ethnographic fieldnotes (2nd ed.). University of Chicago Press.…
  13. Practicing research in writing studies: Reflexive and ethically responsible research
  14. Writing groups: History, theory, and implications
  15. Writing groups inside and outside the classroom
  16. Gradin S., Pauley-Gose J., Stewart C. (2006). Disciplinary differences, rhetorical resonances: Graduate writi…
  17. College Composition and Communication
  18. Undergraduate research in English studies
  19. Production of presence: What meaning cannot convey
  20. Praxis
  21. Writing Center Journal
  22. Lassig C. J., Dillon L. H., Diezmann C. M. (2013). Student or scholar? Transforming identities through a rese…
  23. 10.1017/CBO9780511815355
  24. Leaving the ivory tower: The causes and consequences of departure from doctoral study
  25. Lovitts B. E. (2008). The transition to independent research: Who makes it, who doesn’t, and why. The Journal…
  26. Mackiewicz J., Thompson I. K. (2015). Talk about writing: The tutoring strategies of experienced writing cent…
  27. Qualitative research: A guide to design and implementation
  28. Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook
  29. Writing groups inside and outside the classroom
  30. Paré A. (2011). Speaking of writing: Supervisory feedback and the dissertation. In McAlpine L., Amundsen C. (…
  31. Paré A. (2014). Writing together for many reasons: Theoretical and historical perspectives. In Aitchison C., …
  32. Paré A., Stark-Meyerring D., McAlpine L. (2011). Knowledge and identity work in the supervision of doctoral s…
  33. Praxis
  34. Written Communication
  35. Research in the Teaching of English
  36. Writing/disciplinarity: A sociohistoric account of literate activity in the academy
  37. Expanding literate landscapes: Persons, practices, and sociohistoric perspectives of disc…
  38. The coding manual for qualitative researchers
  39. Writing studies research in practice: Methods and methodologies
  40. Across property lines: Textual ownership in writing groups
  41. Wenger E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge University Press. https…
  42. Writing Lab Newsletter