Written Communication Jul 1993

The Promise of Writing to Learn

JOHN M. ACKERMAN

Abstract

This essay situates the phenomenon of writing and learning in historical, pedagogical, and theoretical frameworks to isolate write-to-learn methods derived from the “British model” of language and learning. Writing as a mode of learning has maintained its status partly because of the rise of rhetoric and composition as a specialized field and because cross-curricular writing instruction has been offered as one answer to alleged “crises” of literate standards and competence in public and higher education. Generally, the author claims that typical accounts of writing as a unique tool for promoting learning ignore the complexities of cultures, classrooms, assignments, and other media that might equally facilitate learning. The author's reading of 35 studies of writing and learning is that they do not provide the long-sought empirical validation of writing as a mode of learning. He argues that this research is grounded in the same assumptions about language and learning as are common in the lore and practice of “writing across the curriculum” (WAC) and writing process approaches, and as a result, the issue of writing and learning has been framed wrongly. The confounds within this body of research are many of the cognitive and situational variables that would support a model of writing and learning that is compatible with the diverse discourses and experiences within and across institutions.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
1993-07-01
DOI
10.1177/0741088393010003002
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
rhetorical criticism writing pedagogy writing across the curriculum literacy studies
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (14)

  1. Alexander et al. (2023)
    Confronting the Challenges of Undergraduates’ Argumentation Writing in a “Learn…
    Written Communication
  2. Gere et al. (2019)
    Writing and Conceptual Learning in Science: An Analysis of Assignments
    Written Communication
  3. Mills et al. (2014)
    Time, Space, and Text in the Elementary School Digital Writing Classroom
    Written Communication
  4. Prendergast (2013)
    Writing and Learning in View of the Lab: Why "They" Might be Right
    Literacy in Composition Studies
  5. Wolfe et al. (2009)
    Argumentation Schema and the Myside Bias in Written Argumentation
    Written Communication
Show all 14 →
  1. Shaver et al. (2009)
    Making the Rhetorical Sell
    Pedagogy
  2. Carter et al. (2007)
    Writing to Learn by Learning to Write in the Disciplines
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  3. Thompson et al. (2000)
    Learning-To-Communicate and Communicating-To-Learn in Veterinary Medicine: A Su…
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  4. HILGERS et al. (1999)
    “As You're Writing, You Have these Epiphanies”: What College Students Say about…
    Written Communication
  5. YOUNG et al. (1998)
    Writing from Primary Documents: A Way of Knowing in History
    Written Communication
  6. SMAGORINSKY (1997)
    Personal Growth in Social Context: A High School Senior's Search for Meaning in…
    Written Communication
  7. MEDWAY (1996)
    Virtual and Material Buildings: Construction and Constructivism in Architecture…
    Written Communication
  8. Spinuzzi (1996)
    Pseudotransactionality, Activity Theory, and Professional Writing Instruction
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  9. SMAGORINSKY et al. (1994)
    Cultural Tools and the Classroom Context: An Exploration of an Artistic Respons…
    Written Communication

References (134) · 15 in this index

  1. Ackerman (1991)
    Reading, Writing, and Knowing: The Role of Disciplinary Knowledge in Comprehens…
    Research in the Teaching of English
  2. A Language for Life (Bullock Report)
  3. Allen, D.
    English teaching since 1965: How much growth?
  4. Anderson, J.
    The architecture of cognition
     ↗
  5. Anderson, R.
    Handbook of reading research
Show all 134 →
  1. Applebee, A.
    Tradition and reform in the teaching of English: A history
  2. Applebee, A.
    Writing in the secondary school: English and the content areas
  3. 10.3102/00346543054004577
     ↗
  4. Applebee, A.
    The teaching of writing
  5. Barr, M.
    What's going on? Language learning episodes in British and American classrooms, grades 4-13
  6. Bartholomae, D.
    When a writer can't write: Studies in writers block and other composing process problems
  7. Berlin, J.
    Rhetoric and reality: Writing instruction in American colleges, 1900-1985
  8. Bizzell et al. (1985)
    Writing‐across‐the‐curriculum textbooks: A bibliographic essay
    Rhetoric Review
  9. Bloom, A.
    The closing of the American mind
     ↗
  10. Brandt, D.
    Literacy as involvement: The acts of writers, readers, and texts
  11. BRANDT (1992)
    The Cognitive as the Social: An Ethnomethodological Approach to Writing Process…
    Written Communication
  12. 10.1016/0361-476X(79)90069-9
     ↗
  13. 10.1037/0022-0663.73.2.242
     ↗
  14. Britton, J.
    Language and learning
  15. Britton (1990)
    James Britton: An Impressionistic Sketch: A Response
    College Composition and Communication
  16. Britton, J.
    The development of writing abilities 11-18
  17. 10.3102/0013189X018001032
     ↗
  18. Bruner, J.
    Toward a theory of instruction
  19. 10.2307/357655
     ↗
  20. 10.2307/357812
     ↗
  21. Colvin-Murphy, C. (1987)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  22. Copeland, K.
    annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association
  23. Corbett, E.P.J.
    Classical rhetoric for the modern student
  24. Davis, R.
    Teaching for literacy: Reflections on the Bullock Report
  25. 10.17763/haer.58.3.c43481778r528qw4
     ↗
  26. Dewey, J.
    John Dewey: The latter works, 1925-1933
  27. Durst (1987)
    Cognitive and Linguistic Demands of Analytic Writing
    Research in the Teaching of English
  28. Dyer, D. (1988)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  29. 10.2307/357972
     ↗
  30. Emig, J.
    The composing processes of twelfth graders
  31. 10.2307/356095
     ↗
  32. 10.3102/00346543054004525
     ↗
  33. Faber, J. (1987)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  34. Fillion, B.
    To compose
  35. Flower, L.
    The construction of negotiated meaning: A social cognitive theory of writing
  36. Fulwiler, T.
    The journal book
  37. Gardner, H.
    The mind's new science: A history of the cognitive revolution
  38. Gere, A.
    Roots in the sawdust: Writing to learn across the disciplines
  39. 10.1086/461607
     ↗
  40. Graff, G. (1990)
    10.1215/00382876-89-1-51
    The Southern Atlantic Quarterly  ↗
  41. Graff, H.
    The literacy myth: Literacy and social structure in the nineteenth-century city
  42. Graves, D.
    Balance the basics: Let them write
  43. Greene (1993)
    The Role of Task in the Development of Academic Thinking through Reading and Wr…
    Research in the Teaching of English
  44. Griffin, C.
    Teaching writing in all disciplines: New directions for teaching and learning (#12)
  45. 10.2307/357858
     ↗
  46. Grossman, J. (1988)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  47. Hall, C. (1984)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  48. 10.1080/10862968709547610
     ↗
  49. Heath, S.
    Ways with words: Language, life, and work in communities and classrooms
  50. Hillock, G.
    Research on written composition: New directions for teaching. ERIC Clearinghouse on Readi…
  51. Hirsch, E.
    Cultural literacy: What every American needs to know
  52. Horowitz, R.
    Comprehending oral and written language
     ↗
  53. 10.1002/tea.3660220607
     ↗
  54. Hoye, M. (1988)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  55. Johnstone, A. (1988)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  56. Kelley, K. (1984)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  57. Kelly, G.
    The psychology of personal constructs
  58. Kinneavy, J. (1983)
    Association of Departments of English Bulletin
  59. Kinneavy, J.
    Teaching composition: Twelve bibliographic essays
  60. 10.2307/376844
     ↗
  61. 10.2307/747918
     ↗
  62. Langer, J. (1986)
    Journal of Reading
  63. Langer, J.
    How writing shapes thinking: A study of teaching and learning
  64. Lave, J.
    Cognition in practice
  65. Lawrence, S. (1988)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  66. Lloyd-Jones, R.
    English coalition conference: Democracy through language
  67. Luria, A.
    Cognitive development: Its cultural and social foundations
  68. Macrorie, K.
    Telling writing
     ↗
  69. Marland, M.
    Language across the curriculum
  70. Marshall (1987)
    The Effects of Writing on Students’ Understanding of Literary Texts
    Research in the Teaching of English
  71. Martin, N.
    Writing across the curriculum: Pamphlets from the Schools Council/London Institute of Edu…
  72. Martin, N.
    Writing and learning across the curriculum 11-16: Schools Council Project
  73. McCarthy (1987)
    A Stranger in Strange Lands: A College Student Writing Across the Curriculum
    Research in the Teaching of English
  74. McGINLEY et al. (1989)
    Traversing the Topical Landscape: Reading and Writing as Ways of Knowing
    Written Communication
  75. McLaughlin, D.
    When literacy empowers: An ethnography of uses for English and Navajo print
  76. McLeod, S.
    Strengthening programs for writing across the curriculum: New directions for teaching and…
  77. McLeod
    Strengthening programs for writing across the curriculum: New directions for teaching and…
  78. Miller, S.
    Textual carnivals: The politics of composition
  79. Moffett, J.
    Teaching the universe of discourse
  80. Moliterno, A. (1988)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  81. Moore, R. (1987)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  82. Myers, M.
    The teacher-researcher: How to study writing in the classroom. ERIC Clearinghouse
  83. National Assessment of Educational Progress
    Reading, thinking, and writing
  84. Newell (1984)
    Learning from Writing in Two Content Areas: A Case Study/Protocol Analysis
    Research in the Teaching of English
  85. Newell, G.
    annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association
  86. Newell, G.
    annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association
  87. 10.1080/10862968909547657
     ↗
  88. NEWELL et al. (1989)
    The Effects of Writing on Learning from Expository Text
    Written Communication
  89. Nostrand, A. (1979)
    Social Education
  90. Ogbu, J.
    Minority education and caste: The American system in cross-cultural perspective
  91. 10.17763/haer.47.3.8840364413869005
     ↗
  92. Ong, W.
    Orality and literacy
  93. Parker (1985)
    The "Language across the Curriculum" Movement: A Brief Overview and Bibliography
    College Composition and Communication
  94. Pearse, S.
    Roots in the sawdust: Writing to learn across the disciplines
  95. PENROSE (1992)
    To Write or Not to Write: Effects of Task and Task Interpretation on Learning t…
    Written Communication
  96. Philips, S.
    Functions of language in the classroom
  97. Raines (1990)
    Is There a Writing Program in This College? Two Hundred and Thirty-Six Two-Year…
    College Composition and Communication
  98. Reilly, J. M.
    annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association
  99. Reynolds, F. (1987)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  100. Rogoff, B.
    Apprenticeship in thinking
     ↗
  101. Rose, B. (1989)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  102. Rose, M.
    Lives on the boundary: The struggles and achievements of America's underprepared
  103. Rumelhart, D.
    Theoretical issues in reading comprehension
  104. Rumelhart, D.
    Cognitive skills and their acquisition
  105. Russell, D.
    Writing in the academic disciplines, 1870-1990: A curricular history
  106. Sapir, E.
    Culture, language and personality
  107. Schumacher et al. (1991)
    Conceptualizing and Measuring Knowledge Change Due to Writing
    Research in the Teaching of English
  108. Scribner, S.
    The psychology of literacy
     ↗
  109. Selfe, C. (1983)
    Engineering Education
  110. Sharp, J. E. (1987)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  111. Shaughnessy, M.
    Errors and expectations: A guide for the teacher of basic writing
  112. Stout, B.
    Strengthening programs for writing across the curriculum: New directions for teaching and…
  113. Street, B.
    Literacy in theory and practice
  114. Survey of the Profession
  115. Swisher, K. (1989)
    Journal of American Indian Education
  116. Taylor, C. (1984)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  117. Thaiss, C.
    Language across the curriculum in the elementary grades
  118. Thaiss, C.
    Strengthening programs for writing across the curriculum: Teaching and learning (#36)
  119. Tierney, R.
    The teacher-researcher: How to study writing in the classroom
  120. 10.3102/00346543057001051
     ↗
  121. Voss, J.
    The psychology of learning and motivation: Advances in research theory
  122. Vygotsky, L.
    Thought and language
  123. Wason-Ellan, L.
    annual meeting of the National Council of Teachers of English
  124. Weiss, R.
    annual meeting of the National Council of Teachers of English
  125. Wells, C. (1986)
    Dissertation Abstracts International
  126. Witte, S.
    A national survey of college and university teachers of writing
  127. Video Conference
  128. Young, A.
    Writing across the disciplines: Research into practice
  129. Young, R.
    Rhetoric: Discovery and change
CrossRef global citation count: 94 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Pedagogy Oct 2025
    Contributors ↗
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory cultural rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy advanced composition creative writing writing across the curriculum graduate education two-year college service learning teacher development technical communication professional writing labor and working conditions archival research multimodality artificial intelligence literacy studies race and writing gender and writing disability studies literary studies editorial matter
  2. Pedagogy Oct 2024
    Contributors ↗
    rhetorical criticism first-year composition writing pedagogy basic writing writing across the curriculum graduate education two-year college service learning teacher development revision argument collaborative writing assessment writing program administration multimodality multilingual writers literacy studies race and writing disability studies community literacy editorial matter
  3. Pedagogy Oct 2023
    Contributors ↗
    rhetorical criticism first-year composition writing pedagogy writing across the curriculum two-year college teacher development collaborative writing assessment writing centers qualitative research multimodality literacy studies race and writing gender and writing disability studies affect and writing literary studies book reviews editorial matter
  4. Pedagogy Jan 2023
    Contributors ↗
    rhetorical criticism first-year composition writing pedagogy writing across the curriculum graduate education teacher development writing program administration writing centers digital rhetoric literacy studies gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric literary studies book reviews editorial matter
  5. Pedagogy Oct 2022
    Film in the Composition Classroom ↗
    Zack Shaw
    rhetorical criticism writing pedagogy writing across the curriculum teacher development multimodality literacy studies