Students’ Reactions to Teacher Comments: An Exploratory Study

Research in the Teaching of English Feb 1997

Students’ Reactions to Teacher Comments: An Exploratory Study

Richard Straub

Abstract

Current scholarship indicates that most writing students read and make use of teachers’ written comments on their drafts and find some types of comments more helpful than others. But the research is unclear about which comments students find most useful and why. This article presents the results of a survey of 142 first- year college writing students’ perceptions about teacher comments on a writing sample. A 40-item questionnaire was used to investigate students’ reactions to three variables of teacher response: focus, specificity, and mode. The survey found that these college students seemed equally interested in getting responses on global matters of content, purpose, and organization as on local matters of sentence structure, wording, and correctness, but were wary of negative comments about ideas they had already expressed in their text. It also found that these students favored detailed commentary with specific and elaborated comments, but they did not like comments that sought to control their writing or that failed to provide helpful criticism for improving the writing. They most preferred comments that provided employed open questions, or included explanations that guided revision.

Journal: Research in the Teaching of English
Published: 1997-02-01
DOI: 10.58680/rte19973873
Open Access: Closed
Topics: multimodality revision

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (10)

Kramer-Simpson (2018)

Feedback From Internship Mentors in Technical Communication Internships

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Schreibersdorf (2014)

Literary Discipline in the Margins

Pedagogy
Silva (2012)

Camtasia in the Classroom: Student Attitudes and Preferences for Video Commenta…

Computers and Composition
Cope et al. (2011)

Technology-Mediated Writing Assessments: Principles and Processes

Computers and Composition
Taylor (2011)

“I Really Don't Know What He Meant by That”: How Well Do Engineering Students U…

Technical Communication Quarterly

Show all 10 →

Still et al. (2010)

Listening to Students: A Usability Evaluation of Instructor Commentary

Journal of Business and Technical Communication
Cho et al. (2006)

Commenting on Writing

Written Communication
Peterson et al. (2006)

Sixth-Grade Teachers’ Written Comments on Student Writing

Written Communication
Batt (2005)

The Rhetoric of the End Comment

Rhetoric Review
Lunsford (2002)

Contextualizing Toulmin's Model in the Writing Classroom

Written Communication

Cites in this index (0)

No references match articles in this index.

CrossRef global citation count: 91 View in citation network →