Contextualizing Toulmin's Model in the Writing Classroom: A Case Study

Karen J. Lunsford University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign

Abstract

Although Toulmin models of argumentation are pervasive in composition textbooks, research on the model's use in writing classrooms has been scarce'typically limited to evaluating how students' essays align with the model's elements (claim, data, warrant, qualifier, rebuttal, backing) construed as objective standards. That approach discounts Toulmin's emphasis on context. In contrast, this study of a major university's summer composition program for high school students employs Wenger's notion of communities of practice and Bakhtin's notion of response to trace how classroom contexts mediate students' and teachers' understandings of a Toulmin model. The article presents a case study of a controversy that emerged when participants attempted to identify the main claim in one student's essay. The controversy arose, the analysis suggests, as participants positioned competing tacit and explicit representations of claims with/against other rhetorical terms (for example, thesis), variously interpreted the assigned tasks, and negotiated over tasks and texts.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
2002-01-01
DOI
10.1177/074108830201900105
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (6)

  1. Written Communication
  2. Argumentation
  3. Written Communication
  4. Written Communication
  5. Technical Communication Quarterly
Show all 6 →
  1. Philosophy & Rhetoric

References (94) · 18 in this index

  1. Speech genres and other late essays
  2. Critical thinking: Reading and writing
  3. Shaping written knowledge: The genre and activity of the experimental article in science
  4. Genre and the new rhetoric
  5. Research in the Teaching of English
Show all 94 →
  1. Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  2. Interacting with audiences: Social influences on the production of scientific writing
  3. After Foucault: Humanistic knowledge, postmodern challenges
  4. Reinventing undergraduate education: A blueprint for America's research universities
  5. Journal of Classroom Interaction
  6. The inventive writer: A discovery-based rhetoric
  7. The power of writing, with additional readings
  8. 10.1177/016146819810000205
    Teachers College Record  
  9. The genre of argument
  10. Clauss, P. J. (1999). Stephen Toulmin's The uses of argument: …
  11. annual convention of the Conference on College Composition and Communication
  12. Process, form, and substance: A rhetoric for advanced writers
  13. Writing across languages: Analysis of L2 text
  14. Research in the Teaching of English
  15. Writing across languages and cultures: Issues in contrastive rhetoric
  16. The elements of reasoning
  17. Crammond, J. G. (1997). An analysis of argument structure in expert and student persuas…
  18. Written Communication
  19. Collaboration and conflict: A contextual exploration of group writing and positive emphasis
  20. The aims of argument: A rhetoric and reader
  21. Written Communication
  22. Research in the Teaching of English
  23. Written Communication
  24. Good reasons
  25. Research in the Teaching of English
  26. Argument revisited, argument redefined: Negotiating meaning in the composition classroom
  27. Analysing argumentation in planning and public policy: Assessing, improving and transcend…
  28. Academic literacy and the nature of expertise: Reading, writing, and knowing in academic …
  29. Rethinking context: Language as an interactive phenomenon
  30. Successful writing: A rhetoric for advanced composition
  31. A pedagogy of possibility: Bakhtinian perspectives on composition studies
  32. A teaching subject: Composition since 1966
  33. The Simon & Schuster guide to writing
  34. Arguing in communities
  35. Advances in writing research: Vol. 2. Writing in academic disciplines
  36. Essential strategies of argument
  37. Howto lie with statistics
  38. annual meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching
  39. 10.2307/1389288
  40. The Bedford reader
  41. 10.1080/00220671.1992.9944434
  42. Child Study Journal
  43. Rhetoric and style: Strategies for advanced writers
  44. Four worlds of writing
  45. 10.1017/CBO9780511815355
  46. Everything's an argument
  47. For argument's sake: A guide to writing effective arguments
  48. Research in the Teaching of English
  49. annual convention of the Conference on College Composition and Communication
  50. From inquiry to argument
  51. The informed argument
  52. Textual carnivals: The politics of composition
  53. Validating holistic scoring for writing assessment: Theoretical and empirical foundations
  54. National assessment of educational progress (NAEP) 1998: Writing report card for the nati…
  55. Effective argument: A writer's guide with readings
  56. Developmental pragmatics
  57. Research in the Teaching of English
  58. Journal of Advanced Composition
  59. Audience and rhetoric: An archaeological composition of the discourse community
  60. Written Communication
  61. Writing/disciplinarity: A sociohistoric account of literate activity in the academy
  62. Writing arguments
  63. Research in the Teaching of English
  64. Elements of argument: A textured reader
  65. Research in the Teaching of English
  66. Inside out: A guide to writing
  67. Journal of Teaching Writing
  68. Research in the Teaching of English
  69. Across property lines: Textual ownership in writing groups
  70. The power to persuade
  71. Research in the Teaching of English
  72. Philosophy, rhetoric, literary criticism: (Inter)views
  73. 10.1080/0748763910070408
  74. The uses of argument
  75. Human understanding
  76. Return to reason
  77. An introduction to reasoning
  78. An introduction to reasoning
  79. The call to write
  80. Reading and writing short arguments
  81. Thinking and writing in college: A naturalistic study of students in four disciplines
  82. Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy
  83. 10.1017/CBO9780511803932
  84. Style: Toward clarity and grace
  85. Perspectives on argument
  86. Research in the Teaching of English
  87. 10.2307/249686
  88. Research in the Teaching of English
  89. Assessing Writing