Technical Communication Quarterly

278 articles
Year: Topic: Clear
Export:
rhetorical criticism ×

April 2021

  1. Involving the Audience: A Rhetorical Perspective on Using Social Media to Improve Websites: by Lee-Ann Kastman Breuch. New York, NY: Routledge, 2019, 200 pp., $31.96 (paperback), $19.98 (ebook), ISBN 9780815384540
    Abstract

    Technical and professional communication (TPC) is largely marked by attentiveness to audience. Blakeslee (2009) underscores this facet of the field’s character, urging scholars to explore how the g...

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2021.1888527
  2. “Are You Authorized to Work in the U.S.?” Investigating “Inclusive” Practices in Rhetoric and Technical Communication Job Descriptions
    Abstract

    This paper studies the language of job descriptions in rhetoric and technical and professional communication to explore how this language might be exclusionary of international scholars. Through critical discourse analysis, we reviewed current U.S. labor and immigration laws and contrasted those laws with the language of hiring documents. We found that hiring documents do not always align with U.S. labor and immigration laws and consequently hinder the hiring prospects of international scholars.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2020.1829072
  3. Ridicule, Technical Communication, and Nineteenth-Century Women Performing College Math
    Abstract

    This article examines how nineteenth-century participants in technical and professional communication (TPC) used rhetorical techniques of ridicule to critique audiences’ assumptions and advocate for expanded educational opportunities. Encouraging laughter ostensibly about college mathematics, Vassar students drew on their knowledge of rhetoric and higher education to disrupt audience expectations regarding the gendered identities of mathematician and college student. Using a case study, this article broadly urges the development of the role of humor as a technique in TPC.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2020.1803989

January 2021

  1. The Rhetoric of Online Exclusive Pumping Communities: Tactical Technical Communication as Eschewing Judgment
    Abstract

    ABSTRACT “Exclusive Pumping” straddles the most common infant-feeding methods: breastfeeding and bottle feeding. Exclusive pumpers express milk and feed with bottles. Yet experts rarely recommend exclusive pumping, creating a need for information outside of formal communication outlets. This article argues that exclusive pumping forums are sites of tactical technical communication – operating as “anti-institutional” – and explores these forums as places of inspiration and support, as well as spaces where mothers seek to solve technical feeding problems while avoiding institutional judgment.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2020.1823485

October 2020

  1. Embracing a Metic Lens for Community-based Participatory Research in Technical Communication
    Abstract

    This article responds to recent calls for social justice-oriented work in Technical and professional communication, detailing moments from a participatory photovoice project with community organizers working toward a more just regional economy. By juxtaposing participatory action research methods and the rhetorical concept of metis, or embodied, rhetorical cunning, this article highlights how reversals of power might transform research projects for all parties involved; and how disenfranchised groups might challenge extractive practices draining their communities.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2020.1789745
  2. Rhetorical work in emergency medical services: communicating in the unpredictable workplace: by Elizabeth Angeli, New York, NY, Routledge, 2019, 204 pp., $47.95 (paperback), $47.95 (e-book)
    Abstract

    In an in-depth study of communication in the Emergency Medical Services (EMS) field, Angeli broadens the scope of health and medical professional communication through an analysis of the high stake...

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1689090

July 2020

  1. Sequential Mapping: Using Sequential Rhetoric and Comics Production to Understand UX Design
    Abstract

    Sequential rhetoric can serve as a framework to instruct UX practice (through user story maps) to new learners because it is both approachable and affordable. Sequential rhetoric consists of five main facets that incorporate planning elements (core visual writing and envisaging) and composing elements (interanimation, juxtaquencing, and gestalt closure), which this essay both defines and relates to convergent scholarship. We argue that sequential rhetoric transfers beyond the technical classroom and into the profession itself.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2020.1768292
  2. Lapses in Literacy: Cultural Accessibility in Graphic Health Communication
    Abstract

    This graphic meditation on issues of cultural relevance and accessibility in comic-based health communication texts presents the web of rhetorical considerations inherent in creating culturally accessible health communication texts. Applying recent technical communication theories related to social justice this article will examine contemporary instances of comics being used as health communication tools for culturally diverse patient populations. The authors offer original drawings and text for the article.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2020.1768295
  3. Rhizcomics: Rhetoric, Technology, and New Media Composition: by Jason Helms, Ann Arbor, MI, Sweetland Digital Rhetoric Collaborative. Open Access. Online version: https://www.digitalrhetoriccollaborative.org/books/rhizcomics_drc/
    Abstract

    In a move that is becoming more common within digital humanities and comics scholarship, Jason Helms sets out to illustrate his argument through formal means, and thus has produced a work that is b...

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2020.1768030
  4. Examining Methectic Technical Communication in an Urban Planning Comic Book
    Abstract

    Technical communication research has relied heavily on participatory, user-focused strategies as well as “participative”, posthuman frameworks. Both research methodologies have various strengths, yet also have been critiqued for underplaying the role of human and non-human agency (respectively) in rhetorical situations. Through an analysis of an urban planning comic book, I suggest that turning to the Greek concept of methexis – or “participation” – may help technical communication researchers bridge posthuman and user-centered investigative approaches.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2020.1768289

April 2020

  1. Humanizing Visual Design: The Rhetoric of Human Forms in Practical Communication Humanizing Visual Design: The Rhetoric of Human Forms in Practical Communication , by Charles Kostelnick, New York, NY, Routledge, 2019, 280 pp., $150.00 (hardback), ISBN: 978-1-138-07151-3, $49.45 (eBook), ISBN: 978-1-315-11462-0
    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1669963
  2. Rhetoric, Technology, and the Virtues Rhetoric, Technology, and the Virtues , by Jared S. Colton and Steve Holmes, Louisville, CO, Utah State University Press, 2018, 184 pp., $23.95 (paperback), $19.95 (e-book), https://upcolorado.com/utah-state-university-press/item/3479-rhetoric-technology-and-the-virtues
    Abstract

    In Rhetoric, Technology, and the Virtues, Jared Colton and Steve Holmes wrestle with a core question facing digital rhetoricians: how might any example of digital communication technology or practi...

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1613332

January 2020

  1. Reconsidering an Essential Premise in Kessler, M. M., & Graham, S. S. (2018). Terminal Node Problems: ANT 2.0 and Prescription Drug Labels. Technical Communication Quarterly, 27(2), 121-136
    Abstract

    I appreciate that this paper was applauded for its thoughtful approach to assessing “prescription drug labels (PDLs)” using rhetorical principles. However, I believe the authors’ invention of the composite artifact “PDL” and their subsequent assessment based on this flawed concept is problematic and may weaken the validity of their conclusions.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1692909
  2. Visualizing Chinese Immigrants in theU.S. Statistical Atlases: A Case Study in Charting and Mapping the Other(s)
    Abstract

    This study examines the visual representation of Chinese immigrants in the U.S. Statistical Atlases from 1874 to1925. Compilers of the Atlases used a variety of visual strategies to facilitate rhetorical inclusion and exclusion, and by creating particular visual emphasis, constructed Chinese immigrants as being alienated, racialized, and low in the ethnic hierarchy. The visual constructs of the Chinese population reflected and reshaped the state’s policy of immigration restriction in the 19th and 20th centuries.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1690695
  3. Topic-driven environmental rhetoric: edited by D. G. Ross, New York, NY, Routledge, 278 pp., $150.00 (hardcover), $49.46 (eBook)
    Abstract

    “When I say the word environmental, what is the first thing that comes to mind?” (Ross, p. 1). So begins Ross’ edited collection, Topic-Driven Environmental Rhetoric, which examines how language an...

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1669961
  4. Guiguzi, China’s First Treatise on Rhetoric: A Critical Translation and Commentary: H. Wu, Carbondale, IL, Southern Illinois University Press, 2016, 180 pp., $40 (paperback), ISBN: 9780809335268
    Abstract

    As globalization exerts a higher demand on the technical communication profession, technical communication scholars and practitioners have paid significant attention to translation/localization (St...

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1669967

October 2019

  1. Rhetoric and Communication Perspectives on Domestic Violence and Sexual Assault: A. D. Propen and M. L. Schuster, New York, NY: Routledge Press, 2017, 216 pp., including index, US$160.00 (hardback), ISBN: 978-1138714984
    Abstract

    "Rhetoric and Communication Perspectives on Domestic Violence and Sexual Assault." Technical Communication Quarterly, 28(4), pp. 426–427

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1521649
  2. Communicating Campus Sexual Assault: A Mixed Methods Rhetorical Analysis
    Abstract

    This article reports on a mixed methods rhetorical analysis of a data set of news reports on campus sexual assault. A macro-level qualitative analysis of narratives combined with micro-level quantitative content analysis of verb voice offers insight into how news media shapes perceptions of power, blame, and agency in reporting. These findings offer implications for how public actors discuss campus sexual assault and implications for the teaching and practice of research methods in technical communication.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1621386
  3. Under Pressure: Exploring Agency–Structure Dynamics with a Rhetorical Approach to Register
    Abstract

    This study traced the adoption of a new social language among financial advisors responding to intense regulatory pressures. Register – specialized vocabularies, argumentative moves, and syntactical patterns – was analyzed to explore rhetorical practices embedded in agency–structure dynamics. Through analysis of advisors’ correspondence with clients and semi-structured interviews exploring their communication practices, this study demonstrates how register changes embody everyday rhetorical tactics for managing complicated audiences. This article contributes to studies of agency–structure dynamics in professional communication contexts governed by strong regulatory constraints.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1621387
  4. Professional Communication and Network Interaction: A Rhetorical and Ethical Approach: by Heidi A. McKee and James E. Porter, Routledge, 2017, 221 pp., https://www.routledge.com/Professional-Communication-and-Network-Interaction-A-Rhetorical-and-Ethical/McKee-Porter/p/book/9781138715219
    Abstract

    Tempora mutantur, et nos mutamur in illis (times change and we change with them). Not only is the techne of today’s rhetoric and professional communication changing but we rhetors and professiona...

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1613333

July 2019

  1. There’s No Such Thing as a Scientific Controversy
    Abstract

    We examine 81 rhetoric and technical communication studies of “scientific controversy.” Our praxiographic analysis reveals that “scientific controversy” is not one thing but three, each staged according to a radically different ontology; yet the literature continues to handle these ontologies the same and to privilege scientists’ demarcation claims in their analysis. We conclude the modifier scientific should be abandoned entirely in controversy studies and recommend an antilogical rather than dialectical approach to controversy.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1571243
  2. Writing childbirth: women’s rhetorical agency in labor and online
    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1618108
  3. A Computational Approach to Assessing Rhetorical Effectiveness: Agentic Framing of Climate Change in the Congressional Record, 1994–2016
    Abstract

    The goal of this paper is to consider rhetorical effects as the propagation of rhetorical expressions across large sets of texts, measured by the extent to which rhetorical expressions, structures, or practices become replicated in texts and sites of rhetorical in(ter)vention. The paper draws on lines of scholarship in the digital humanities and computational rhetoric – primarily, sequential structuring of semantic contexts, semantic parsing of unstructured text, and diachronic tracking of textual expressions – to extend their conceptual and methodological insights into a computational framework for assessing rhetorical effectiveness. It offers a test case for this concept through an analysis of how Congress has framed human agency toward addressing climate change.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1601774

April 2019

  1. Q-Rhetoric and Controlled Equivocation: Revising “The Scientific Study of Subjectivity” for Cross-Disciplinary Collaboration
    Abstract

    This article offers a revision to an existing social science methodology, Q methodology, through “Q-Rhetoric.” After detailing Q methodology’s theoretical underpinnings and practical method, and persistent critiques of the methodology, the article employs perspectives from rhetorical theory and Amerindian anthropology to suggest a methodological correction. It concludes by detailing the use of Q-Rhetoric to intervene in a Wisconsin stream management controversy, proposing Q-Rhetoric as a pragmatic and theoretically sound methodology for working across disciplinary divides.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1583377
  2. Research that Resonates: A Perspective on Durable and Portable Approaches to Scholarship in Technical Communication and Rhetoric of Science
    Abstract

    The current U.S. political climate has catalyzed intense public conversations about our relationship with facts and the truth. Declarations we have entered a Post-Truth Era vie with demands for ren...

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1591118
  3. Durable Research, Portable Findings: Rhetorical Methods in Case Study Research
    Abstract

    Case studies have been a central methodology employed by scholars working in the rhetoric of science and technical communication. However, concerns have been raised about how cases are constructed and collected, and what they convey. The authors reflect on how rhetoricians of science and technical communication researchers can – and do – construct a variety of case-based mixed-methods studies in ways that may make our research more portable and durable without undercutting the important and central role of case-based analysis.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1588376
  4. Durable, Portable Research through Partnerships with Interdisciplinary Advocacy Groups, Specific Research Topics, and Larger Data Sets
    Abstract

    Relying on the case of a mixed-methods study centered on patients’ strategies for establishing their credibility in clinical conversations, this essay argues that the more intentional and effective the participant recruitment and the more specific the inquiry, the more likely technical communication and rhetoric of science researchers are to encounter potentially powerful partners through which they might get and analyze compelling data and, thus, gain engaged audiences outside of their disciplines.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2019.1588375

January 2019

  1. The recalcitrant invention of X-ray images
    Abstract

    This article extends new materialist theorizing on the constructive role played by the physical stuff of the world. Specifically, it draws on Kenneth Burke’s writings on recalcitrance to theorize the materialities of rhetorical invention. It takes X-rays as a case study in recalcitrance-driven invention, focusing on two particular applications, traditional medical X-rays, a pervasive category of contemporary technical communication, and backscatter X-ray airport security scans, a controversial and short-lived one. Its analysis shows how recalcitrance (1) is harnessed as means of technical invention and (2) is key to invention’s bidirectionality, by which our material interventions, in turn, work upon us.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1539193

October 2018

  1. Visualizing Certainty: What the Cultural History of the Gantt Chart Teaches Technical and Professional Communicators about Management
    Abstract

    Using a cultural-historical genre analysis of the Gantt chart, the author describes how, when a project’s progress and scope are being considered, this popular project management visualization evokes managerial values of certainty and simplicity. These values, instantiated in early 20th-century scientific management philosophy, are made visually manifest in Henry L. Gantt’s popular chart. These charts require technical and professional communicators to gauge the rhetorical implications of using them when providing their expertise in communicating project management.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1520025
  2. The Rhetorical Work of YouTube’s Beauty Community: Relationship- and Identity-Building in User-Created Procedural Discourse
    Abstract

    This study investigates YouTube’s beauty community, an online group of women who make videos about makeup products and techniques. The videos contain makeup application instructions and challenge ideas about what is “usable” procedural discourse. They sometimes defy conventions for high production quality. Moreover, storytelling and instruction are integral to the rhetorical work of these tutorials. For the diverse groups in this community, procedural discourse also serves as a means of establishing credibility not otherwise afforded to them, as well as opportunities for identity- and relationship building.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1518950

July 2018

  1. Artifactual dimensions of visual rhetoric: what a content analysis of 114 peer-reviewed articles reveals about data collection reporting
    Abstract

    This content analysis examined how the authors of 114 peer-reviewed journal articles explained their empirical approaches to visual rhetoric scholarship. The authors content analysis sought to answer the question: how do scholars engage with the material dimensions of visual culture, specifically in terms of artifact selection and reporting data collection procedures? The answers to this question, the authors argue, are needed urgently as visual rhetoric research continues to expand because inconsistent reporting will hinder replicability and the reader’s access to the author’s argument. The authors use the findings of their content analysis to surface the implicit norms of empirical visual rhetoric research and to develop recommendations for reporting visual data collection procedures.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1479587

May 2018

  1. Artifactual Dimensions of Visual Rhetoric: What a Content Analysis of 114 Peer-Reviewed Articles Reveals about Data Collection Reporting
    Abstract

    This content analysis examined how the authors of 114 peer-reviewed journal articles explained their empirical approaches to visual rhetoric scholarship. Our content analysis sought to answer the question: how do scholars engage with the material dimensions of visual culture, specifically in terms of artifact selection and reporting data collection procedures? The answers to this question, we argue, are needed urgently as visual rhetoric research continues to expand because inconsistent reporting will hinder replicability and the reader’s access to the author’s argument. We use the findings of our content analysis to surface the implicit norms of empirical visual rhetoric research and to develop recommendations for reporting visual data collection procedures.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1479777

April 2018

  1. Rhetoric, Through Everyday Things. Raquel M. Robvais, Scot Barnett & Casey Boyle, Eds. Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama, 2016. 270 pages, $29.95 cloth, $28.45 electronic.
    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1425822
  2. Better science through rhetoric: A new model and pilot program for training graduate student science writers
    Abstract

    Graduate programs in the sciences offer minimal support for writing, yet there is an increasing need for scientists to engage with the public and policy makers. To address this need, the authors describe an innovative, cross-disciplinary, National Science Foundation (NSF)–funded training program in rhetoric and writing for science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) graduate students and faculty at the University of Rhode Island. The program offers a theory-driven, flexible, scalable model that could be adopted in a variety of institutional contexts.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1425735
  3. Still life with rhetoric: A new materialist approach for visual rhetorics. L. E. Gries. Boulder, CO: University Press of Colorado, 2015, 324 pages, including index. US$27.95 (paperback).
    Abstract

    The dispute for authority between the seemingly disparate disciplinary camps of theory and practice is a longstanding and well-documented tension within the field of technical communication (Miller...

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1425823
  4. Poor poor dumb mouths, and bid them speak for me: Theorizing the use of personas in practice
    Abstract

    Although personas are commonly used to represent users in design, their rhetorical function has been little explored. In this article, the authors theorize personas’ rhetorical function as ventriloquization, where one person speaks with the voice of another. In ventriloquizing users through personas, practitioners speak for users, while scripting personas to speak for their creators: each magnifies the others’ voice. Personas represent a strategic rhetorical gambit for gaining legitimacy within organizations and technological decision-making processes.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2017.1386005

January 2018

  1. Healing Arts: RhetoricalTechneas Medical (Humanities) Intervention
    Abstract

    To forge collaborative ties among the rhetoric of health and medicine, the medical humanities, and medicine itself, scholars need shared terms. We argue that techne can unite researchers from across these disciplines. To demonstrate, we discuss our interdisciplinary research study, Writing Diabetes. By learning about the techne of rhetoric and writing about diabetes, participants became more attentive to the techne of their health experience—or “health techne”—enabling them to invent new ways of “doing” diabetes.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1425960
  2. Mapping the Terrain: Examining the Conditions for Alignment Between the Rhetoric of Health and Medicine and the Medical Humanities
    Abstract

    This article offers an empirical study of literature in the rhetoric of health and medicine (RHM) and the medical humanities (MH). Article traces the topics, funding mechanisms, research methods, theoretical frameworks, evidence types, audience, discourse arrangement patterns, and action orientation that constitute the scholarship in the sample to offer a landscape of the current state of RHM and the MH. Findings can be leveraged to assess the potential for alignment between these fields for future research.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2017.1402561
  3. Medical Narratives in Rhetorical Context: Ethically Researching Anti-Vaccinationists
    Abstract

    This article argues that anti-vaccinationists pose an ethical challenge to researchers. On the one hand, research practices in narrative medicine push us to empower illness narratives. On the other hand, empowering some illness narratives may be misleading if the narrator is misinformed. By combining approaches to ethics found in medical humanities, medical ethics, and rhetoric of health and medicine, we can more accurately and ethically unravel how these skeptics are persuaded to hold their attitudes.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1399750
  4. Health Humanities Baccalaureate Programs and the Rhetoric of Health and Medicine
    Abstract

    This article argues that technical and professional communication (TPC) programs and specialists need to contribute more to health humanities scholarship and program curricula. The article reviews the writing courses offered by baccalaureate health humanities programs and “to support further TPC engagement in these programs” offers core generalizations and strategies for managing their approval process.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2017.1402566
  5. Health Ecologies in Addiction Treatment: Rhetoric of Health and Medicine and Conceptualizing Care
    Abstract

    This study explored the introduction of an ecological care model into a women’s alcohol-and-other-drug treatment facility. When patients learned that their health resembled a network of factors including demographics, health experiences, and their own health literacy, they approached addiction as a problem that required complex solutions. The authors present a methodology derived from rhetoric of health and medicine scholarship and the medical humanities that may help patients improve mental health literacy and treatment outcomes.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1401352
  6. Teaching Writing for the Health Professions: Disciplinary Intersections and Pedagogical Practice
    Abstract

    This article outlines an approach to teaching a Writing for the Health Professions course and situates this approach within the aims of and tensions between the medical humanities, the rhetoric of health and medicine, and disability studies. This analysis provides a pragmatic walkthrough of how assignments in such courses can be linked to programmatic outcomes (with SOAP [Subjective, Objective, Assessment, Plan] note and patient education assignments as extended examples) as well as an interdisciplinary framework for future empirical studies.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2017.1402573
  7. The Rhetoric of Health and Medicine as a “Teaching Subject”: Lessons from the Medical Humanities and Simulation Pedagogy
    Abstract

    The rhetoric of health and medicine has only begun to intervene in health pedagogy. In contrast, the medical humanities has spearheaded curriculum to address dehumanizing trends in medicine. This article argues that rhetorical scholars can align with medical humanities’ initiatives and uniquely contribute to health curriculum. Drawing on the author’s research on clinical simulation, the article discusses rhetorical methodologies, genre theory, and critical lenses as areas for pedagogical collaboration between rhetoricians and health practitioners.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1401348
  8. Blending Humanistic and Rhetorical Analysis to Locate Gendered Dimensions of Kenyan Medical Practitioner Attitudes About Cancer
    Abstract

    Medical humanities and the rhetoric of health and medicine apply different methods to healthcare documents and discourses. This methodological reflection of a project studying cancer attitudes in Kenya describes how researchers combined practices from these disparate fields to produce more sensitive and ethical methods for studying cross-cultural contexts. By extending humanistic methods into social-science data collections, researchers were better able to ask precise questions and to perceive context-specific cues for consent and non-consent.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1401344
  9. Introduction to the Special Issue: Medical Humanities and/or the Rhetoric of Health and Medicine
    doi:10.1080/10572252.2018.1399746

October 2017

  1. Integrating Quantitative Literacy into Technical Writing Instruction
    Abstract

    The authors argue that skills in quantitative literacy (QL) and quantitative reasoning (QR) augment students’ communicative effectiveness. This article offers a pedagogical framework and model for how QR can be productively interwoven with the rhetorical know-how of technical writing pedagogy. The authors describe their course redesign, present preliminary assessment data, and conclude by highlighting some implications not only for student learning, but also for the QL movement itself.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2017.1382259
  2. Rhetorical Memory: A Study of Technical Communication and Information Management, by Stewart Whittemore: Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 2015, 242 pages, $50.00 cloth, $40.00 electronic
    doi:10.1080/10572252.2017.1385996
  3. Representation in Engineering Practice: A Case Study of Framing in a Student Design Group
    Abstract

    This article presents a case study using ethnographic and visual methods to investigate the framing activity of engineering students. Findings suggest students use the rhetorical figure of hypotyposis to produce the vivid images needed to frame engineering constraints. Data reveal students multimodally inducing collaboration between group members to construct images as ways to configure engineering constraints. The author argues for the usefulness of hypotyposis for understanding the framing of engineers, technical communicators, and other designers.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2017.1382258

April 2017

  1. Bounding Biomedicine: Evidence and Rhetoric in the New Science of Alternative Medicine, by Colleen Derkatch: Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 2016, 209 pp., $55.00 (hardcover)
    doi:10.1080/10572252.2017.1297133
  2. Optical Solutions: Reception of an NSF-Funded Science Comic Book on the Biology of the Eye
    Abstract

    This article traces the reception of a “science comic book” by various audiences including readers and reviewers after publication as well as grant application review committees vetting the proposed project in its conceptual stage. Specifically, the work is a biology textbook containing comics-style visual explanations couched in the form of an imaginative story interwoven with and supplementing traditional text-based explanations of the same ideas. The analysis uses Genette’s concept of “paratexts” (i.e., a class of speech genres comprising those supplementary texts that contextualize and inform readers’ interpretations of the primary text that they accompany) to examine the rhetoric of the visual in the discourse of science education. This analysis observes that the stigmatization of comics as a medium played some role in how readers, critics, and reviewers responded to the text. The implications of this stigma for cultural conceptions of science and their relationships to other knowledge domains, including the arts and humanities, raise a concern for the mediation of public impressions of science as an institution.

    doi:10.1080/10572252.2017.1285962