College Composition and Communication Sep 2025

AI Writing Is Always Embodied: Building a Critical Awareness of the Invisible Labor of Humans-in-the-Loop in AI Products

Gabriel Lorenzo Aguilar

Abstract

I argue that composition studies must build critical awareness about how humans from the Global South train AI with their writing embodiments. To draw our attention to how those working in the Global South train AI in harmful conditions, even though AI companies use algorithms and terms of service to smooth away these embodiments, I adapt the concept of humans-in-the-loop. Critical awareness of humans-in-the-loop moves scholarship in writing studies from a focus on AI-human collaboration that begins after an AI produces a text to one that requires us to see how AI products are always already human authored. Through a case study of Google Translate, I demonstrate how a critical awareness of how AI can erase the writing embodiment of humans-in-the-loop affords me opportunities to ask generative questions: How does language translation play a role in the erasure of embodied writing? Why does AI produce with bias toward marginalized populations when marginalized populations are those that moderate AI? Overall, I ask compositionists to see AI products as already human authored so that writing studies can consider the invisible labor of humans-in-the-loop as the field moves forward in researching AI.

Journal
College Composition and Communication
Published
2025-09-01
DOI
10.58680/ccc202577139
Open Access
Closed
Topics
qualitative research multimodality artificial intelligence body and rhetoric

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

Cites in this index (22)

  1. Carradini (2024)
    On the Current Moment in AI: Introduction to Special Issue on Effects of Artifi…
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  2. Johnson-Eilola et al. (2024)
    Can Artificial Intelligence Robots Write Effective Instructions?
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  3. Hallsby (2024)
    A Copious Void: Rhetoric as Artificial Intelligence 1.0
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  4. Lubin et al. (2024)
    Sex after Technology: The Rhetoric of Health Monitoring Apps and the Reversal o…
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  5. Aguilar (2024)
    Rhetorically training students to generate with AI: Social justice applications…
    Computers and Composition
Show all 22 →
  1. Bedington et al. (2024)
    Writing with generative AI and human-machine teaming: Insights and recommendati…
    Computers and Composition
  2. Knowles (2024)
    Machine-in-the-loop writing: Optimizing the rhetorical load
    Computers and Composition
  3. Li (2024)
    A “Dance of storytelling”: Dissonances between substance and style in collabora…
    Computers and Composition
  4. Kong et al. (2024)
    Tools, Potential, and Pitfalls of Social Media Screening: Social Profiling in t…
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  5. Erby (2023)
    Imagining Freedom: Cultural Rhetorics, Digital Literacies, and Podcasting in Prison
    College Composition and Communication
  6. Grayson (2023)
    Assimilation/Appropriation: What Jewish Discourses in Rhetoric, Composition, an…
    College Composition and Communication
  7. Mukavetz (2023)
    Another Temporarily Hopeful Intervention: Cultural Rhetorics as a Commitment to…
    College Composition and Communication
  8. Vega (2023)
    Amplifying Autogestión and Cultural Rhetorics of Resistance
    College Composition and Communication
  9. West-Puckett et al. (2023)
    Engaging Assessment Counterstories through a Cultural Rhetorics Framework
    College Composition and Communication
  10. Anderson (2023)
    “Places to stand”: Multiple metaphors for framing ChatGPT's corpus
    Computers and Composition
  11. Cushman et al. (2021)
    Introduction: Delinking: Toward Pluriversal Rhetorics
    College English
  12. Gallagher (2020)
    The Ethics of Writing for Algorithmic Audiences
    Computers and Composition
  13. Riley-Mukavetz (2020)
    Developing a Relational Scholarly Practice: Snakes, Dreams, and Grandmothers
    College Composition and Communication
  14. Clayson (2018)
    Distributed writing as a lens for examining writing as embodied practice
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  15. LeMesurier (2016)
    Mobile Bodies: Triggering Bodily Uptake through Movement
    College Composition and Communication
  16. Jones (2016)
    The Technical Communicator as Advocate
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  17. Haas et al. (2001)
    Writing as an Embodied Practice
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication
Also cites 8 works outside this index ↓
  1. Arora (2023)
    Risk and the Future of AI: Algorithmic Bias, Data Colonialism, and Marginalization
    Information and Organization  ↗
  2. Breslow (2018)
    Moderating the ‘Worst of Humanity’: Sexuality, Witnessing, and the Digital Life of Coloniality
    Porn Studies  ↗
  3. Couldry (2019)
    Data Colonialism: Rethinking Big Data’s Relation to the Contemporary Subject
    Television & New Media  ↗
  4. Couldry (2019)
    Making Data Colonialism Liveable: How Might Data’s Social Order Be Regulated?
    Internet Policy Review  ↗
  5. David (2016)
    Outsourced Heroes and Queer Incorporations: Labor Brokerage and the Politics of Inclusion…
    GLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies  ↗
  6. Ricaurte (2019)
    Data Epistemologies, The Coloniality of Power, and Resistance
    Television & New Media  ↗
  7. Sham (2023)
    Ethical AI in Facial Expression Analysis: Racial Bias
    Signal, Image and Video Processing  ↗
  8. Siapera (2022)
    AI Content Moderation, Racism and (de)Coloniality
    International Journal of Bullying Prevention  ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network →

Related Articles

  1. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication Oct 2024
    Role Play: Conversational Roles as a Framework for Reflexive Practice in AI-Assisted Qualitative Research ↗
    Luke Thominet; Jacqueline Amorim; Kristine Acosta; Vanessa K. Sohan
    qualitative research multimodality artificial intelligence technical communication multilingual writers
  2. Journal of Technical Writing and Communication Mar 2026
    “It's Hard to Show ROI When You’re Preventing Things from Happening”: How Impact Storytelling Frames Community Health Initiatives for Executive Audiences ↗
    Margaret Hsiao
    qualitative research multimodality technical communication professional writing multilingual writers
  3. Computers and Composition Mar 2026
    Chinese EFL learners’ engagement with ChatGPT feedback on academic writing: A case study in Malaysia ↗
    Zhang Kailin; Murad Abdu Saeed
    qualitative research artificial intelligence multilingual writers
  4. Written Communication Jan 2026
    Writing Instruction for Adult L2-Learners: A Case Study From Three Swedish Classrooms ↗
    Clara Palm; Ann-Christin Randahl; Liss Kerstin Sylvén
    writing pedagogy genre theory qualitative research multimodality
  5. Composition Forum Oct 2025
    Adding to the Qualitative Research Method Toolkit: Eliciting and Coding Participant Drawings ↗
    writing across the curriculum empirical research qualitative research multimodality multilingual writers