Why Napster matters to writing: Filesharing as a new ethic of digital delivery

Dànielle Nicole DeVoss Michigan State University ; James E. Porter Michigan State University

Abstract

This article discusses the Napster phenomenon and its cultural significance, traces some of the threads of the current “copyright crisis,” and connects these cultural and legal dynamics to show how the current filesharing context of digital environments pertains to issues affecting writing teachers. The article (1) urges writing teachers to view the Napster moment—and the writing practice at the center of it, filesharing—in terms of the rhetorical and economic dynamics of digital publishing and in the context of public battles about copyright and intellectual property and (2) argues that digital filesharing forms the basis for an emergent ethic of digital delivery, an ethic that should lead composition teachers to rethink pedagogical approaches and to revise plagiarism policies to recognize the value of filesharing and to acknowledge Fair Use as an ethic for digital composition.

Journal
Computers and Composition
Published
2006-01-01
DOI
10.1016/j.compcom.2006.02.001
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (23)

  1. College English
  2. Computers and Composition
  3. Literacy in Composition Studies
  4. Computers and Composition
  5. Computers and Composition
Show all 23 →
  1. Computers and Composition
  2. Computers and Composition
  3. Computers and Composition
  4. Computers and Composition
  5. Computers and Composition
  6. Rhetoric Review
  7. Computers and Composition
  8. Rhetoric Review
  9. Computers and Composition
  10. Computers and Composition
  11. Computers and Composition
  12. Computers and Composition
  13. Pedagogy
  14. Computers and Composition
  15. Computers and Composition
  16. Computers and Composition
  17. Computers and Composition
  18. Computers and Composition

References (121) · 7 in this index

  1. A&M Records, Inc. v. Napster, Inc. 239 F.3d 1004. CA 9th Cir. (2001). Retrieved from <http://www.law.cornell.…
  2. Aigrain, Philippe. (2003). The individual and the collective in open information communities. Free/Open Sourc…
  3. The economy of ideas
    Wired
  4. Free as the air to common use: First Amendment constraints of the public domain
    New York University Law Review
  5. The shape of text to come: The texture of print on screens
    College Composition and Communication  
Show all 121 →
  1. From Internet to information superhighway
    Resisting the virtual life: The culture and politics of information
  2. Besser, Howard. (2001). Intellectual property: The attack on public space in cyberspace. Retrieved from <http…
  3. Writing space: Computers, hypertext, and the remediation of print
  4. Borland, John. (2001, May). Campus file swappers to pay RIAA. CNET News.com. Retrieved from <http://news.com.…
  5. Borland, John. (2004, March). New RIAA file-swapping suits filed. CNET News.com. Retrieved from <http://news.…
  6. Borland, John, & Barnes, Cecily. (2000, July). Judge issues injunction against Napster. News.com. Retrieved f…
  7. Boyle, James. (n.d.). A politics of intellectual property: Environmentalism for the Net? Retrieved from <http…
  8. Carlson, Scott. (2003, May). A president tries to settle the controversy over file sharing. Chronicle of High…
  9. Carnevale, Dan. (2003, August). Record industry will sue only students who download “substantial” numbers of …
  10. Cassavoy, Liane. (2003, September). Music labels declare war on file swappers. Retrieved from <http://yahoo.p…
  11. Open content and value creation
    First Monday  
  12. The economics of open source hijacking and declining quality of digital information resou…
    First Monday  
  13. Rhetoric Review
  14. Copyright, plagiarism, and intellectual property. (1998). Special Issue of Kairos. Retrieved from <http://eng…
  15. Dahlander, Linus. (2004). Appropriating the commons: Firms in open source software. Free/Open Source Research…
  16. Dean, Katie. (2003, December). Tis the season for RIAA lawsuits. Wired News. Retrieved from <http://www.wired…
  17. Dean, Katie. (2004a, February). New flurry of RIAA lawsuits. Wired News. Retrieved from <http://www.wired.com…
  18. Dean, Katie. (2004b, August). Copyright crusaders hit schools. Wired News. Retrieved from <http://www.wired.c…
  19. Computers and Composition
  20. Dornsife, Rob. (2004, March). “Yes, you can do that now”: How computer composition changes the rules of acade…
  21. Digital music and subculture: Sharing files, sharing styles
    First Monday  
  22. The Economist Group. (2005). The economics of sharing. Economist.com. Retrieved from <http://www.economist.co…
  23. Electronic Frontier Foundation. (2004a). How not to get sued by the RIAA for filesharing. Retrieved from <htt…
  24. Electronic Frontier Foundation. (2004b). Prelude to a fake complaint. Retrieved from <http://www.eff.org/IP/A…
  25. Electronic Frontier Foundation. (2005, January 20). Supreme Court date set for Grokster. Retrieved from <http…
  26. Evangelista, Benny. (2003, August). Download warning 101: Freshman orientation this fall to include record in…
  27. Foster, Andrea L. (2004, June). Congress quietly considers two bills encouraging prosecution of file-sharing …
  28. GartnerG2 and The Berkman Center for Internet & Society at Harvard Law School. (2003). Copyright and digital …
  29. College English
  30. Space, time, and perversion: Essays on the politics of bodies
  31. Grow, Brian. (2001, November). Can Morpheus prevail where Napster failed? Business Week. Retrieved from <http…
  32. Gurak, Laura, & Johnson-Eilola, Johndan (Eds.). (1998). Legal and conceptual issues in intellectual property.…
  33. Hamilton, Marci. (2003). Why suing college students for illegal music downloading is right. CNN.com. Retrieve…
  34. Evolving perspectives on computers and composition studies: Questions for the 1990s
  35. Computers and the teaching of writing in American higher education, 1979–1994: A history
  36. Passions, pedagogies, and 21st century technologies
  37. Heins, Marjorie. (2002). “The progress of science and useful arts”: Why copyright today threatens intellectua…
  38. Computers and Composition
  39. The hacker ethic: A radical approach to the philosophy of business
  40. Plagiarisms, authorships, and the academic death penalty
    College English  
  41. Sexuality, textuality: The cultural work of plagiarism
    College English  
  42. Jardin, Xeni. (2004, March). Congress moves to criminalize P2P. Wired News. Retrieved from <http://www.wired.…
  43. Democratizing software: Open source, the hacker ethic, and beyond
    First Monday  
  44. Nostalgic angels: Rearticulating hypertext writing
  45. Johnson-Eilola, Johndan. (2005). Datacloud: Toward a new theory of online work. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
  46. Jones, Christopher. (2000, March). Open-source “Napster” shut down. Wired News. Retrieved from <http://www.wi…
  47. Of two minds: Hypertext pedagogy and poetics
  48. The computer and the page: Publishing, technology, and the classroom
  49. Karagiannis, Thomas, Broido, Andre, Brownlee, Nevil, Claffy, K. C., & Faloutsos, Michalis. (2004). Is P2P dyi…
  50. Music in the age of free distribution: MP3 and society
    First Monday  
  51. Kranich, Nancy. (2004, June). The information commons: A public policy report. Free Expression Policy Project…
  52. Lakhani, Karim R., & Wolf, Bob. (2003). Why hackers do what they do: Understanding motivation and effort in f…
  53. Landau, Michael. (2001, May). Questions and answers about the Napster case. Gigalaw.com. Retrieved from <http…
  54. Hypertext: The convergence of contemporary critical theory and technology
  55. Hyper/text/theory
  56. Writing instruction from late antiquity to the twelfth century
    A short history of writing instruction: From ancient Greece to modern America
  57. A handlist of rhetorical terms
  58. The electronic word: Democracy, technology, and the arts
  59. P2P users sued in IFPI blitzkrieg
    Billboard
  60. The Internet under siege
    Foreign Policy
  61. Lessig, Lawrence. (2002, August). Free culture. O’Reilly Policy DevCenter. Retrieved from <http://www.oreilly…
  62. Lessig, Lawrence. (2004, March). Some like it hot. Wired News. Retrieved from <http://www.wired.com/wired/arc…
  63. Computers and Composition
  64. A copyright cold war? The polarized rhetoric of the peer–to–peer debates
    First Monday  
  65. Rhetoric, feminism, and the politics of textual ownership
    College English  
  66. Intellectual property and composition studies
    College Composition and Communication  
  67. Mann, Charles, Barlow, John Perry, Stefik, Mark, & Lessig, Lawrence. (1998). Life, liberty, and… the pursuit …
  68. Marx, Karl. (1859/1970). A contribution to the critique of political economy. (Maurice Dobb, Trans.). New Yor…
  69. So much for the magic of technology and the free market: The World Wide Web and the corpo…
    The World Wide Web and contemporary cultural theory
  70. Gifting technologies
    First Monday  
  71. McKenna, Barrie, & Waldie, Paul. (2003). Lawsuits hit net music downloaders. Retrieved from <http://www.thegl…
  72. New round of RIAA lawsuits
    Slyck
  73. MGM v. Grokster. (2004). Retrieved from <http://www.eff.org/IP/P2P/MGM_v_Grokster/>.
  74. Miller, Mark Crispin. (2001, December). What's wrong with this picture? The Nation. Retrieved from <http://ww…
  75. O’Connor, Sandra Day. (1991). Writing for the majority in Feist Publications, Inc. v. Rural Telephone Service…
  76. Peer-to-Peer News Week in Review (2004, May 8). Retrieved from <http://www.p2p-zone.com/underground/showthrea…
  77. Peters, Marybeth. (2003, September). Statement by the Register of Copyrights before the Committee on the Judi…
  78. Rhetoric Review
  79. Legal realities and ethical hyperrealities: A critical approach toward cyberwriting
    Computers and technical communication: Pedagogical and programmatic perspectives
  80. Rhetorical ethics and internetworked writing
  81. Porter, James E. (1999, March). Public rhetorics and the corporate takeover of electronic writing. Presented …
  82. Porter, James E. (2001, March). Introduction to panel on “Economies of writing: How E-economics promises (thr…
  83. Porter, James E. (2002, October). The rhetoric of digital audiences. Presented at Thomas R. Watson Conference…
  84. Porter, James E. (2005). The chilling of digital information: Technical communicators as public advocates. In…
  85. Raymond, Eric S. (1997). The cathedral and the bazaar. Retrieved from <http://www.kde.org/food/cathedral/cath…
  86. Recording industry forces universities to identify students suspected of music piracy
    Chronicle of Higher Education
  87. Delivery
    Encyclopedia of rhetoric and composition: Communication from ancient times to the information age
  88. RIAA files lawsuits against file sharers. (2003, September). Fox News. Retrieved from <http://www.foxnews.com…
  89. Distributed authorship: A feminist case-study framework for studying intellectual property
    College English  
  90. Rose, Derek. (2003, September). Brianna pays the piper. New York Daily News. Retrieved from <http://www.nydai…
  91. Samuelson, Pamela. (1996, January). The copyright grab. Wired News. Retrieved from <http://www.wired.com/wire…
  92. Samuelson, Pamela. (1998a, February). The netizen: Database debacle. Wired News. Retrieved from <http://www.w…
  93. Samuelson, Pamela. (1998b, March). The netizen: Maximum copyright, minimum use. Wired News. Retrieved from <h…
  94. Culture Inc.: The corporate takeover of public expression
  95. Schwartz, John. (2004, April 5). A heretical view of file sharing. The New York Times, C, p. 1.
  96. Making technology democratic
    Resisting the virtual life: The culture and politics of information
  97. Technical Communication Quarterly
  98. Reimagining the functional side of computer literacy
    College Composition and Communication  
  99. Redefining literacy: The multilayered grammars of computers
    Critical perspectives on computers and composition instruction
  100. Technology and literacy in the twenty-first century: The perils of not paying attention
  101. Literacy and technology
  102. Shirky, Clay. (2003a). File-sharing goes social. Retrieved from <http://www.shirky.com/writings/file-sharing_…
  103. Shirky, Clay. (2003b). Fame vs. fortune: Micropayments and free content. Retrieved from <http://shirky.com/wr…
  104. Smith, Ethan. (2004, September 20). This compilation CD is meant to be copied and shared. DavidByrne.com. Ret…
  105. Society for Critical Exchange. (n.d.). Project on “new economic criticism.” Retrieved from <http://www.cwru.e…
  106. Panel on “economies of writing” at the Modern Language Association Conference
  107. Sony Corporation v. Universal City Studios, Inc. (1984). U.S. Supreme Court 464 U.S. 417. No. 81-1687. Retrie…
  108. Sullivan, Jennifer. (1999, November). Napster: Music is for sharing. Wired News. Retrieved from <http://www.w…
  109. Taking control of the page: Electronic writing and word publishing
    Evolving perspectives on computers and composition studies: Questions for the 1990s
  110. Thomas, Alice. (2003, May). OSU raid raises ante in file-sharing fight. Columbus Dispatch. Retrieved from <ht…
  111. Copyrights and copywrongs: The rise of intellectual property and how it threatens creativity
  112. Vaidhyanathan, Siva. (2002, July). Copyrights and copywrongs: Why Thomas Jefferson would love Napster. MSNBC.…
  113. Veiga, Alex. (2003, May 1). Students settle file-swapping lawsuit with music industry. Kansas City Star. Retr…
  114. Electrifying classical rhetoric: Ancient media, modern technology, and contemporary composition
    Journal of Advanced Composition
  115. Scholarly associations and the economic viability of open access publishing
    Journal of Digital Information
  116. The law of texts: Copyright in the academy
    College English