IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication Sep 2015

The Current State of Component Content Management: An Integrative Literature Review

Rebekka Andersen University of California, Davis ; Tatiana Batova Arizona State University

Abstract

Research problem: The widespread adoption of component content management in organizations calls for a comprehensive summary of the territory of this phenomenon. A summary provides stakeholders in component content management with a sense of how the practice has evolved and its implications to research, theory, and future practice. The last such review was published in 2003. This integrative literature review is intended to fill the gap in the literature by describing the current state of component content management as presented in the current publications. Research questions: How is “content” currently defined, described, and approached in the component content-management literature? What processes and tools are organizations adopting to achieve the goals of component content management? Literature review: The theoretical orientation of this review is Rhetorical Genre theory, which allows for classifying individual components as a genre characterized by granularity, reusability, and potentiality. Component content management gained recognition in the mid-1990s when early adopter organizations were looking for more efficient and effective approaches to reusing information between similar products or versions of the same product. Developments in the 2000s include a surge of publications focused on defining and describing component content management; new best practices for implementing a component content-management initiative; evolving processes and technologies for creating highly engineered, modular content that can automatically adjust to specific user requests and device capabilities; and collaborative efforts to integrate content creation and management strategies across organizational units. Scholarly and trade publications increasingly explore different concerns; whereas scholarly publications tend to offer critical perspectives on component content management, trade publications tend to describe processes and technologies and articulate best practices. Both focus on the goals of component content management, such as single sourcing, content reuse, multichannel publishing, and the structured content components required to achieve these goals. Methodology: To answer the research questions, we reviewed the body of literature on component content management. To do so, we searched library databases, Google, and Amazon.com for articles and books in both the scholarly and trade literature; we also sought out publications by well-known voices in component content management who direct successful consultant and/or research organizations. We then classified selected publications in relation to research questions and identified themes within each research question. The review did not explore other types of content management. Results and conclusions: Current component content-management literature suggests that component content management has evolved from a practice focused on single sourcing and reuse strategies for product documentation to a mature discipline concerned with designing pre-sales and post-sales information products for a multitude of devices and delivery channels. In recent years, trade publications have led the way to standardizing the discipline's core concepts, methodologies, processes, and technologies, such as structured content, structured authoring, single sourcing, component-based content strategy, Extensible Markup Language authoring tools, and component-content-management systems. Scholarly publications, however, have had comparatively little impact on advancing the discipline of component content management because only a handful of publications have focused on the topic and almost no crosstalk exists between these publications and the trade literature. Several questions about the practices of component content management still need to be answered, particularly in the areas of multilingual communication and content quality and usability. Based on the results of the literature review, we call for a coherent, robust, and ambitious component content-management research agenda that addresses topics such as content quality and usability, the diffusion of content-management systems, and global content management and that leads to studies that both advance scholarship and improve component content-management practice.

Journal
IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
Published
2015-09-01
DOI
10.1109/tpc.2016.2516619
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
rhetorical criticism genre theory collaborative writing technical communication book reviews
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (17)

  1. Madson (2024)
    The Packaging and Labeling of Cannabis Edibles: Opportunities for Professional …
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  2. Schreiber (2024)
    What Is Technical About Technical Editing?
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  3. Gattis (2023)
    A Study of Lexical Repetition and the Comprehensibility of Single-Sourced Techn…
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  4. Getto et al. (2023)
    Introduction to Special Issue: The People, Practices, and Technologies Central …
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  5. Campbell et al. (2023)
    A Maturity Model for Content Strategy Development and Technical Communicator Le…
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Show all 17 →
  1. Swarts (2022)
    Uses of Metadiscourse in Online Help
    Written Communication
  2. Tham (2022)
    Book Review: Content Strategy in Technical Communication by Giuseppe, G., Labri…
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  3. Verhulsdonck et al. (2021)
    Investigating the Impact of Design Thinking, Content Strategy, and Artificial I…
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  4. Swarts (2018)
    Locating and Describing the Work of Technical Communication in an Online User Network
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  5. Batova (2018)
    Global Technical Communication in 7.5 Weeks Online: Combining Industry and Acad…
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  6. Eito-Brun et al. (2018)
    Automation of Quality Reports in the Aerospace Industry
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  7. Batova (2018)
    Negotiating Multilingual Quality in Component Content-Management Environments
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  8. McDaniel et al. (2017)
    Creative Content Management: Importance, Novelty, and Affect as Design Heuristi…
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  9. Batova et al. (2017)
    A Systematic Literature Review of Changes in Roles/Skills in Component Content …
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  10. Moxley-Kelly (2017)
    Review of "The Language of Technical Communication," by Gallon, R. (2016). Lagu…
    Communication Design Quarterly
  11. Batova et al. (2016)
    Introduction to the Special Issue: Content Strategy— A Unifying Vision
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  12. Clark (2016)
    Content Strategy: An Integrative Literature Review
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication

References (135) · 19 in this index

  1. mcgrane (2012) (0)
    Adapting ourselves to adaptive content
  2. wachter-boettcher (2011) (0)
    Structured Content Shifting Context Responsive Design Content Strategy & the Future
  3. gollner (2013) (0)
    The Emergence of Intelligent Content The Evolution of Open Content Standards and Their Significance
  4. gollner (2013) (0)
    A practical introduction to intelligent content
    tcworld Magazine for International Information Management
  5. wahl (2006)
    Best practices for implementing a CMS for technical publications?Part 2
    CIDM Inf Manage News
Show all 135 →
  1. shumate (2011)
    Implementing the big 3: A project management view on lessons learned on implementing an X…
    CIDM Best Pract
  2. rockley (2010)
    Managing content: An intelligent content strategy
    Proc Inf Manage Best Practices
  3. wachter-boettcher (2012) (0)
    Future ready content.
    A List Apart
  4. rockley (2012)
    Managing Enterprise Content A Unified Content Strategy
  5. lovinger (2010) (0)
    Nimble: A razorfish report on publishing in the digital age.
    Razorfish
  6. robitaille (2005)
    Change management: Dealing with emotions
    Rockley Rep
  7. oakes (2010)
    Creating clear governance?How to enable good decision making in complex organizations
    TIMAF Information Management Best Practices
  8. rockley (2004)
    Best practices: Why start with analysis and design?
    Rockley Rep
  9. berg (2007)
    Why your CM initiave fails
    The Content Economy
  10. kostur (2004)
    Technology's impact on its users
    Rockley Rep
  11. Dayton (2006)
    A Hybrid Analytical Framework to Guide Studies of Innovative IT Adoption by Wor…
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  12. Andersen (2011)
    Component Content Management: Shaping the Discourse through Innovation Diffusio…
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  13. trotter (2007) (0)
    The 7 challenges of implementing a content management system ECM Connection
  14. swisher (2012) (0)
    Content Strategy Goes Global
  15. hamer (2007)
    Implementing a CMS: A game-changing corporate initiative
    Intercom (Des Moines)
  16. porter (2013)
    A note from the guest editor
    Intercom (Des Moines)
  17. carr (2011)
    Case study: Developing a sharepoint 2010 strategy <ref_formula> <tex Notation="TeX">$\ldo…
    Amer Soc Inf Sci Technol Bull
  18. Zachry et al. (2004)
    An Interview with Edward R. Tufte
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  19. 10.1109/IPCC.2011.6087228
     ↗
  20. abel (2014)
    The Language of Content Strategy
  21. gollner (2013) (0)
    Products Content Strategy
  22. hart (2013)
    Defining content: Going beyond the explicit to define the implicit information
    Intercom (Des Moines)
  23. abel (2014)
    The Language of Content Strategy
  24. Clark (2007)
    Content Management and the Separation of Presentation and Content
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  25. miles (1994)
    Qualitative Data Analysis An Expanded Sourcebook
  26. tesch (1990)
    Qualitative Research Analysis Types and Software Tools
  27. salda�a (2009)
    The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers
  28. jones (2011)
    Clout The Art and Science of Influential Web Content
  29. dayton (2010)
    Single sourcing and content management: A survey of STC members
    Tech Commun
  30. abel (2013) (0)
    2012 technical communication benchmarking survey summary results
  31. 10.1080/00335638409383686
     ↗
  32. (0)
    Research report Global authoring survey 2009
  33. 10.1145/584955.584985
     ↗
  34. Spilka (2000)
    The issue of quality in professional documentation: How can academia make more …
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  35. yates (1992)
    Genres of organizational communication: A structurational approach to studying communicat…
    Acad Manage Rev  ↗
  36. honkaranta (2003)
    Developing document and content management in enterprises using a ?genre lens,?
    Proc Int Conf Enterprise Inf Syst
  37. dicks (2002)
    Reshaping Technical Communication New Directions and Challenges for the 21st Century
  38. Clark (2004)
    Is Professional Writing Relevant? A Model for Action Research
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  39. giammona (2004)
    Giammona 2004 the future of technical communication.pdf
    Tech Commun
  40. hayhoe (1998)
    The academe-industry partnership: What's in it for all of us?
    Tech Commun
  41. Andersen (2007)
    The Rhetoric of Enterprise Content Management (ECM): Confronting the Assumption…
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  42. 10.1177/1534484305278283
     ↗
  43. carliner (1997)
    Demonstrating effectiveness and value?: A process for evaluating technical communication …
    Tech Commun
  44. Blakeslee et al. (2004)
    The State of Research in Technical Communication
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  45. andersen (0)
    The value of a reciprocal relationship between research and practice.
    CIDM Inf Manage News
  46. Andersen (2014)
    Planning for the Shaping Force of Cultural Dynamics in a Component Content-Mana…
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  47. Whittemore (2007)
    Metadata and Memory: Lessons from the Canon ofMemoriafor the Design of Content …
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  48. hoeber (0)
    Recognizing customer behavior with web analytics
    CIDM Best Practices Conf Monterey CA USA
  49. o'keefe (2009) (0)
    Structured authoring and XML
  50. day (2014)
    The Language of Content Strategy
  51. Batova et al. (2015)
    The Complexities of Globalized Content Management
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  52. taft (2012)
    Messaging and collaboration. Technical communication: 10 top trends enterprises Need to Know
    eWeek
  53. Hart-Davidson et al. (2007)
    Coming to Content Management: Inventing Infrastructure for Organizational Knowl…
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  54. swisher (2013) (0)
    The Content Strategy Terminology Problem
  55. schwartz (2012)
    Structured content and why it matters for global companies
    Inform Today
  56. gattis (2009)
    Content Management Bridging the Gap between Theory and Practice
  57. rockley (2011) (0)
    What is intelligent content?
    The Content Wrangler
  58. Robidoux (2007)
    Rhetorically Structured Content: Developing a Collaborative Single-Sourcing Cur…
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  59. sapienza (2004)
    Usability, structured content, single sourcing with XML
    Tech Commun
  60. mcdaniel (2011)
    Complex Worlds Digital Culture Rhetoric Professional Communication
  61. gesteland mcshane (2008)
    Content Management Bridging the Gap between Theory and Practice
  62. Batova (2014)
    Component Content Management and Quality of Information Products for Global Aud…
    IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
  63. rockley (2014)
    The Language of Content Strategy
  64. batova (2015) (0)
    Multilingual quality and topic-based authoring?: A survey of common practices
    CIDM Inf Manage News
  65. cooper (2014)
    The Language of Content Strategy
  66. benavente (0)
    Results of the April 2013 technical communication industry research needs survey.
    CIDM Inf Manage News
  67. hart-davidson (2005)
    Technical Communication and the World Wide Web
  68. mcgrane (2014) (0)
    Content in a Zombie apocalypse
  69. leibtag (2014)
    The Digital Crown Winning at Content on the Web
  70. Sapienza (2007)
    A Rhetorical Approach to Single-Sourcing Via Intertextuality
    Technical Communication Quarterly
  71. 10.1002/bult.2011.1720370211
     ↗
  72. hackos (2011)
    Introduction to DITA?Second Edition A Users Guide to the Darwin Information Typing Architecture Including DITA 1 2
  73. lewis (2012)
    DITA Metrics 101 The Business Case for XML and Intelligent Content
  74. rockley (2010)
    DITA 101 Fundamentals for DITA for Authors and Managers
  75. kostur (2011)
    Structured authoring: A first step to content management
    Proc Soc Tech Commun Annu Conf
  76. williams (2003)
    The implications of single sourcing for technical communicators
    Tech Commun
  77. self (2007) (0)
    Semantic, structured authoring.
    HyperWrite Consultancy and Training
  78. Andersen (2014)
    Rhetorical Work in the Age of Content Management: Implications for the Field of…
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  79. (2013)
    Content strategy?Planning for success.
    Rockley Rep
  80. white (2014)
    The Language of Content Strategy
  81. nichols (2015)
    Enterprise Content Management A Project Guide
  82. self (2011) (0)
    Can you explain that again? DITA for beginners
    tcworld Magazine for International Information Management
  83. o'keefe (0)
    Transforming technical content into a business asset
    tcworld Magazine for International Information Management
  84. baker (2015) (0)
    Reducing the cost of structured writing and publishing systems development
  85. gollner (2010) (0)
    About content strategy
  86. (0)
    Technical communication poll Can structured authoring and web content delivery co-exist?
  87. abel (2013)
    The importance of vision in content strategy
    Intercom (Des Moines)
  88. day (2013) (0)
    What is 'DITA for the web?
  89. 10.1002/bult.2011.1720370207
     ↗
  90. johnson (2013) (0)
    Is structured authoring (like DITA) a good fit for publishing on a website?
  91. urbina (2010) (0)
    Developing a content strategy
  92. lundin (2011) (0)
    Do we Need a Content Strategy? In Pursuit of the Ultimate techCom Information Architecture
  93. bailie (2010)
    Content Lifecycle Closing the Loop in Content Strategy
  94. gollner (2013)
    The technology side of content strategy
    Intercom (Des Moines)
  95. wachter-boettcher (2012)
    Content Everywhere Strategy and Structure for Future-Ready Content
  96. molisani (2013)
    So you want to be a content strategist?
    Intercom (Des Moines)
  97. hart-davidson (2009)
    Digital Literacy for Technical Communication 21st Century Theory and Practice
  98. Swarts (2010)
    Recycled Writing: Assembling Actor Networks From Reusable Content
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  99. bacha (2008)
    Content Management Bridging the Gap between Theory and Practice
  100. McCarthy et al. (2011)
    Content Management in the Workplace: Community, Context, and a New Way to Organ…
    Journal of Business and Technical Communication
  101. albers (2003)
    Single sourcing and the technical communication career path
    Tech Commun
  102. ament (2003)
    Single Sourcing Building Modular Documentation
  103. bottitta (2003)
    Moving to single sourcing: Managing the effects of organizational changes
    Tech Commun
  104. carter (2003)
    The implications of single sourcing for writers and writing
    Tech Commun
  105. clark (2002)
    Rhetoric of present single-sourcing methodologies
    Proc 20th Annu Int Conf Comput Document
  106. spilka (2002)
    Reshaping Technical Communication New Directions and Challenges for the 21st Century
  107. eble (2003)
    Content vs. product: The effects of single sourcing on the teaching of technical communication
    Tech Commun
  108. gollner (2011) (0)
    Intelligent content in the green desert.
    The Content Philosopher
  109. Andersen (2014)
    Toward a more integrated view of technical communication
    Communication Design Quarterly
  110. kramer (2003)
    Single source in practice: IBM's SGML toolset and the writer as technologist, problem sol…
    Tech Commun
  111. bock (2010)
    Smart content in the enterprise: How next generation XML applications deliver new value t…
    The Gilbane Report
  112. rockley (2001)
    The impact of single sourcing and technology
    Tech Commun
  113. o'keefe (2012)
    Content Strategy 101 Transform Technical Content into a Critical Asset
  114. hackos (2014) (0)
    User-generated content: A study of content curation.
    Cent Inf Develop Manage Best Practices Newslett
  115. bailie (2007)
    Top ten mistakes in content management
    Intercom (Des Moines)
  116. bailie (2013)
    Content Strategy for Decision Makers Connecting the Dots between Business Brand and Benefits
  117. trippe (2005)
    Component content management in practice: Meeting the demands of the most complex content…
    The Gilbane Report
  118. (2010)
    The Compass Essential Reading About XML DITA Web 2 0
  119. abel (2012)
    What is dynamic publishing, anyway?
    The Dynamic Publisher
  120. bailie (2009) (0)
    Anticipating the impact of content convergence.
    MultiLingual
  121. pullman (2008)
    Content Management Bridging the Gap between Theory and Practice
  122. o'keefe (2011)
    The State of Structured Authoring
  123. gibbon (2014)
    The Language of Content Strategy
  124. andersen (2013) (0)
    Results of the 2012 best practices research needs survey.
    CIDM Inf Manage News
  125. burrows (0)
    Meeting our challenges: An opportunity for new habits?
    CIDM Best Practices Conf Monterey CA USA
  126. hackos (0)
    Thinking, slow and fast
    CIDM Best Practices Conf Monterey CA USA
  127. riley (2013)
    Telling the right story: Proving the business value of content
    Intercom (Des Moines)
  128. swisher (2012)
    Writing for global readiness: What technical writers need to know
    Tech Writer Today
  129. halvorson (2012)
    Content Strategy for the Web
  130. welchman (2015)
    Managing Chaos Digital Governance by Design
CrossRef global citation count: 34 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Pedagogy Apr 2024
    Contributors ↗
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism feminist rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy creative writing teacher development collaborative writing assessment technical communication professional writing grammar and mechanics literacy studies gender and writing literary studies book reviews editorial matter
  2. Pedagogy Apr 2022
    Contributors ↗
    rhetorical criticism writing pedagogy creative writing writing across the curriculum teacher development collaborative writing assessment writing program administration technical communication professional writing digital rhetoric literacy studies gender and writing disability studies literary studies book reviews editorial matter
  3. IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication Mar 2022
    Embodying Public Feminisms: Collaborative Intersectional Models for Engagement ↗
    Temptaous Mckoy; Cecilia D. Shelton; Carleigh Davis; Erin A. Frost
    rhetorical criticism genre theory african american rhetorics collaborative writing technical communication professional writing race and writing gender and writing body and rhetoric
  4. Pedagogy Jan 2022
    Contributors ↗
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis african american rhetorics decolonial rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy basic writing writing across the curriculum graduate education teacher development argument collaborative writing transfer assessment portfolios writing program administration writing centers peer tutoring technical communication professional writing archival research digital rhetoric social media grammar and mechanics literacy studies race and writing gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric community literacy literary studies editorial matter
  5. IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication Sep 2021
    Design Thinking in Technical Communication: Solving Problems Through Making and Collaboration: Jason C. K. Tham: [Book Review] ↗
    Dorcas Asenyeni Anabire
    genre theory writing pedagogy teacher development collaborative writing technical communication race and writing book reviews